ATPsynthase is amazing. I am constantly amazed that it actually looks like a motor, as well as being the endpoint of the complex system to produce ATP energy in a cell.
> Imagine a flashy spaceship lands in your backyard. The door opens and you are invited to investigate everything to see what you can learn. The technology is clearly millions of years beyond what we can make.
> This is biology.
IIRC one can see these things moving in the lab under a suitable microscope and track their path: the challenge is to show that the path they take indicates they expended energy/did work, and how. That depends on the molecular assembly/motion. The linked papers describe what that entails.
But, the link isn't recent. The people who worked on this left the group and the PI seems to have moved labs within Oxford. From the available info, I'm not sure if the research is still ongoing or not---maybe the problem of assembling larger molecular motors wasn't solved.
> many of the protein components of the flagellar motor exchange with spare parts in the rest of the cell, on a timescale of minutes, even while the motor is working
If you had the choice between flying in a plane powered by a couple of Rolls Royce Trent engines or a couple of these things, which would you choose? What if it was a thousand of these things?
Yeah, I was getting more at the Rolls Royce being engineered and based on science that we understand, while the molecular motor is "evolved" and something we can't really understand (at least without considerable effort, which would be pointless to undertake).
Made me think of vibe coded software and whatever other designs are likely to emerge from AI soon.
Related proteins that are just as wonderful:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ATP_synthase
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Type_III_secretion_system
ATPsynthase is amazing. I am constantly amazed that it actually looks like a motor, as well as being the endpoint of the complex system to produce ATP energy in a cell.
It's like a hydroelectric dam! The synthase is the turbine. The protons are the water flowing through it. The electrochemical gradient is gravity.
Incredible. Can't help but think of:
> Imagine a flashy spaceship lands in your backyard. The door opens and you are invited to investigate everything to see what you can learn. The technology is clearly millions of years beyond what we can make. > This is biology.
- https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/immune-system/
This does pose (but not for everyone) some rather fundamental questions about life and universe doesn't it?
Yes, "what process built this?"
I don’t think anything biology came up with is millions of years beyond us now. In 100 years you’ll be able to 3d print these.
There’s plenty of room at the bottom.
IIRC one can see these things moving in the lab under a suitable microscope and track their path: the challenge is to show that the path they take indicates they expended energy/did work, and how. That depends on the molecular assembly/motion. The linked papers describe what that entails.
But, the link isn't recent. The people who worked on this left the group and the PI seems to have moved labs within Oxford. From the available info, I'm not sure if the research is still ongoing or not---maybe the problem of assembling larger molecular motors wasn't solved.
Molecular motor videos are pretty popular as short-form video. Some good ones here: https://www.youtube.com/@iJEPStudio/videos
If someone wants to become instantly internet-famous they'll 3D-print working models of some of these molecular mechanisms.
My jaw fell on the ADN replication https://youtu.be/AVu8Kb1r5gU
Thanks for sharing.
Can someone explain why the mechanisms employed by these molecular motors don't scale?
> many of the protein components of the flagellar motor exchange with spare parts in the rest of the cell, on a timescale of minutes, even while the motor is working
There goes irreducible complexity.
If you had the choice between flying in a plane powered by a couple of Rolls Royce Trent engines or a couple of these things, which would you choose? What if it was a thousand of these things?
Try a few billion billion. These things are several orders of magnitude weaker than a jet engine.
Indeed, about 23 orders of magnitude
Yeah, I was getting more at the Rolls Royce being engineered and based on science that we understand, while the molecular motor is "evolved" and something we can't really understand (at least without considerable effort, which would be pointless to undertake).
Made me think of vibe coded software and whatever other designs are likely to emerge from AI soon.