SamBam 3 hours ago

This seems fine, and I say this as a teacher that is struggling with what to do about AI.

The course has an in person exam, which is graded. So the real point of homework is not to get a grade, it's too actually learn something.

Perversely, by making homework graded you are probably increasing the number of students who feel they need to use AI to get good grades.

Eliminating the grades means eliminating the fear of getting a bad grade, and so allows good students to actually use the homework to learn something.

If they don't take advantage of that, well, that's on them.

  • lumost 3 hours ago

    This is the way forward in my opinion. Pick learning objectives that reflect a world where AI can do most route work, Measure progress against these objectives in a manner where AI use does not matter.

    I'm in a course on video game design where one of the objectives is to learn the Unity IDE... which of course doesn't matter anymore. They could have picked the objective "Make a fun and engaging game" which would allow for arbitrary AI usage and require learning the rest of the course material on what makes a game fun/engaging/graphically interesting.

    • Silamoth 2 hours ago

      I’m sorry, but if you think learning to use a game engine isn’t relevant to designing and developing games, you are sorely mistaken. The existence of LLMs isn’t an excuse to not learn the fundamentals. That’s like saying learning Python or JavaScript or C++ doesn’t matter - completely absurd. At least, if you want to develop actual skill and not be reliant on LLM providers.

      • arecsu 1 hour ago

        Would like to know what you think about the immense amount of developers in the last couple of decades that despite not knowing Assembly, they have been able to ship stuff. Somebody would have thrown the same analogy in the name of fundamentals decades ago about assembly. Yet, here we are. Maybe I'm missing something. Maybe the definition of fundamental is fairly subjective and context dependant, much broader than what you might be suggesting really

        • Silamoth 39 minutes ago

          I would consider assembly fundamental knowledge of computer science. I would not consider assembly fundamental to all areas of software engineering. Assembly is fundamental to embedded programming. It is not fundamental to programming with a game engine.

          The fundamentals are context dependent. I don’t think anything in my comment suggested otherwise? But if you’re making a game in a game engine, knowing how to use that engine is fundamental. Not sure how you can really argue that.

      • lumost 31 minutes ago

        Learning to use the Unity Editor, which is full of tedium that is utterly decoupled from learning game engine fundamentals.

  • stefan_ 3 hours ago

    At the German university I studied at, long before AI, completing the homework successfully was sometimes just a prerequisite to be able to take the exam, and the exam counted for 100% of your grade. Some classes had homework but purely for your own independent learning, and there was just a weekly presentation by a TA going through it step by step.

  • stackskipton 3 hours ago

    Problem is, that can impact girls grades vs boys. Studies have shown that boys tend to do better on tests and girls do better on homework.

    https://archive.is/OYPvh#selection-1525.0-1525.510

    • deaux 3 hours ago

      Is that a problem? I'm sure there's another 100 variables. Maybe boys do better on 2 tests wherher girls do better on 3 tests. Or on a longer test vs a shorter one. Or open book vs closed book. Multiple choice vs open questions.

      So what makes this variable more important in this aspect? Or are you arguing for adjusting all of those factors based on girls vs boys? Then what if it's the other way around for ethnic majority vs ethnic minority?

      I write this because I don't understand your thinking at all and it'd be nice to gain some understanding.

      • stackskipton 1 hour ago

        My point is, Homework being bigger part of final grade helped with girls school scores. If you change that, it might impact and that might make certain people unhappy.

        As always, any change somewhere has impact on someone and understanding why homework got mixed turned into larger part of final grade was partially for that reason.

    • kalaksi 2 hours ago

      But other way around it's not a problem?

  • xboxnolifes 3 hours ago

    > Perversely, by making homework graded you are probably increasing the number of students who feel they need to use AI to get good grades.

    I don't think this is false, but it's not the first time homework hasn't been graded. Not that long ago I had professors say they made homework a minor portion (10%-ish) of the total, since not having it be graded left most students not doing it and grades clearly went down.

