My kids (16 and 13) both attend schools that recently implemented phone bans and they love it, somewhat surprisingly. They've commented on how one of their favorite things about school is actually the social aspect. Before the ban, at lunch or study halls or recess, kids would just be on their phones and now they're laughing and goofing off, as kids should be doing.
Bonkers to me that we ever allowed this.
Oh, and for context, the kids are allowed to go to the office and check in on a message or send a text (e.g., soccer practice is canceled due to rain, can you pick me up at 4?) during any non-class period so it's still easy to communicate.
You don't know what you have until you don't have it. This generation knows what it's like with phones because they experienced school with phones. The next generation who grows up with the phone ban will probably think it's pretty stupid, because they don't know what it was like without it. Then they'll repeal it again and go through the same cycle.
My older son (12) has his phone on my desk, and I unlock it for him when he wants it. Tried many times to give him full access, only to find out the phone usage skyrocketed to several hours a day.
When they go on a school trip, he's usually the only one without a phone and watches others glued to their screens, even when they have free time to run in a park.
Now, finally, the school purchased a box where kids lock their phones in at the start of the day and recover them at the end. They seem to enjoy it as well.
Of course, he would want to have a phone like other kids. On the train, he usually finds someone else to talk to or reads a book. Last trip he's talked to some girls which he otherwise wouldn't if he'd have a phone. At times, he gets frustrated, sometimes angry, but I try to talk him out of it, which sometimes works, sometimes it doesn't.
We just don't give our daughter (11) a phone. She has a smart watch that can text us and a few other whitelisted phone numbers (or call them). I don't think middle school kids need an actual phone.
A little off-topic for schools, but honestly, I was always shocked by the amount of lost productivity to phones in the white-collar workplace. I worked in a cube farm, and walking around nearly everyone at their desk was looking at their phone at any given time. I can guarantee you that, most of the time, what they were looking at wasn't work related, or at best maybe it was related in a peripheral way (stock prices, industry gossip, etc.)
The "attention tax" that is paid to a handful of firms in Silicon Valley is really unbelievable.
That's wild. In my workplace, I rarely see that. If it's that visible, how come they aren't reprimanded for it? I'd think excessive phone-use would affect how much they get done too (in a visible way).
It's not just productivity. It alters the workplace socially, typically in negative ways. Rather than getting to know one's colleagues and accept them for who they are, animosity flourishes over trivial things. (I'm not claiming that workplaces were anywhere near perfect before cell phones, you still had jerks and gossiping cliques. But a lot of the time I'm like, "pull your nose away from the phone and get to know them, you may actually like them.)
Granted, I have worked in places where the only convenient social contact you have is with people within a 1 km radius. So you either got to know the people you worked with, isolated yourself, were paying hefty long-distance bills, or were burning your paycheques to fly to the nearest city every weekend.
I don't understand when it become allowed honestly. Like when I was at school, phones were never allowed. If a teacher saw one they'd confiscate it and your parents would have to come and collect it.
That was before the absolute worst addictive dark patterns etc. Which means that someone looked at the world after that point and said "yeah actually, phones are ok now" which baffles me
My recollection was the vocal complaints about banning phones in classes was from people who were concerned that their kid needed a phone to call for help if Columbine happened. This was 20 years ago before smartphones.
Today's parents are the kids who were raised to never talk to strangers (for "safety") and so are largely also extremely adverse to that sort of "call a stranger" option.
I am still absolutely perplexed and bamboozled by the actual real fact that there are parents texting their children at school, during classes, to check how they are doing on a daily basis.
Which is frankly bonkers on its own. Kids should know to call 911 first if they believe they are in a life threatening situation. Relaying information back through a parent who’s not on location is not ideal
The last thing emergency services need during a calamity is a horde of random people calling them about the thing theyre already aware of.
I got emergency response training from my university when I was on the board of an association and one of the big things they told us was, call the university emergency number rather than 112 because we (the university) are in more direct contact with emergency services, have well thought out calamity plans, a better overview of things like open buildings and where people are, cameras, etc.
We really don't hate the media enough. An extremely rare occurrence that gets boosted whenever one occurs has convinced every parent in America it's happening everywhere, constantly, and thus we need to compromise the education of every student in the school to work around it.
Might as well leave your kid home at that point, iPad in hand. Even less ""risk"" when they were never going to learn anything at school anyway if they are allowed access to devices.
please, the US propaganda is strong here. That is the only country in the world where guns are so normalised that parents are legitimately worried about a random person shooting their kids in a school. Wikpiedia has multiple pages of school shootings in the US, so many that they have been grouped by decade. Five people were killed just a month back. In 2025, 71 school shootings happened. That is absolutely insane.
Seriously, take a good, long, hard, look at your usage of the term "extremely rare".
You're more likely to die being driven to school than you are in a school shooting. Of those 71 - how many were targeted gang on gang violence?
With over 100,000 schools - school shootings, as common as they are when compared to other countries, still classify as an "extremely rare event".
To compare it against other common concerns. You should be more worried about your child drowning than them going through a school shooting and more worried about them choking on their school lunch every day than them dying in a school shooting.
That parents worry about it and whether parents should be worrying about it are two different things.
The point in question is whether allowing children to have phones in schools is a vital need so that they can communicate with their parents during shootings, not whether guns are a problem in the U.S. I would say definitely no to the former and definitely yes to the latter.
26 school shootings have occurred in 2026 alone as of Oct 16. [1] That's not extremely rare to me. Extremely rare are the typical things Republicans campaign on, like widespread voter fraud or schools performing sex change operations.
> has convinced every parent in America it's happening everywhere,
Schools have active shooter drills. This has, in fact, saved lives. It's not something that doesn't happen.
I mean, it's happening in most states. Just not all the time.
But no, blame the media instead of blaming the shooters and the government that doesn't do anything to prevent it even when it knows how.
If you look at the actual underlying data [0] most of these school shootings are escalations of fights, especially at football games. These are not what most people think of when they think of 'school shootings', where someone is rampaging through the halls executing everyone they see.
Yeah from 2000-2025, there have been 35 "active shooter" type school shootings. There were roughly 30 "school shootings" per year between 1992 and 1999. They dropped to about 15 per year until 2020 when the number spiked back up to the 30 range where we are now
The USA is big, but 415 deaths in 405 shootings in 2026 is not exactly "rare" to justify kids having a phone. I don't totally disagree with your though. It's the same kind of slippery slope that leads to everyone having a massive truck to protect themselves.
>There's about 250-350 school shootings a year in the US. More than 1 a day
There's almost 1000 civil aviation accidents per year in the US, so 3x more than school shootings, yet most people don't go on a plane thinking this is something that will surely happen to them every time they board.
