points by beardyw 1 year ago Yesterday's identical post:https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40994901
dredmorbius 1 year ago With only three comments, that doesn't count as "significant discussion", which means that today's re-posting is not a dupe by HN standards:See "Are reposts ok?": <https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html>Recent-ish dang comment clarifying further: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37484775> beardyw 1 year ago Not sure pointing out another discussion is a problem. If I were to criticise the post it would be to say is it an HN topic? Might be more suitable on a music discussion. dredmorbius 1 year ago It's not a problem, nominally, but it is a problem if this leads others to believe that the submission does meet dupelicate criteria.If I note prior submissions (often because I'd seen the earlier submission in the "New" queue, I'll specifically note whether or not it's a dupe.
beardyw 1 year ago Not sure pointing out another discussion is a problem. If I were to criticise the post it would be to say is it an HN topic? Might be more suitable on a music discussion. dredmorbius 1 year ago It's not a problem, nominally, but it is a problem if this leads others to believe that the submission does meet dupelicate criteria.If I note prior submissions (often because I'd seen the earlier submission in the "New" queue, I'll specifically note whether or not it's a dupe.
dredmorbius 1 year ago It's not a problem, nominally, but it is a problem if this leads others to believe that the submission does meet dupelicate criteria.If I note prior submissions (often because I'd seen the earlier submission in the "New" queue, I'll specifically note whether or not it's a dupe.
With only three comments, that doesn't count as "significant discussion", which means that today's re-posting is not a dupe by HN standards:
See "Are reposts ok?": <https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html>
Recent-ish dang comment clarifying further: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37484775>
Not sure pointing out another discussion is a problem. If I were to criticise the post it would be to say is it an HN topic? Might be more suitable on a music discussion.
It's not a problem, nominally, but it is a problem if this leads others to believe that the submission does meet dupelicate criteria.
If I note prior submissions (often because I'd seen the earlier submission in the "New" queue, I'll specifically note whether or not it's a dupe.