    It's very much a situation where poor incentives lie on both extremes.

    • crote 2 hours ago

      Heck, I can't recall ever having been graded on my homework!

      In my experience the fallout of not doing the homework was that you'd look like an idiot when called on during the communal walk-through session, or get a bad grade on the exam because you had no idea what was going on. Absolute worst-case scenario, a highschool teacher would get upset and call my parents, I guess?

      I was definitely graded on projects I had to do, but that was more "write a book review" assignments than "do exercise 1 through 15" homework.

    • dmurray 2 hours ago

      This would have helped me. I wouldn't have done the homework if it wasn't graded; if it was, I would do it and not cheat (and do better in the exam because of it). 10% seems like a sweet spot: enough to incentivize the lazy but not a big reward for cheating. You can tweak the grading further so anyone who made an effort is likely to get, say, 60%+, so the extra marks gained by cheaters are even less significant.

  • smath 1 hour ago

    I agree grading it in a way that affects the student's final grade might be a bad idea. But grading it to give feedback to the student on what they do / dont uncerstand is essential I think. How else do you encourage students to do the homework? I know its for their own learning (rather than to test them), but they don't necessarily understand this well. Without a clear deadline to submit homework, its likely to lie by the side and not get done.

jasonriddle 3 hours ago

I'm in a graduate program, as a student teacher studying to become a high school math teacher. I have a mentor in the classroom, and basically, we only grade the homework for the completion, because we assume the students are going to cheat, so it's only worth 10% of their grade. Even with AI, and just grading for completion, some are still too lazy to do the homework.

It's usually very clear who took the time to do the homework, because they either do well on the quizzes/tests or do poorly.

So, it's not impossible. Just put less weight towards the homework, and more weight towards quizzes/tests/projects/etc.

  • nickff 3 hours ago

    Why put any weight on the homework at all if those who are completing the homework are also doing well on the tests? It seems like the only people you are advantaging are those using AI (as compared to the 'lazy' students who don't turn anything at all).

    • jasonriddle 2 hours ago

      It's a fair point, it's not my policy but my mentor's. When I have my own classroom, I'll have to think about how to handle/grade homework.

    • OkayPhysicist 2 hours ago

      It's a small stick to encourage the students to act in their own interest and actually do it.

  • crote 2 hours ago

    If you already assume they are going to cheat, what's the point of even grading it?! If everyone is cheating and outsourcing it to AI, why bother assigning it? Why make it count towards the grade at all? It's just pointless busy-work at that point!

    Grading homework was already a stupid idea from the start, as the goal should be to ensure the pupils learn something - and learning is very much not the same as "provided proof of busy-work". If a student can get a genuine 100/100 on the test, who cares whether they are "too lazy" to do the homework - the goal of providing education has been achieved!

    If everyone is cheating, then you are literally grading them on something which has zero value beyond busy-work. You might as well ask them to sit in a corner for an hour counting grains of rice, and give them a grade for it...

    • BeetleB 2 hours ago

      > If you already assume they are going to cheat, what's the point of even grading it?! If everyone is cheating and outsourcing it to AI, why bother assigning it? Why make it count towards the grade at all? It's just pointless busy-work at that point!

      My undergrad (decades ago) was like this. Homework was assigned, but not collected or graded. The purpose of homework was to give you sample problems you should be able to solve, and you could go to office hours for help.

      In one engineering class, the professor would assign, but collect (and grade) them very randomly. It was max 10% of the grade. The idea was to ensure you're at least attempting the HW problems and not slacking off.

      • crote 1 hour ago

        Homework which isn't collected or graded is a completely different thing. The sole purpose of it is to practice, and it is completely up to the student whether they want to make use of that opportunity or not. The only incentive to do it is to get better at it, so there is zero reason to use AI. Want to do it a week later? Want to keep it all to practice before the exam? Want to not do it at all? That's all totally fine, and there's zero penalty for it.