So yeah, the way media handles accidents has a huge impact on how gen-pop perceives threats.
Remember, the point of the media is to ragebait and fearmonger you to drive views and engagement, not to educate you. For education, you'll have to read books and papers.
>250-300 school shootings a year still seems crazy.
When you factor in US guns/capita, easy access to firearms over there compared to anywhere else in the world, prevalence of mental illnesses, drug use, bullying, average crime rates in the area etc, it's not actually that much. Plus if you start to deep dive, highest chances of shootings tend to be clustered into a few hotspot areas, that if you avoid, then chances of school shooting drop to zero.
For Americans it might also seem crazy that people in the UK have 800–1,200+ times[1] the chance of getting stabbed than US children getting shot, and at how many people in UK get arrested for online speech that would be protected under the first amendment in the US, so it's never apples to apples comparisons between countries, as everything differs.
[1]
US school shooting rates: 0.07–0.1 per 100,000 people
UK knife stabbing rates: 80–90 per 100,000 people
> For Americans it might also seem crazy how many people in UK get arrested for online speech
I mean, I would agree that this a problem! Still, I'd rather be arrested (most of these people are never actually charged with anything) than my children be shot.
>most of these people are never actually charged with anything
Because as they say, "The Process Is the Punishment".
>I'd rather be arrested
I'd rather not, since it's something that can be avoided, by not having a government that treats 1984 as a model. But you can't really control if someone one day decides to stab or shoot you the same way you can't control if you get hit by lightning or by a drunk driver.
>than my children be shot
Most american school children will never be shot regardless of what they do. But the chance of speech arrest in the UK depends on what you say to who.
The planes most people fly on are extremely safe. You're safer on one of those than you are in your own shower. The average number of airliner crashes per year in the US over the past decade is 0.1. The figure you quoted includes small planes, which are orders of magnitude more dangerous, especially small planes operated by hobby pilots. As a hobby pilot myself, I'd say that if you get in a plane like that without at least making sure your life insurance is paid up, you're fooling yourself. And most people do think small planes are kind of dangerous (and rightfully so).
Bad example aside, this is certainly a real phenomenon. It's not about ragebait or fearmongering. Those certainly don't help, but even news that deliberately avoids those and only tries to inform will suffer from it. News is, by definition, unusual. The more unusual it is, the more news it is. A fatal car crash might get a one-sentence mention in the local media. A business jet crash makes national headlines. A fatal airliner crash makes international headlines for months. That can easily form an upside-down impression of their frequency if folks aren't thinking about how news works.
Quick search reports that just commercial airline incidents are responsible for 857 deaths since 2000 while school shooting deaths total 220. So the point stands especially if you tried to account for more hours spent in school than on a commercial airliner. Per hour your airliner is probably orders of magnitude more likely to crash and kill you than a student is likely to die in a shooting.
Yes, it is extremely rare. As a comparison, the US has about 40,000 deaths from car crashes per year. About 110 deaths per day. Your kid's risk of dying on the drive to school is 10,000% higher than from being shot during the day.
Also, the school shooting statistics grossly misrepresent the real risk for the average family, because distribution is extremely biased towards violence that happens in a tiny number of high schools with high crime, drug and gang problems.
Few things are as emotionally overwhelming as the idea of your child being killed, so people react based on how strongly they feel about the issue, not by rationally assessing the real risk. A Columbine-style random mass shooter is like being afraid of a shark attack at the beach - it strikes terror into people, but it's not factually in the top hundred or thousand things you should rationally be worried about.
> Extremely rare? Not in the US. There's about 250-350 school shootings a year in the US. More than 1 a day
Where are you getting this data. I think that's way off. [0] Says 268 since 2018, where a school shooting is any shooting on school property, whether during school hours or not.
The data on school shootings is very inconsistent. In most of the sources, a shooting between gangs that happens on a weekend at 2am that happens to be in school grounds is reported as a school shooting. So is any other murder between anyone on campus including staff, etc, even if they're not "mass" or "random" killings. Even suicide is often counted in these lists.
The closest analog we have for "person goes into a school while it's in session to kill people at random" is the FBI's list of "active shooter" incidents, and only some of those are counted as "Mass killings", and the data there says we've has as little as 3 (in 2024) and as many as 15 (in 2023) per year in the past 5 years: https://usafacts.org/articles/what-is-considered-a-mass-shoo...
And that 3-15 number is all mass killings, not just in schools (I don't know how many of those were in schools, but we could stipulate maybe 1 in 3?)
So, the 250-350 number is a couple of orders of magnitude higher than the type of school shootings parents are actually worried about when it comes to needing to text them during the day.
In 2025 there were 18 incidents where someone was injured with a firearm on school grounds and 6 of those happened during school hours. In total three students were murdered across two separate school shootings.
If ‘school shooting’ statistics are anything like other gun violence statistics, the vast majority of those are inner city gang activity in the vague vicinity of a public school, not Columbine copycats.
Not an American, but have family living there. In two separate occasions, my nephews were in a lockdown because of a potential shooter in the area. The problem is, the hoaxes, bomb threats and etc. do not contribute to the statistics, but they make everything much worse.
I'm very sorry to say this, but I have no idea how you guys live like that.
> I'm very sorry to say this, but I have no idea how you guys live like that.
Unrelated to the topic, but keep this in mind when you see or read any news coming out of the U.S. There is no war on U.S. soil, so it's not a literal war zone, but the population has been living in a similar state of heightened arousal perpetually since Sept. 11, 2001. Everyone's brain has been paralyzed with fight-or-flight since then. Constant state of being afraid and on edge, fed and amplified by the media and the politicians (who are all victims of it as well, to some degree). You can't make rational decisions when in constant panic. It becomes a feedback loop of panic and overreaction, over-correction, and irrational actions causing more fear and paranoia- some justified, some not. I truly believe this explains a lot of what has happened to the country in the last decades.
That's a great description of the first few years after 9/11. But now, bollocks. Sure, there are always-online people that are like this, but not your average Joe on the street, at least where I live.
The US has anything around 250-350 shootings a year (I wonder where the spike during covid comes from?!) [1]. The entirety of Europe including the European parts of Russia and Turkey struggles to reach 10 incidents a year [2], with quite a few of them being barely relevant (accidental discharge, mafia drive-by gone bad). Europe is about the same size as the US and has about double the population, so the risk per person and year to experience a shooting is orders of magnitude more large than in the US.
On top of that, gun violence and accidents are the top killer for children and young adolescents in the US [3].
