ttd 9 hours ago

Looks very polished, congrats! I've been slowly working my way towards supporting C4 in Vexlio, since the interactive+layered view is nearly an exact fit for the interactivity model (https://vexlio.com/solutions/interactive-process-documentati... has a screencap).

One reason it's been lower on my list is that I haven't been able to get a handle on how much C4 is actually used in practice. Not necessarily the model itself, but the visual representation. Did you create this based on your own experience of using C4? I'd be curious for any anecdata you may have come across too.

viraptor 9 hours ago

What's people's general feeling about C4? I've tried it a few times, but then up just annoyed by the strict model - everything I actually want to show ends up being a custom dynamic + fighting the include/exclude system. At that point I'd rather do a custom diagram in excalidraw that actually communicates just the things I want... and accept it won't get updated automatically.

Does it work well as designed in some environments?

  • billyp-rva 8 hours ago

    In my opinion, most are better served sticking with concrete resources [0] rather than trying to map things to C4's abstractions. Today we have so many kinds of things (especially cloud resources) that are already named and people know what they are and what they are for. Adding C4 on top mostly just obscures them, I think.

    [0] https://www.ilograph.com/blog/posts/concrete-diagramming-mod...

  • aqula 4 hours ago

    I think maintaining diagrams is painful as it is, and doing so in a rigid template, even more so. I'm experimenting with generating C4 like diagrams directly from code. Would love to hear your thoughts - https://arcaide.foo

    • viraptor 2 hours ago

      Unfortunately auto-diagrams are often bad in my experience and I'm constantly commenting "I don't understand what it's trying to show me, can you simplify / rephrase / redo?" on documentation. I like things that make the creation process easier, but I gave up on generation. (without a clear guidance of the goal anyway)

anpat 10 hours ago

Thanks for making this, I have been needing and thinking a lot about making something similar.

  • oliveralbertini 9 hours ago

    Thanks! Yeah, there are quite a few paid solutions out there, but neither my employer nor I are willing to shell out for them :)

datadrivenangel 10 hours ago

Should be the link instead of the video, though the website is also painfully AI.

https://maplespire.ca/en/#open-source

  • bmitc 6 hours ago

    The entire thing screams AI, which doesn't give me hope. Also, we all have AI too, and we can just create the same thing.