        By adding a grade to it you change the nature of it from "get better through practice" to "hand in correct answers on time". Handing it in becomes what provides value to the student, as their grade suffers when they don't. And with today's AI it is indeed trivial to cheat and hard to prove that cheating happened, so one should assume that everyone will. Except for the handful of poor souls who try to be honest and will be punished for not cheating and handing in imperfect homework, of course.

    • argee 2 hours ago

      It's not pointless busywork. It's important work, punishing the naive students who don't yet understand that no good deed goes unpunished, and teaching them they should be cheating, otherwise they are doormats who worked harder for no reason.

      Not to mention homework remains one of the best ways to make an uneven playing field in education in general.

      • akramachamarei 2 hours ago

        > Not to mention homework remains one of the best ways to make an uneven playing field in education in general.

        How do you figure? My first thought was something along the lines of how affluence influences the fitness of the home for homework success, but I would expect the same effect on study in general. I would expect adding homework just makes the problem a bit more obvious. Likewise if the putative cause is affluence influencing the time and energy available for both study and homework.

        • argee 34 minutes ago

          > How do you figure?

          I'll leave finding arguments for that as your homework.

    • xp84 2 hours ago

      More than ever, education and especially college is not about imparting knowledge or skills. 20 years ago it was simply a filter intended to try to solve the problem of an oversupply of people for the number of jobs there are in the elite and upper-middle classes of work. Forcing teenagers to prove their worth through two successive four-year stints of high-stress hoop-jumping, and hiring only those who completed that successfully meant that you would be selecting the most tenacious people, who were better at problem-solving, time management, handling stress. That system stopped working years ago, though, because the bleakness of the post industrial economy meant that if you didn’t get into one of those careers that require college, and weren’t willing to learn a useful trade, you were well and truly screwed. So we basically removed all barriers that stopped anyone from getting a four-year degree by inventing more bullshit degrees, and accepting absolute mediocrity in undergrad. A degree is basically treated as a human right. So now finishing a four-year degree doesn’t necessarily even prove much tenacity or hard work. Just that you’ve been patient, I guess! And now we have even more of a shortage in the number of white-collar jobs compared to the number of college graduates!

      AI is in the process of making the absurdity of this system even more so. Now even a completely ignorant person can BS their way through a degree by cheating with AI, so, more degrees awarded, more money spent on college and more competitive admissions, meanwhile, the jobs that pay enough to justify those expensive degrees are even fewer, as AI eliminates entry-level white-collar jobs.

  • clusterhacks 2 hours ago

    Even pre-AI, my experience as an adjunct led me to believe there was a lot of cheating on homework and assignments.

    Individual programming projects for students wrecked me as a lecturer. The time investment for me for meetings, reviews, and understanding 30+ projects well enough to grade against a higher-level, abstract rubric just took too much time.

    Are you happy with the MS of Ed program you are in? I sometimes think about making the same transition to high school math teacher. I find that I do very well with engaged high school students (I volunteer in various ways at my local high school) but haven't quite found my footing with students who (maybe rationally) don't engage with the material.

    • jasonriddle 2 hours ago

      Yes, I do well with engaged students too. I haven't found out how to manage students who don't stay engaged, they all have some sort of hidden trauma, maybe someone told them they were bad at math (more mild form of trauma), to more extreme forms of trauma related to family relationships and the such. It feels like being a teacher is learning now to support the students that have been through the trauma, and how to create a safe space in the classroom (so they feel okay saying they don't know something and are okay with mistaking mistakes), which isn't easy and I'm still learning how to do this.

  • ibejoeb 2 hours ago

    This has always bugged me. When did we decide that homework ought to be graded anyway? The objective of formal courses is for the student to demonstrate proficiency. "Homework" is just handy tips for students to guide studying. It's not the study process that is being evaluated. If you're grading homework, you're just administering an exam off premises, and that has always had the same a problem as we see here.

    Do it or don't do it. Maybe you don't need it. Maybe your parents insist, and because you're a child, that's the way it goes. But unless someone is there guiding this very specific, prescribed study method, it should be immaterial to the ultimate assessment.