You don't have a problem with the media, you have a problem with guns. And with "you" I mean "Americans as a whole", because Switzerland and Czechia (the countries with the most permissive firearms regulations and similar ownership rates to the US) don't have school shootings being a thing.
This line got brought up constantly at a local school board meeting when a phone policy was being drafted (And is brought up by parents to admin when their children are reprimanded for phone use)
It appears to be either:
A. An excuse to get their kid out of trouble for scrolling TikTok & Reels during class
B. A weak attempt to provide a socially-justifiable reason for the parent’s general anxiety (constantly texting their kid, watching their precise location, using Life360 to see their messages with peers and fine-grained activity)
C. A futile effort to exercise control over a hypothetical situation where the parent is stripped of control. What are you going to do if you get a text saying “there’s a shooter in the school”? Call the police? The faculty all have phones and are doing the same. Text them back saying “okay I love you”?
C. In Uvalde parents got their kids out of the school while the police stood around and did nothing. But yes, being able to say "I love you" means something.
A horrible failure by police to do their job. The police also actively restrained and handcuffed parents who were trying to get in to the school.
Taking a broader look at the situation, kids being rescued in heroic efforts by parents when police are actively not doing their job or making a situation worse, the solution to this is probably not unregulated phone access for children during school hours.
I've gone through a version of this as a parent. One afternoon, I received a phone call from my son as he and his class were fleeing into the woods behind his school due to shots fired on the campus. As I drove the 30 minutes to an area near his school (not to the school, I didn't want to be in the way or in danger) and was passed by a constant stream of police vehicles, the only thing keeping me sane was the occasional message from my son. He and dozens of schoolmates made it to a neighborhood near the school where people that were home took them in, fed them, and helped them feel safe.
As it turned out, the actual issue was a hoax call about a student with a gun and an accidental gun misfire by an investigating police officer leading to a "shots fired" emergency.
All that said, I still think phones in school is a net negative for the kids. It's a massive distraction.
Our school district has had a number of similar “false alarms” in the last few years. Usually about once season.
Students will notice something concerning (an unidentified object in someone’s backpack, a threatening comment online by a peer, a rumor, etc) and text their parents instead of reporting it to an adult at the school who could investigate.
The parents (not knowing what else to do since they are not in the school) call police, tell other parents, post on social media. Leading to a wave of parents calling the front office and rushing to pick up their kids from class early.
That's a comfort thing rather than a safety thing. In a version of that story where he didn't have a phone, the eventual outcome would have been the same.
The actual safety argument is really thin. You'd need a situation where the adults are out of contact, the kids are in a position to use their phones, they aren't in a position to use a wall phone or find a friendly adult, and somehow that communication is critical to their survival. I'm not sure this ever happens, even rarely.
>accidental gun misfire by an investigating police officer leading to a "shots fired" emergency
Cops are jokes, man. They should be required to have a 4-year degree and pass military style firearms training, not whatever gobbledygook is happening at the academies.
Parents want to text their kids during the school day in places where this is not a concern. You only need a few sufficiently needy or neurotic parents to get the schools to relax policies (which is also why legislation to ban phones helps even if schools ‘should’ all have bans anyway: they get to say that their hands are forced if parents complain)
I've heard the rise of safety-ism and anxiety can be linked to the missing children photos on the back of milk jugs in the 70s. Also throw in media streaming national news instead of local news and you get a distorted idea of the dangers in your local community.
Maybe the terrorism and other turmoil in the 70s sunk into the generational subconscious and also contributes to the modern anxiety.
Anyway, parents (among others) are anxious and can be influenced/manipulated by playing into those fears
Today's parents of school-aged kids largely weren't even born in the 70s, so milk jug thing probably isn't true. (I'm about to turn 50, born in '77, if I had a kid at 30, they'd be 20 and out of school).
But, the national media, with it's need to get views/clicks/engagement, pushes a steady stream of outrage-porn, doom-porn, anxiety-porn, whatever you want to call it. And I suspect that doesn't help anybody.
> parents texting their children at school, during classes, to check how they are doing on a daily basis.
That's the least surprising part, to me. The immediately severely addictive nature of The Devil's Whispering Obsidian Mirror of Everlasting Distraction is more of a "why didn't the teachers ban it sooner?" thing than a "why might parents who have the same addiction, prefer using their Endless Scroll Distraction Oblong to talk to their kids than spend another minute doing whatever boring job the economy forced upon them?"
15 years ago, when my then-girlfriend was phoning me in the middle of the work day, it was surprising; but then, I am a massive introvert*, and by the power of the Typical Mind Fallacy** the idea of people wanting to just hang out with me all day was a thing I had to learn rather than it just being my expectation the whole time.
We're a social species. Checking in on each other is the norm. Parents on their kids, moreso. I wish now my parents had been more like that than they were, though I finished school at basically the same year 84x48 black and white 2G phones got affordable: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nokia_8210
But what's the root cause analysis? Big tech infesting our society with social media addiction so that they can personally profit from it.
Everyone who builds these products and profits from doing so is responsible for this.
So what is the solution? It seems to me that we should look at what was done to the tobacco companies in the previous century. Regulate these companies and fine them for the damage that they've intentionally caused to society.
Imagine how much better off we’d be, with capacity to nimbly and efficiently both establish new regulations and repeal existing ones. We do the opposite, make it difficult to regulate and difficult to deregulate. Much commerce, especially tech, depends upon the lack of regulatory agility, especially since it often allows the industry to supply the agility when needed by writing the regulations themselves, or guiding via lobby.
Unfortunately, parents now are very worried about school shootings. That just wasn't a concern until the last two or three generations (the Columbine shooting happened when millennials were in grade school).
Nope, 2023 was a record year for the number of school shootings. And the overall trend line continues to go up, with increased lethality per shooting as well.
There were 21 people killed in 2023 from school shootings.
This is fewer than "deaths in a hot car" (1/2), "familial homicide" (1/10), and "deaths from traffic" (1/50). Cancer, suicide, and (inferential from various studies) obesity all outrank it.
As I recall from the last time I dug this up, this is fewer deaths than "people falling off of their roof" and lower than the annualized rate of fatal lightning strikes (2006-2025).
Strange then that none of those drive policy, and we instead focus on a thing that is astonishingly unlikely to occur.
- Spend finite resources where they will have more, rather than less, impact
- Diminishing returns can mean that reducing the prevalence of an outcome from 1% to 0.01% is less expensive than reducing it from 0.01% to 0.005%
- That an outcome is tragic does not intrinsically mean "something must be done". Sometimes all possible "somethings" carry costs that outweigh the benefit
In this context, the "something" that is proposed is "bringing phones into school" which has demonstrably
- not reduced shooting incidence
- Nor reduced its harm
- increased antisocial behavior and depression
- Reduced school performance outcomes
So "moving on" would have been better than what happened in this case, yes.
