by crossroadsguy 1 day ago

Why does everyone is completely discounting (or not mentioning) the possibility that Jensen was the spy? I am not even considering the "illegals" and deep sleeper agents like The Americans (as traditionally Russia is known to do this), but just a normal possibility – someone becoming/turning or being a spy. And if he knew what Ms. Huang was and was doing then doesn't that already make him one? Or is it because he is too limelighted to be a spy at all? Or is it his personality or something else, or the so called patriotism? I have really not heard this angle at all.

Though I must add that this thought first came to me when I was listening to a podcast and some author (who researched his life/him) mentioned how he came to USA as a teenager (even before his parents could come) and went to a Southern private (boarding?) school which was almost like a juvenile centre (that author's thoughts, not mine) and for someone who was one of the shortest boys there, barely spoke any English, looked anything but like a Southern white boy, he actually became one of the most popular students (and yes, that alludes to his genius or so indeed). And no, that author/podcast guest didn't even allude to him being a deep implant or so (to be fair). I just wondered about it. I am not even saying he is one (hell, I think he isn't – just "feelings"). I am just curious whether people/agencies/journalists checked this aspect and wrote off, or this was never checked.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oneida_Baptist_Institute in Kentucky.

nonethewiser 1 day ago

> Why does everyone is completely discounting (or not mentioning) the possibility that Jensen was the spy?

Because there is no evidence for it. And there is nothing to discount - I haven’t seen that suggested. Because there is no evidence for it.

If there is evidence then we should recognize it. But I havent seem any. Its not even clear if Alice Huang was a spy.

Synaesthesia 1 day ago

There's no confirmation that anyone is a spy here.

  • altcognito 1 day ago

    This is also not a court of law.

zelphirkalt 1 day ago

Yeah, this was also my thought somewhat. I keep thinking, that Jensen was probably completely fine with GPU being shipped to China, since he lobbied for it supposedly and he must have known what Megaspeed supposedly was doing. He probably didn't care, as long as it rakes in the moneys.

dsign 1 day ago

That's a bit far-fetched :-)

Also, how exactly can he be a spy? His company sells all over the world. His fiduciary duty to the shareholders is to do just that. When he doesn't sell to China, he is pissing me off as a shareholder. The right thing for him to do is to expatriate NVIDIA and himself. That he hasn't done it speaks of a man that values his adopted homeland more than he values the duties of his office. Shame on him.

  • pcbro141 1 day ago

    Even if he could move the company abroad, it would still be subject to US export control laws.

    https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII...

    Any chip made anywhere in the world using US origin software (such as design tools from Cadence or Synopsys) or US semiconductor manufacturing equipment falls under American export jurisdiction.

    Not easy to replace all your US staff, US software you rely on, US equipment in fabs you work with. Plus the political ramifications and potential sanctions as a consequence.

aurareturn 1 day ago

Holy shit. Now Jensen Huang is the spy.

Is Alice Huang a spy?[0]

- AG says no. (“no conclusions reached”).

- CIA says no. (“not yet convinced”).

- DNI says no (“not entirely accurate and over-torqued”).

- Ranking Democrat on House Intelligence (incoming Chairman) says no. (“today, at least, I don’t know”). This was immediately after he was briefed.

- Singaporean government came out and disputed WSJ's spy claims.[1]

But since Alice Huang is not confirmed to be a spy, Jensen Huang must be the a spy!

[0]https://x.com/DavidSacks/status/2121070881258504395

[1]https://x.com/brianchau57/status/2121465308368265231

  • dofm 1 day ago

    The claim has it seems always generally assumed she is a spy in the sense of an asset (willing or otherwise), rather than in the sense of an intelligence officer.

    None of the above uncertainty rules this broader interpretation out.

    She seems pretty certain to be a smuggler, though, and they are often compromised.

    • aurareturn 1 day ago

      An "asset"? What does that mean?

      A smuggler? Has it been proven?

      So the spy claims hold no merit and now we're just making shit up?

      • dofm 1 day ago

        “Asset” is a well-defined term in the context. It means someone (occasionally something) that is of direct value to the intelligence operation. Someone who has been turned, someone who is vulnerable to manipulation, someone who has some kind of sympathy for the operation and is providing information; a wide range of degrees of involvement from useful idiot all the way up to paid operative. (Indeed, assets don’t necessarily even have to understand that they are assets.)

        A smuggler? There is considerable evidence that there is a GPU-smuggling operation around Megaspeed that has seen GPUs not just “Singapore-washed” but also shipped to mainland China. Proof? Maybe the public will never get that information, because it is semi-sensitive. That would not be unusual. But if you do some reading it is hard to escape the notion that the most plausible explanation for Alice Huang is that she is making it easier for Chinese companies to get Nvidia GPUs, against the objective of the export controls: that is smuggling at some level.

        Nobody has ever insisted that the only explanation is that Alice Huang is a literal intelligence officer. They have only ever had evidence to support a strong belief that she has links to Chinese intelligence. There appears to have been enough merit for the State department to get into that.

        Exactly who is what to whom is never that simple or black-and-white in intelligence and counterintelligence; you are arguing on the basis that a kind of simple certainty has ever been suggested, when in fact we only really know that there was very significant concern about Alice Huang’s background and her closeness to Jensen Huang.