    It's absurd that, at a university level, especially one like caltech, there is graded homework. If you pay for a course and then can't be bothered to get anything from it, so be it. This is nuts.

Silamoth 2 hours ago

I’ve always thought the obsession with grading homework was weird. Homework is your chance to practice. It’s totally normal and expected that you’ll make mistakes - so why are students’ final grades being penalized because they made mistakes during practice?

Don’t get me wrong, homework should still be marked for feedback. After all, that’s how you learn what you were doing wrong and prepare for an exam. But students shouldn’t be stressing over correctness in homework. If they do well on exams and projects, that should be sufficient to get a good grade. A student bombing the homework, learning from their mistakes, and doing well on the exam is a good outcome, not one we should punish by factoring homework correctness into a final course grade.

  • dieselgate 2 hours ago

    My high school chemistry teacher only graded homework if a student received less than 90.00% on a test. I think this worked well and is an appropriate happy medium—even the best students still did the homework and wanted it to be correct.

    Edit: people can be a bit hard nosed about “grading homework is dumb” but I was the kind of student where I’d hope homework scores would help raise my grade

  • robcohen 2 hours ago

    The point of grading homework was just a way to disincentivize students from hurting themselves by not preparing. If it's not graded, then why not bomb it and then cram before the exam? Students tend to be bad at estimating how much they can get done.

    This is the ostensible reason, but really it's just lazy instructors trying to ensure they don't look like they are doing a poor job preparing their students when the students fail.

    Here's a question: why don't more schools offer credit for "course challenge" tests, where the student just takes the final exam? If a student has the knowledge, why not let them get credit? Is the course evaluative, or is it more about the journey.

    • janalsncm 2 hours ago

      > then why not bomb it and then cram before the exam?

      I’ve been in classes where homework was optional. I tried not doing the homework. It didn’t work out well for me, but maybe it will for other, smarter people.

      Aside from practicing, homework is a chance to figure out that you don’t actually understand the material as well as you thought. A lot better to find out before the test than during it.

    • xp84 2 hours ago

      The following would be an extremely unpopular take in some forums, though maybe not as much here:

      They generally don’t allow you to just get credit by taking the final because a lot of people think school should be “fair” - meaning that students who already learned the stuff independently, or just easily intuit things like math, should have to sit and grind through the full semester(s) of lectures, practice, and homework the same as everyone else, because it “wouldn’t be fair” to give them a pass “just” because they already know the material.

      Basically, they think a degree should serve as a kind of Proof of Work, rather than a proof of knowledge. Probably because it plays to a broader audience. The pitch of education, and especially higher education in the last 30 years, is that literally anybody can and should achieve greatness academically, and that all it takes is enough hard work. If we allowed some people to achieve even a high school diploma or bachelors degree without hard work, the people who do have to work very hard might conclude that their efforts and their six figures of money might be better spent on something besides college.

    • eikenberry 2 hours ago

      > The point of grading homework was just a way to disincentivize students from hurting themselves by not preparing. If it's not graded, then why not bomb it and then cram before the exam? Students tend to be bad at estimating how much they can get done.

      I thought the research pretty much showed that the best way to facilitate learning is to have weekly (frequent) quizzes over the material just covered. This would also serve your purpose as the students would be tested as they went.

    • aldonius 2 hours ago

      > The point of grading homework was just a way to disincentivize students from hurting themselves by not preparing.

      I understand you disagree with this perspective, but in my tutoring experience, I think this is fundamentally correct! "What gets measured gets managed" and all that.

      Anything in a course which doesn't have a direct impact on your grade (either through marks or pass/fail mechanism) is optional.

    • Silamoth 2 hours ago

      The incentive to do homework is to learn the material and succeed on the exam. Cramming is not generally an effective technique (especially if there are regularly spaced quizzes). And if the homework isn’t necessary to succeed on quizzes and exams, then why make students do it in the first place?