This seems to be true. Depending on how you define each.
Speaking very roughly, a random person is more likely to be hospitalized due to covid than to be even at a school while a gun is fired there.
CDC estimates that this week alone there will be 5100 covid hospitalizations, while Everytown (cited below by robby_w_g) tallied 107 incidents of gunfire at school for the entire year-to-date.
As if texting your mom while a shooter is running loose in the building would change anything. Come on, let's be serious, parents cannot help in that situation.
Kids don't need to have their phones on them during class "for safety". On the way to and from school, sure, but once they're at school, stow them somewhere.
Parents seem worried about kids too here in the UK where we don't have school shootings. I think everyone is just so used to a world where we have constant contact with anyone at all times.
School shootings aren't a concern. Just picking a random year from google-- there were 21 school shooting deaths in 2023.
Compare with other causes of death for kids
- 29 from vehicular heatstroke
- ~300 (1/100k) familial homicides
- 1014 traffic fatalities
Even if it were a concern having a phone in such a scenario may make for good hollywood, but is terrible from a safety viewpoint. The last thing you want during a lockdown is phones clogging the network and ringing as kids try to hide.
Parent's aren't worried about school shootings because they're mathematically a concern, parents are worried because they're emotionally terrifying. People are bad at evaluating risk, and you can't solve that problem by just pointing at some numbers.
Policy decisions should definitely be based on statistics and not feelings though, and "pointing at some numbers" is a great way to structure a disagreement about policy.
Arguing in bad faith is fun! But you are right: We should allow an entire generation of kids to suffer from phone-induced brainrot so that their parents don't have to worry about school shootings.
School boards are elected, and highest turnout for those is going to be among parents. If a majority of parents have a concern then the school board has to listen if they want to keep their position.
Sometimes feelings turn into statistics (eg anxiety, depression, etc). You can't always just tell people to walk it off. Sometimes you can, but sometimes it absolutely has to actually be handled (gun control).
How is this inhumane? Because it calls attention to the scourage of vehicular child killing? The bloodbath on the highway? Can you not admit there's something curious in the way people selectively care about things regardless of their importance or solveability?
That number should be 0. As a parent of a child in a country that doesn't have issues with school shootings, the fact that kids are taught how to protect themselves during a school shooting from a very young age, aren't allowed to wear light-up shoes to not be seen too easily by a shooter, some states even argue that teachers should carry. This is very concerning to me. Enough that I would not choose to move to the US for fear of the safety of my kids. Arguing that kids die from other causes too diminishes the urgency of the situation, which I understand is your point, but you might want to reconsider.
> the Columbine shooting happened when millennials were in grade school
I'm a millennial and it happened when I was in high school. But yeah, there was maybe only one incident with a gun at my high school before then (not a shooting, kid just had a starter pistol in his backpack) and I don't recall ever thinking of a school shooting until Columbine happened.
That doesn't explain it though. Millennials were allowed to have phones with us, they just had to be kept silent and out of sight at all times during the school day. They were already available to us in case of a real emergency, there was no need to relax the rules to account for school shootings.
I don't see this as a legitimate concern because their child can simply have a phone and not use it unless needed. In the unlikely circumstance that a school shooting occurs while their phone is confiscated another room, I'm sure they can borrow a phone from a classmate.
That doesn’t explain it in most parts of the world where school shootings aren’t a thing parents would list on their top 20 things they worry about though.
Whether or not it's just in their head, the fact that the chance of your child being shot to death is high enough that the school runs practice drills is so disturbing that some parents need an extra security blanket.
Parents wanted their kids to have phones in school to treat their (the parents') anxiety. It doesn't do anything to stop a shooter or any other problem, but you can blast off a bunch of texts to your kid if you're worried about them.
It's a shame that so many parents basically traded their kids' social development for relief from some temporary bad feelings.
I think that, when used well, the ability to communicate was more about giving kids extra freedom than about increasing safety. I was not born before the wide availability of landline phones, so I don’t have a direct comparison. But it was pretty great to be able to easily call home and say something like “hey, is it okay if I go out with some friends and come back later than usual?” or “there’s an activity I’d like to do that will make me miss the bus - can you pick me up?”.
In the pay phone era, the use of phones at school was asymmetrical: kids could call parents, but parents mostly could not call kids.
Before the phone era, you wouldn't have to make those calls, because your parents didn't care what you were up to. You could even stay over with friends for a few days without telling your parents and it wouldn't have mattered a whole lot.
Then, of course, the media was full of scary murderers during the late 1960s and 1970s and things changed. Laws also changed to get parents on the hook.
Without any sort of phone, I might have been less inclined to do an unplanned activity that would keep me at school after the school bus left, because getting home by public transit was obnoxiously slow, it was too far to credibly walk, a safe bike route basically didn’t exist, and none of my friends were old enough to have a car. But I was lucky that my parents’ commutes were such that one of them could come and get me after work if I managed to arrange it. Which I sometimes did by using the aforementioned pay phone to call their office.
I don’t know about any relevant laws, but this was a big city, well after the 1970s. I semi-regularly walked myself a mile or so after elementary school to a parent’s office and no one batted an eye, but this may have been partially a result of the fact that the route was quite safe and largely car-free. Hmm, maybe the problem with kids’ freedom these days has as much to do with busy roads dividing up the world as with fear of school shootings.
I think that public transit in the particular area where my middle school was would have been, if anything, worse in the pre-phone era.
As a young kid we had to ask the office to make a call. When we were older we had a student (landline) phone for outgoing calls that we didn’t have to ask to use.
Parents called the office and left messages directly or had the kids call back.
I grew up in the early 90s, pagers were common among doctors and drug dealers, but cell phones were largely a novelty (and those that did exists were the size of shoe boxes, so usually mounted in a car's center console).
If mom or dad needed to contact me, they called the office. If it was urgent, the office dispatched somebody to come get me out of class. This happened to me approximately never, but on odd occasion it did happen to somebody.
And as noted, if I needed to contact mom or dad, I used the pay phone. If it was just "come and get me from sport practice", I didn't even feed in a quarter, I just called collect and they didn't bother accepting.
Parents are a bit insane today. Growing up (pre-teens through teens), I could disappear for the better part of a day and it was no big deal. I'd ride my bike into the city (20 miles each way). I'd go skiing with friends and be gone until well after dark.
Similarly, when my son was a similar age, he's skateboard all around town. He had a cell phone for part of that period, but we pretty much never texted him and he was even less likely to text us. Kids need to stretch their wings.