        Plus now it is out in the open, it’s not just counterintelligence, it’s international politics. There may be (e.g. in the run-up to a trilateral summit) good reasons to say in public “we’re not saying we’re certain she was a literal spy”.

        • aurareturn 1 day ago

          All I'm reading is just a bunch of speculation, not facts. It seems like you already made up your mind and you're trying to find plausible ways to fit your believes.

          If Alice Huang is proven to be just another business person who got close to Jensen Huang to secure business, you'll just make something else up.

          • dofm 1 day ago

            I am not making stuff up, I am describing what I have read. I am a random British person who is interested in the story, which has shades and degrees and nuances and intrigues. As such it doesn’t fucking matter whether I have made up my mind; I am of no consequence.

            I don’t really understand your obsessive need for this story to vindicate any individual, or why you are posting in such a campaigning way, arguing for a grand conspiracy theory when it looks more like this:

            A very rich person who runs the company that makes all the important GPUs is shagging around, and one of the people he is shagging is running a business that ships GPUs to China the long way round, which achieves something he himself has openly advocated for, but which happens to be against US law and suggests that he has, to some extent and with or without Lutnick and the Commerce department’s involvement been involved in a scheme to get around export controls (and perhaps a sort of unwritten export policy).

            Why can’t the explanation be that simple? Why do you seem to need it to be something else?

            • aurareturn 1 day ago

              Or how about the most likely scenario?

              Alice Huang isn't a spy. Jensen Huang isn't a spy (LOL). Nvidia did not do anything illegal.

              • dofm 1 day ago

                This is not the most likely scenario. It is not at all likely that Nvidia has done nothing wrong.

                ----

                My guesses… this is all hypotheticals but I think it is likely:

                - Alice Huang will turn out to be an intelligence asset.

                - Either way she is surely a smuggler, there are notable questions about her background, and Jensen Huang knew.

                - Jensen Huang is an idiot who could actually be at some risk of going to prison because of the risks to national security inherent in his behaviour, particularly if he was advised about it.

                - Tim Teter (Nvidia general counsel) is potentially in serious trouble too.

                - Howard Lutnick and Jeff Kessler are possibly in an Oliver North type situation; Bessent and Rubio will hang them out to dry and have been covering themselves since they found out.

                - Much more than just Megaspeed is implicated here — perhaps it will turn out that a quarter of the Asia Pacific sales of GPUs subsequently end up in mainland China or in the hands of wholly Chinese-controlled companies and more are leased by Chinese firms. (I am guessing at the size of this problem but I think it is a real problem for the export rules)

                - Trump knew and did nothing.

                - More evidence of Nvidia manipulating the GPU market will fall out of these inquiries.

                ----

                Now, I am a non-American who only uses open weights local LLMs (though purely coincidentally I don't currently use any Chinese ones), so I don't really care about the export rules or about "Singapore-washing", and I don't care if the Chinese get GPUs, really. I personally care more about whether Nvidia's sales practices are inflating a bubble that will do global economic damage.

                But I do think that what we are looking at here is potentially one of the biggest scandals in US industrial history. It absolutely could rival Iran-Contra in its long term impacts.

                It doesn't really matter much if you are rich and important and think laws are stupid or wrong, if you broke them and there's someone there to enforce them.

    • nonethewiser 1 day ago

      You say she was a "spy" in the sense of an "asset" and not as an "intelligence officer." What do you think that shows?

      Your own phrasing recognizes that an asset is a type of spy.

      The comment you are replying to says these different parties haven't concluded she was a "spy." Nothing depends on if she was recruited as an asset or was a planted intelligence officer.

      • dofm 1 day ago

        Well — an asset can be used for furthering spying, I guess. But they can just be, like, the lobby janitor who has serious gambling debts and is blackmailed into passing on what they overhear. Is the janitor a spy? Not in any sense that matters. They are assets; they have been suborned, but they are mostly sources.

        But "spies" as in spooks, actual trained employed intelligence officers or payrolled people actively seeking out intelligence, is a subset of this broader class of "asset".

        There is no clarity that Alice Huang is one of those or that the State department thought she was at that level, and I don't think that is what the reporting has shown so far. But there were concerns she is a significant asset.

        > The comment you are replying to says these different parties haven't concluded she was a "spy." Nothing depends on if she was recruited as an asset or was a planted intelligence officer.

        Right but the media are using the term quite colloquially. Nothing about government sources replying on the record "we can't prove she was a spy" exactly means "we don't think she was any kind of asset to Chinese intelligence".

  • crossroadsguy 1 day ago

    Ah, we haven't learnt anything from our Philbies, have we? ;-)

madaxe_again 1 day ago

Thats exactly what a spy would say to throw people off the trail. Perhaps we should fire you, and then investigate.

  • nonethewiser 1 day ago

    Exactly. I have no idea why people aren’t talking about this more.

BatteryMountain 1 day ago

I joked about this with a friend when the news broke, that everything we see in the media is the distraction and that he probably did something way more nefarious or was the spy all along. Or a calculated set of actions that needs to happen before December to avoid having their bubble popped.

numpad0 1 day ago

or maybe he represents the ROC after all.