by pfdietz 1 week ago

> 20TW is roughly current world marketed energy consumption. But, on Earth, solar power plants have a capacity factor around 20%, so you need 100TW of solar panels to produce those 20TW.

This confuses primary energy with work. 1 TWh of solar can displace multiple TWh of primary energy. This depends on details, of course; in some cases it makes sense to directly convert solar output resistively to heat even if that takes a second law loss.

kragen 1 week ago

This is a good point; in particular, electrification of transport will reduce the figure substantially, especially because car engines are usually less than 30% efficient. But electrical power is already about a third of the total, isn't it?

  • Retric 6 days ago

    No, 31,746.92 terawatt-hours (TWh) in 2025 / 365 / 24h = 3.6TW. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_electrici...

    3.6 / 20 = 18%.

    • kragen 6 days ago

      You're right, that's less than a fifth. Thank you.

      So, the other 82% of primary energy consumption could be reduced by about 60%, except for the part that's already used for heating (how much is that?), and by about 75% when it's being burned in the inefficient internal combustion engines commonly used in cars and the like.

      Ballparking, this seems like fueling the current economy purely with electricity, and counting "primary energy usage" as the output in the case of solar panels (rather than "the sunlight hitting them" as you advocated elsewhere, which is a defensible convention but not one anyone uses) would cut primary energy usage by about a third.

      • Retric 6 days ago

        > except for the part that's already used for heating

        Heat pumps are ~300% efficient on average across most of the globe outside of a few areas. Even just cooking with resistive heating uses less fuel because you’re not heating up air to supply oxygen to a fire.

        Also, reducing fossil fuel refining and transportation is a surprisingly large fraction of that primary energy supply with 40% of global shipping by weight being oil. Think of it this way if you’re buying 10 gallons of gasoline a week that’s 6.2 lb/g * 10 * 52 = 62 * 52= 3,200 lb a year in fuel ie the weight a car shipped from some oil field to a refinery then to you.

        • kragen 6 days ago

          You have some good points, but I think there are some flaws in them.

          Heat pumps are probably now economic only in niche scenarios, even at current PV module prices; they cost dramatically more than the solar panels they displace. And they're really only applicable to climate control, not to other applications of heat, such as cement kilns, electric arc furnaces, or baking bread. I do use one to heat my bedroom in winter, but I don't think they are really relevant to the future.

          It is true that electric cooking is more efficient, especially when the heat can be produced in close proximity to the food, as in induction stovetops, crockpots, and microwave ovens. I don't know how to size this, but I don't think it's very large.

          40% of global shipping by weight is fossil fuels, not just oil (https://billmckibben.substack.com/p/the-happiest-number-ive-...) but that's by weight, not energy consumption. The vast majority of fossil-fuel shipping is shipped by shipping ships, not by railroads, tractor-trailer trucks, stepvans, small boats, or personal cars, and, if I'm understanding https://unstats.un.org/unsd/energystats/pubs/documents/2026p... correctly, only 2.5% of the global total energy supply ("TES", the UN's term for world marketed energy consumption) is the bunker fuel that powers those ships. (I had guessed 3%.)

          So, completely eliminating fossil fuel shipping will save about 1% of total energy consumption.

          • Retric 6 days ago

            > I don't know how to size this, but I don't think it's very large.

            It covers every use case for high temperatures and more impactful the higher temperature you want. Melting iron using fossil fuels at 1,500 °C also means wasting high temperature exhaust air.

            • pfdietz 5 days ago

              It's quite common in such situations to use the outgoing hot gas to preheat incoming air. This kind of technology goes back more than a century. This cannot be 100% effective (entropy created in the process has to go somewhere) but can greatly reduce the energy needed.

              https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/engineering/cowper-stov...

              https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_preheater#Regenerative_air...

              https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regenerative_heat_exchanger

              • Retric 5 days ago

                Pre heating air is very much a thing, but it only buys you so much.

                Really high efficiency home furnaces require cooling the exhaust gasses low enough for water to condense but that low temperature heat isn’t particularly useful at a smelter where low relatively temperature waste heat is plentiful.

                There’s other issues like introducing drag which requires either a large chimney with hot exhaust gasses or fans to force airflow etc.

                In the end the only thing that matters for these calculations is relative efficiency where electricity wins by ~20% or so in the real world plus fuel lost in transit.

                • kragen 5 days ago

                  > that low temperature heat isn’t particularly useful at a smelter where low relatively temperature waste heat is plentiful.

                  I suggest you read through the links pfdietz provided, and understand them, because you are mistaken about this point. It is not a peripheral issue; it has been central to thermodynamic machinery since Stirling.

                  • Retric 5 days ago

                    Feel free to quote any part that actually disagrees with what I said.

                    Coal is the only fossil fuel with minimal hydrogen turning O2 into H20. Latent heat of vaporization for water is very high, but you can only extract that by cooling the exhaust gasses below its dew point. Preheating alone doesn’t let you extract that energy from exhaust gasses.

                    • kragen 4 days ago

                      If you're not going to read them, you'll just have to take my word for it. This isn't the kind of thing where quotes are going to help.

                • pfdietz 5 days ago

                  The better home tech analogy would be air-to-air heat exchangers. These exhaust air from inside a house, replacing it with a stream of outside air, and transfer almost all the difference in heat energy from one stream to the other.

                  • Retric 5 days ago

                    At home, air to air heat exchangers run into humidity issues. If it’s 100f at 98% humidity you don’t get even vaguely close to 70f 50% humidity by using cooler internal air to cool hot humid air.

                    • pfdietz 4 days ago

                      There are advanced ones that can transfer humidity as well.

                      • Retric 3 days ago

                        At home the benefit is non zero, but you still need extra energy for the kind of gap I am talking about.

                        Further for a furnace the transfer is zero sum, remove 1g of water from the exit stream move 1g to the input stream and now there’s an extra gram on the output stream canceling out the transfer.

                        More fundamentally, current numbers come from what is actually happening not what could in theory be done.

                        • pfdietz 3 days ago

                          If the thermodynamic states of the two gas streams are swapped then in the limit no extra energy is needed. If humidity is converted to some bound state and then back this is, ideally, completely reversible.

                          Now, in combustion the gas streams are not identical in composition and mass, so there is some unavoidable loss, but the efficiency gain can be very large. Recuperation had a huge effect on the efficiency of blast furnaces.

                          • kragen 1 day ago

                            Technically Cowper stoves are regenerators, not recuperators, but otherwise this is perfectly correct and very important.

            • kragen 5 days ago

              You may be computing Carnot efficiency backwards; heat pumps are less impactful for producing higher temperatures, not more. Also, there are practical difficulties with trying to build a heat pump that can function at several hundred degrees.

              Aside from pfdietz's good point about regenerators, resistively melting iron with electricity doesn't require any high-temperature exhaust air.

              • Retric 4 days ago

                The comparison was pure resistive heating.

                My point was people natural gas smelting is a long way from the 98% efficiency you see in high end home natural gas heaters. Latent heat of vaporization means it takes far less energy to warm the incoming air than you can extract from the exhaust.

                • kragen 4 days ago

                  I think you mean "far more", since if it were far less, you'd have a perpetual motion machine.

                  It doesn't.