Completely understandable desire on the part of parents.
With that context, it seems like the core problem with having phones in schools might be the "smart" part, due to the amount of competing content that is brought into a student's presence when they should be focussed on socializing and academic work.
On the other hand, non-smart phones are decidedly boring. Has any school attempted allowing non-smart phones only? Really curious what the outcomes might be.
> That was before the absolute worst addictive dark patterns etc. Which means that someone looked at the world after that point and said "yeah actually, phones are ok now" which baffles me
Zeitgeist went too deep into phone normalization. Kids are being raised by parents who were mad their phones were taken away when they were in school. Kids complain, parents then complain to admin or teachers, and teachers' authority to take away a phone slips bit by bit by bit.
The cheeky thing about a teacher's authority is, like all authority, it isn't actually real, it just exists by the consent of those over whom the authority is exerted. "Consent" being used loosely - if you can convince people via rhetoric, tricking them, intimidation or whatever, then that counts too. Anyway point is, when all the students decide together that the teacher can't actually make them put their phones away, then that becomes reality. Teachers also learn not to waste their social capital / authority on demanding something they can't get.
The teacher's job has always been hard, but I've a lot of friends and family that have been teachers up to the last 20 years, and it is absolutely getting harder. Glad to hear some school districts are getting the right idea and banning phones, kids just aren't equipped with the tools to protect their attention from those that would leech it to sell to advertisers. Maybe none of us are.
It used to be a funny premise that somebody would carry their phone just because they were leaving the house.
When I was in high school, there was a payphone in the atrium. Then everyone started carrying their own phones and they took the payphones out, so now if you don't have a phone you really are stuck.
Happened in real life, too. A few years ago I was out of town when my phone died and needed to get from one hotel to another. No problem, I thought, get a cab. Oops, hotels don't have a cab stand any more. Call one? No payphone in the lobby. The front desk doesn't have a phone, either. Lowest friction path was buying a charger. Good thing businesses just let you plug in anywhere these days.
The problem was already entrenched before anyone noticed and cared.
Not just a school issue: my 8 yr old daughter asked me to install a TikTok alternative on her iPad. She’s not allowed to use it much - long care rides mostly.
But she found out from a friend who lives in a home with a more liberal policy. Happened on a playdate after school. And so I am negotiating from behind the curve.
Similar for me - but I don’t think that answers the question you’re responding to.
There were parents that let their kids drink in 7th grade when I was in school - but still kids today are not allowed to bring Jim Beam to class, just like then.
Something definitely shifted with the phones, it’d be interesting to see a documentary or read a book about how it ended up being allowed in the classrooms..
It was because only the bourgeois kids had them at first, and these weren’t just average kids — their parents were were in the know techies and early adopters, Steve Jobs stans, yuppies. “If the ‘in the know’ families have cell phones”, thought normie America, “my kids should too.” Iow, blame hn here, and the early adoption crowd whose lack of wisdom and lust for the shiny got us.
> Something definitely shifted with the phones, it’d be interesting to see a documentary or read a book about how it ended up being allowed in the classrooms..
The children in schools aged out of being Gen Z (raised by Gen X) and into Gen Alpha (raised by Millennials). I think that goes pretty far to explain the shift.
I've never personally met a strict millennial parent, while my parents (and those of my peers) when I was in school seemingly still held more 'old-school' values like refusing to give their children smartphones until highschool (or until they got their own job and could buy it with their own money), being willing to ground (and punish) their kids, and restricting screen time.
It's definitely a tough situation. Our kids aren't phone-aged yet but even toddlers are getting iPads as default for outings and even home life in some situations. I've heard people say that when they are more strict about phone access for older kids, the kids will just end up with secret accts on their friends devices. Yet again tech goes faster than we can figure it out
>But she found out from a friend who lives in a home with a more liberal policy. Happened on a playdate after school. And so I am negotiating from behind the curve.
This is precisely why it can't be solved without collective action.
And what's crazy is that studies have found that while kids don't want to be left out of social media, they do want everyone to be off it. Which is more or less corroborated by the top level comment:
>My kids (16 and 13) both attend schools that recently implemented phone bans and they love it, somewhat surprisingly.
> I don't understand when it become allowed honestly. Like when I was at school, phones were never allowed. If a teacher saw one they'd confiscate it and your parents would have to come and collect it.
When and where was this? Before smartphones, teachers (at my school, Sweden, 90s/early 00s sometime) didn't give a crap about phones as long as you didn't play music out loud on it, not until society got infected with social media that teachers started telling kids to put away the phones it seems to me.
I think it was a gradual thing that's why there wasn't a "allow or forbid" moment, it just was, until it was everywhere and literally poisoning people's mind.
In the US in the early mainstream-cell-phone era (95-05ish), playing with any sort of device in class would get called out if spotted by teachers.
Some of the larger-handed athletes amusingly thought their tiny Nokias were small enough to make it not obvious they were texting/playing Snake on them, but it was pretty easy to spot.
Having it in your backpack if it's not making noise? Sure. Using it? Nah.
In the 1980s it was Sony walkman radios and cassette players kids where getting taken away at school. Though it didn't happen much, I think most kids knew it was a distraction.
Probably due to tablets becoming standard use at school. It was around the same time, and I imagine it felt silly to tell kids they couldn’t use one extremely distracting device while requiring them to use another that is the same thing in a different form factor.
Phone bans are a start. Getting tablets out of the curriculum is next.
You didn't use a flip phone in class as all your could do with them was talk which was obvious. Though kids playing snake did get them taken away. For the most part a flip phone was used to call for a ride after school. (much better than waiting in line for 20 minutes for the student phone)
The problem isn't just phones in class, but in school outside of class. We had phones in school, but no use for them - almost all my contacts were my classmates, who would I text?
A whole bunch more school shootings scared parents into wanting connectivity, plus ability to track kids through safety/surveillance tools like Life360
With no thought to what being constantly surveilled does to kids psychologically. As a parent, I know it’s hard, but parents really need to get a handle on their anxiety, helicoptering harms children. Developing independence is a core drive for them.
Anecdotal evidence here, but a number of my family members working in public education have recounted similar stories of parents threatening (or attempting) legal action when a student’s phone or iPad is taken away.
The common rationales from the parents are:
- “What if a school shooting happens? You are making them unsafe!”
- “Their IEP says they need it!” (It almost never does, or calls for device access for a very specific, limited reason tied to a communication tool or educational outcome. Not unlimited video scrolling)
I was in high school when the iPod touch was huge. They were definitely banned by the letter of the law, but so many kids had them that some teachers just gave up on enforcing the rule. There will always be some number of kids not paying attention or goofing off, and they don't have the energy to enforce the rule 100% of the time. Then, as smartphones became ubiquitous, the soft acceptance just snowballed.