      Regarding the “course challenge” tests, I think it depends on the class. You’ll notice my original comment mentioned not just exams but projects. This was pretty engineering-focused, but it can expanded to include labs, research papers, and essays in other fields. These are an integral part of a lot of classes, so credit by exam doesn’t suffice. Maybe credit by exam + applicable project in some cases would work. But that can’t really replace a biology lab.

      For other courses, though, I’m totally on board. If you can pass the final for a math class, you should get credit without needing to do any of the busywork.

my002 3 hours ago

This isn't really new. Back when I did my undegrad (well before the AI days), it was pretty common to have math problem sets not be graded, especially in first-year classes.

  • abirch 3 hours ago

    Tests and quizzes are the best way. Essays were good, but now are dead.

    • goda90 3 hours ago

      Essays that are hand written in a classroom setting without access to computers would still work. Especially if the topic is only vaguely given beforehand so there's no chance of having AI write one and then memorizing it.

      • abirch 3 hours ago

        I agree with what you're saying. I would consider that a test. But, this is semantics.

        I meant larger essays. Something that take weeks and multiple edits. I don't think I ever did a 180 from when I started to where I ended in an essay like this, but I definitely did some 135s.

tygon 3 hours ago

A key aspect here that the author says: They can use AI to do the homework, but unless they know the material, that does not help them pass the exams. Something like math will likely always have a requirement to demonstrate competency in something akin to a proctored exam. The dedicated students will want to learn. The ones that are not dedicated? Well, the AI does not help them much if the exam is weighted properly toward the grade.

Kuyawa 1 hour ago

Eliminate homework once and for all, it's worthless. Increase e-tests in the classroom, auto evaluated, showing results at the end, just like we do in online courses. Adapt to the new world. Make your life easier

sempron64 3 hours ago

Homework should receive a nominal portion of the grade (~10%) to encourage students to do it and not be blindsided by course difficulty.

ramblurr 2 hours ago

This article ended right as I started getting interested. What was I supposed to take away from it?

WarmWash 3 hours ago

What does the future look like?

There are people reading the writing on the wall, people pretending not to see the writing on the wall, and because things are moving so fast, people who are unaware that anything has even been written on the wall.

  • tygon 3 hours ago

    In many ways, this feels like another great "how do we adapt to every kid having a computer at home?" moment for education. Education will adapt. It will likely just be a rocky inconsistent process.

  • doublerabbit 3 hours ago

    Every morning you're given a hexagon coin. You place this coin in your mouth. To hard to chomp so you have to suck; each layer delivering bio-chemicals required for you survive.

    You enter a shower like cubicle and a program executes dependent on what curriculum you chose. You blink thrice; warping you to the Information Store where you'll visit each day until you pass 100% on the exam.

    After achieving the pass you're then enrolled in to a knowledge enrichment program where a data fork siphons your brain in to the veins of the machinery. Your body is then excused to the body masher and reprocessed for the next set of educates.

  • throwawaypty 3 hours ago

    Complex systems won't survive the competency crisis.

dragthor 2 hours ago

How does the professor know again?

ahsgqwr 2 hours ago

So AI makes everything worse yet we still allow it. And academics are silent because they want funding from the perpetrators.

ActorNightly 2 hours ago

Education in general needs to be redone.

AI has highlighted the fact that education skips a lot of the fundamentals, often focusing on reciting things that you are supposed to memorize and not teaching how to reason for one self.

BeetleB 2 hours ago

In my undergrad, almost all the math courses had no required HW. They'd assign it, but you wouldn't turn it in. You'd come to office hours for help on the HW, or ask in class (they'd often dedicate the first 10-15 minutes of each lecture to Q&A).

It was awesome for people like me. No time wasted on neatly presented HWs. I'd do it quickly, verify the answers, and study for the exams.

The flip side was there were many exams (you don't want your grade catered if you do poorly in one exam). A course like calculus could have 4-5 "midterms", and then the final. Often, they'd drop your lowest midterm score so you're allowed one bad day.