I remember advocating to a teacher that an iPod touch is not a phone and therefore it should not be banned.
In general I think we were only allowed to use phones during math lessons (as calculators). This was at a time when none of us had mobile data and there was like one wifi router in the whole building.
Thats how it was in middle school for me, and then in high school phones were basically always allowed. Its probably not a coincidence that my grades were better in middle school than they were in high school.
IMO one cause of this and many other problems in the public education system is that parents have too much influence in the education system.
Nowadays, if they give a kid a failing grade, there's a good chance the parents show up to try and intimidate their way into a pass... Instead of figuring out why their kid is failing. Same goes if their kid gets into trouble - their angel can do no wrong, why are you being mean?
This kind of stuff was happening 20 years ago, I am not surprised it's gotten worse. Parents by and large are unqualified to make decisions about education, but have outsized influence in it. It's probably a huge reason why the US public educational system has been getting smoked by Europe and east Asia, where parents have less insurance.
> Parents by and large are unqualified to make decisions about education
Especially in the sense of grading and assessment, but I wouldn't generalize this. Both in the sense of do they actually make good decisions on things they can (sometimes) control, such as school (district) selection — barring interesting exceptions like Nikole Hannah-Jones I think they do — and whether they are legally or morally thus qualified. Not that you're implying this, but I bristle a little at the use of the term, since it connotes the removal of parent agency by state action. Caution is advisable there.
They are experts, but they are providing a service. There needs to be a balance. Your doctor is another primary example.
I think one guiding principle is methods vs. values. An expert has more authority on methods, but values need broad alignment between the service provider and the the people they serve. And neither party is entitled to the other - both parties need to feel the relationship is mutually beneficial for the relationship to be sustainable.
So there is some truth in needing to defer to educators, but not absolutely.
>Parents by and large are unqualified to make decisions about education
This attitude will drive people away from public schools (and already has). Parents are major stakeholders in their children's education and public schools must be accountable to the public. For the benefit of everyone, there should be a better process for handling the input from parents.
I think we would agree there needs to be a balance. Arguing about changing an F to some passing grade is wrong. But it's also incentivized by the schools and states to meet metrics, so it's unfair to just cast this blame on the parents. But absolutely parents who do this are in the wrong and schools should not enable it.
Some things experts should have broad leeway on are methods. How they structure a reading curriculum or teach long division. Not so much on enforcing certain goals or values.
And the more results that the schools deliver, the more deference from parents they will be able to expect. But the more contention there is between parents and schools, the worse public school support will become.
We pushed as long as we could against "smart phones" as parents with my two sons.
Eventually gave in when the flip phone my son had as a freshman in high school couldn't run the app the marching band was using to communicate.
A very sad memory with my younger son: I was a chaperone for one of his soccer camps when he was in middle school. I remember down time between games, and thinking this is nice he can spend some time socializing with his teammates. But he was the only one without a phone, and the teammates immediately took out their phones and started scrolling, leaving my son to sit there alone in silence.
(Yeah, maybe I should have tried to convince the other kids to put down their phones, but it was an awkward moment that took me by surprise.)
That's great. I sat at dinner with my teenage nephews after the phone ban had been announced in my state but before it had gone into effect. They were all opposed to the idea and gave several reasons about why they weren't comfortable with giving up their phones. I told them some of the arguments for it and they remained skeptical until I pointed out that _noone_ would have phones and their eyes lit up as they considered the implications of that and they suddenly became excited about the upcoming ban.
I think there are more parents that want their kids reachable at all times and the kids just want to hang with their friends.
> Before the ban, at lunch or study halls or recess, kids would just be on their phones and now they're laughing and goofing off, as kids should be doing.
During my personal experience working with schools, I've always saw kids off their phones when physically next to each other. Phones were always banned in class, but lunch usually permitted them. I guess social dynamics change from place to place.
The problem with phones, as well as social media, or anything else with a network effect, is that it becomes a prisoner's dilemma. You can recognise the harms, but feel the need to take part anyway, because opting out puts you at a social disadvantage. If everyone opts out, the disadvantage is neutralised
> Before the ban, at lunch or study halls or recess, kids would just be on their phones and now they're laughing and goofing off, as kids should be doing.
> Bonkers to me that we ever allowed this.
Mm. You've just reminded me of middle school, where if the kids got too loud during lunch, a teacher might order us to all eat in silence and anyone braking the rule would have to stand alone looking at a wall until the end of the lunch period as punishment.
In retrospect, I have absolutely no idea why that guy even wanted to be a teacher if he wasn't OK with kids socialising while they ate.
I recommend reading The Anxious Generation by Jonathan Haidt. It's a great read on the effects of social media, phones, and general modern society on our youth.
One of the interesting bits in the book was about phone access in school. There are 3 tiers for any kid:
1) everyone has phones, including you
2) everyone has phones, except you
3) no one has phones
Option 2 has been tried by many parents over the years, to lackluster results. Kids basically feel weird and isolated if they're the only one without a phone. Turns out, as you discovered, that if no one has a phone, everyone is happier. It's something no single parent can do, but we're starting to discover that if we implement it across the whole school, it really does work.
This isn't directly related to a school ban, but I can share another anecdote that reinforces your kids' thoughts. I'm a parent of 17 & 15 year olds and regularly (3-4x/yr) chaperone my 15yo daughter's soccer team to regional and national events. It's typically two vanloads of girls -- 18-24 kids -- and up until about three events back we let them have phones until lights out. As expected, if they weren't competing, they were on their phones. We instituted a revised policy last year where we take phones at 9pm (lights out at 10pm) and give them back after breakfast. It's made a world of difference in the camaraderie that's developed, since the girls now have to actually talk with each other. It's also led to improved travel maturity overall, and much more pleasant van rides [with only silent phone use allowed -- typically locked in with their personal pre-match music]. 10/10 do recommend.
It’s not bonkers at all. The reason why phone usage became so prevalent is precisely because of how much we didn’t know. It doesn’t even make logical sense why it’s bad.
That’s how insidious it is because it seems so benign.
When I was in middle school, there would always be kids with a GameBoy or Walkman with a small group gathered around them. Even someone with a Nokia phone and snake was enough to break the boredom we all felt.
my boys ( ~17 and 14 and a Junior and Freshman US HS respectively) mostly feel the same. Or at least they don't complain about it and are in the routine. Both of them meet up with their friends before school and sometimes after school for clubs. However, the kids still refer to their Yondr Pouches as a "i-can't-call-my-parents-and-tell-them-i-love-them-in-an-emergency pouch" heh.
The study https://cepr.harvard.edu/sites/g/files/omnuum9881/files/2026... finds a ≈0.01 standard-deviation difference in test scores the year lockable phone pouches are adopted, with no detectable additional difference in the following year. Certainly nothing to sneeze at from a system-wide perspective, but easily overwhelmed by other factors for any individual student.
Individual test students are going to be hard to predict anyway. Though I think this is compared to the sample standard deviation, and for most students their improvement over time is going to be smaller than the difference between two random students.
That ≈0.01 SD effect is actually 0.0087 +/- 0.0043 (standard error), giving a 95% confidence interval of roughly 0.0003 to 0.0171 standard deviations.
So the effect could be tiny.
Worse, the report says it excludes observations outside the 0.5th and 99.5th percentiles of the 2021–22 fall-to-spring score-change distribution. I'm not sure how this is defensible. Either you trust your measurement instrument or you don't.
If you're using a difference-in-differences design, excluding observations can change what you're measuring, particularly if the exclusions differ between treatment and control groups or over time. Without trimming those observations, the estimated effect drops from 0.0087 SD to 0.0058 SD (and is no longer statistically significant).
The authors preregistered their study, but there's nothing in the report indicating that the trimming of 'extreme' values was part of that preregistration...
Sounds like they noticed a few extreme outliers were pulling the difference down and hacked it out. Methodologically that’s really sus to do this after the study is done. But generally I think it’s okay to exclude extreme outliers - we generally assume Gaussian distributions, but the real world happens and messes things up. Having a few kids that are 5 or 6 sigma out pulling your averages - I can believe the rules are different for them. But this should have been decided ahead of time.
I emailed the authors and received a reply. That part of the study was not preregistered.
My message to them:
Dear Dr. Burland and Professor Kane,
I was reading your November 2026 report, Phone-Free Schools and Achievement Growth, and saw that the study was preregistered on the Open Science Framework. I haven’t been able to locate the registration.
Could you please share a link to the preregistration or let me know where I can find it? I’m particularly interested in checking whether the exclusion of extreme fall-to-spring score changes was specified in the original analysis plan.
Thank you for your time and for making the research available.
Best regards
Their reply:
Rahim: That part of the study was not pre-registered. We have used the NWEA data from earlier years, but had not encountered such extreme outliers. The magnitude of gains or losses we dropped were clearly errors—multiple standard deviation gains in a single year, also inconsistent with the midyear measurement. I’m ccing our colleague, Samantha Cullum, who can provide the link to the pre-registration. Tom Kane
Don't forget that scores are normalized for many tests. It's not a linear scale from "nothing correct is a zero, everything correct is a 10". Rather, the average number of correct answers (often weighted, but ok) is a pass. This will mess up any analysis.
The test they're using is the NWEA MAP Growth https://www.nwea.org/map-growth/ which doesn't have a concept of pass or fail. It doesn't even have a fixed set of questions, but adapts the difficulty dynamically based on earlier answers to get a more accurate measurement.
Everyone in the US knew phones were destroying attention spans years ago, but educational bodies and school boards punted the burden down to individual schools, teachers, and parents. Of course it failed: no single teacher or parent wants to be the bad guy and face social friction.
China just banned them outright. It's the same with companies - weak committee vs. a founder who just makes the hard call.
Some others would say it's the same as with liberal or totalitarian states - you are to judge what you do vs. a unchecked despot.
But I agree, this is long overdue and capitalism has figured out how to defacto undermine individual judgement to a level that we need some railguards.
Absolutely. I was a high school teacher in the 2010s, and it was such a hard aspect of teaching to navigate.
For any reasonable phone policy to be implemented well, it has to come from the highest level of administration. It has to be enforced consistently across all levels from the district/principals down to individual classroom teachers. That requires a lot of people to understand the issue well, come to agreement, and be capable of enforcing difficult policies.
There are so many factors that make it difficult for this to happen. Parents who disagree with policies, often for valid reasons. Staff turnover makes consistency difficult. If one teacher lets students use phones, it makes it harder for everyone around them to manage the policy effectively. If groups of teachers don't adhere, it gets even harder.
This is no different than the impact of AirBnB on housing availability, especially in tourist destination towns. Tech companies create a situation that's really hard to manage, and then leave it to individuals and small organizations to manage something that really needs to be figured out at a societal level.
> Everyone in the US knew phones were destroying attention spans years ago
I think that is the general consensus but I think that is only so because of common knowledge; I do not actually believe it is true, nor do we have any data to indicate that it is the phones any more than it is the continuously declining curricula in the US. Correlation is not causation.
It's really not obvious and genuinely feels like moral panic to me. The data here are so weak for something that is supposedly so harmful. It doesn't stand up to scrutiny. I don't think phone bans are worth the cost of the pouches. In some small ways it's actually hurting kids. They used to take pictures of the board or check google classroom assignments and now they can't. Mine are more likely to miss assignments now than before the ban and I don't see any change whatsoever in kids behavior.
How long before this enters the work force at various points?
My empty nester wife reentered the work force as a nurse. As one of her studies during her in hospital training she studied cell phone impacts on nursing. She’s commented how some nurses—and not just the young ones just coming out of school, but just as often the middle and older generations—struggle to be effectively present because they’re on their phones all the time.
I see informal bans, and well motivated individuals, but I haven’t seen it “become the norm thing” for workplaces to do as the schools are starting to do yet. Curious if it will.
I don't see this problem at my workplace. Maybe in the lunchroom which cuts down on socializing I guess. We're a bunch of awkward tech nerds anyway tho
I am in tech and the longer I work the less I want to look at my phone, I usually dont even know where my phone is for most part of the day and then I will remember to check it after 3 or 4 hours, but again, I work on a computer so I think its more of a replacement, the problem exists in a different format
I was just wondering if this could apply to Workshops or other days in the corporate world that are different from the day-to-day.
Imagine your job offers a three day off-site to address some of the most pressing matters. All of the company bigwigs will be there and it will be a luxuriously beautiful space (think Mohonk Mountain House in New Paltz, NY).
The catch is you need to hand your phone to a concierge (who insists you will be contacts in case of an emergency*), laptops need to be checked out, and web activity will be scrutinized (sorry, no HN or Reddit). In a mundane organization (more blue-chip company than hustle-fueled startup), you'd probably only get 5% of office personnel to agree, but they'd probably accomplish some cool stuff.
*I would want to acknowledge that this involves giving up some level of autonomy that is vital for more vulnerable peoples (women, minorities, people who have obligations outside of their job), but it's an interesting thought exercise for how humans collaborate and solve problems.
In France in 1956 they were passing a law that forbid children below 14yo to get alcohol served at the school cantine (https://youtu.be/n_Ez2RMjwuA - TV report from that time in French). I hope we will get laws forbidding phones in schools, or to children in general, and my guess is that it will resonate like this one for future generations.
I wonder if we'll see something happen with phones (and specifically, infinite feed consumption) that somewhat mirrors alcohol and cigarettes. First getting it out of the hands of kids and then gradually removing it from physical and social environments.
Eventually it becomes something adults can do where appropriate, knowing the harms associated with it.
It may seem crazy to think about with such a ubiquitous activity as phone scrolling. But if anyone drank at a business lunch like people did in the 50s or smoked in the office, they'd quickly have a meeting with HR.
It should have been done years ago. My partner is a teacher and she was so frustrated by pupils having phones (more recently, secretly) in the classroom. I don't know why it was ever allowed.
I used to zone out all the time during boring in-person meetings without a device back in the day. I credit having to sit through mass in Catholic school.
I'm in the office. Even the people in the office take calls from their desk to do other things at the same time. And when they bother to go to the meeting room... they fiddle with the phone under the desk to do other things. People who want to "check out" during a meeting will do it one way or another.
It's generational. The parents that didn't grow up with phones at a young age don't understand how addictive/ isolating a phone can be. Millennials grew up with it and understand.
Are the test scores improving because of the phone bans or are they improving because we're getting past the COVID era school lockdowns and things are going back to normal?
The lockdown had permanent strongly negative impact on every kid that was in school at that time. You’d need to wait for all of them to be out (about 15 years) to safely stop blaming it.
I don't see people "blaming COVID", a coronavirus with no agency, for anything.
I see people, including the person to whom you are responding, continuing to make observations about policies which were put in place during the pre-endemicity phase of the spread of that coronaviruses, some of which have turned out to have caused far more harm than the little or zero good they did (school-closures being perhaps the most obvious).
Does it matter? Let's keep at it for a while and see if it continues.
Though I imagine they're pretty certain whether it's one or the other. Teachers at least seem to be quite certain, though 'common sense' doesn't always pan out.
Its a stretch to call them “noticeable improvements across the board”.
The study barely found statistically significant results when excluding students with significant changes and combining subjects. Math and reading on their own had no significant results and neither did including students with extreme changes.
They also ignored other changes that may have been introduced by schools at the same time.
From a policymaker perspective, I’d argue that this study falls short of warranting investments into these pouches.
One may even argue that there is a bit of a conflict of interest here with some of the data for the study coming from the manufacturer themselves and the study specifically discussing these pouches as opposed to other ways of enforcing such ban…
All the kids I know have a healthier relationship with their phone than some of the adults I know. Some adults can't even bear to not look into their phone while watching a movie.
But then that creates the question of whether or not the development of the brain outweighs learning proper use from a young age, something to think about.
I live in a small mountain town in BC and I really hope the who town bans smart phones for kids by the time our 3 year old goes to school.
I think it’s much easier for everyone if nobody has one - nobody is missing out, parents are not the bad guys, etc.
They’re screwing up the lives of so many adults, I feels it’s a certainty we’ll look back in some years and wonder wtf we were thinking giving them to kids.
What I want to know is when was the original ban removed? When I was in high school in the mid-late aughts, cell phones in lockers were tolerated, but if a teacher ever caught you with one in class it would be confiscated until the end of the day.
As a parent, it's clear: time to start cutting technology from children--social media, cell phones, tablets, AI, even internet--until we've returned to at least Millennial academic achievement levels.
It wasn't until 24/7 social media that it started to have such a negative impact though. My first phone I think was a Sony Ericson Z-something, and of course me and everyone else brought their phones to school so we could share mp3s over IR during recess, but during class the most distracted you ended up being was trying to type and send SMSes while not looking at the screen.
A far cry from what seems to be going on with schools today due to smartphones, social media and all that comes with essentially "one big 24/7 public group".
My guess is that a "social media ban" would have the same effect, but it's a lot harder to put in place, so easier to just ban phones overall.
There are already multiple ways of blocking social media on kids phones. I think the kid safe SIMs available in the UK give you that option, you can use DNS that stops looks ups, my router lets me have blocking rules for specific devices...
I home educated so the pressure was less because kids had a variety of rules so they adapted.
Some parents were stricter than me, some a lot less so. At one point I set up a Jitsi server so one girl whose parents did not allow chat apps could talk to the others. They were unusually strict.
I also had my younger one use some things on a computer rather than a phone.
I also found it weird. I graduated in 2011 when teachers still confiscated phones. I found it baffling that between then and now we entered a period where that became something like a taboo.
I’m not surprised we’re back where we started but the fact that we ever went on this journey to begin with is weird.
Maybe they were not harmful back then before social media became big and people got cheap and fast data. Back then phones could basically just text and call and confiscating them was most likely excessive.
I remember when in highschool and sure there was social media but nobody had a smartphone.
Hey i spent a lot of hours playing snake on my Nokia and drug wars on my TI83 in school in the 90s. There are always ways to ignore boring teachers, i guess modern phones just make it easier.
My school confiscated flip phones if you had yours out in class. Before smart phones constant texting was already a thing for young people, plus even dumb phones had games.
Maybe this is an American thing? Here in Ireland lots of kids would have had 2G 'smart phones' capable of running AIM, email, etc in the mid 2000s. By around 2008 / 2009 most kids would have had an iphone or one of the final generation of non touchscreen smartphones that had raced to catchup in features. By 2011 literally every kid would have had an android or iphone (android's were much more popular for a few years due to price, here in Europe - they're still far more common than in the US).
I graduated school in 1999, and every single kid was texting constantly. Phones had become ubiquitous in 1998 due to an Irish bank giving a free cellphone out when a new account was opened.
1998 was firmly beeper territory for my friends and I. I didn't know a single person with a cell phone. We weren't exactly in some tech backwater either - grew up in the SF bay area.
That's crazy to me. I vividly remember everyone I knew going from not having a phone (unless their parents were wealthy) to suddenly having one. For years kids would trade 'free codes' to get around the price of texting - this was all 'pay as you go' so you bought credit from stores to call and text. I suspect the mobile companies were leaking these 'secret engineer codes' in order to boost the popularity of texting. But I did have some awareness that we were quite ahead of the US in adoption of mobile, based on TV shows and such at the time. Incidentally, prior to that literally no one I knew had a pager. Just didn't penetrate at all here beyond drug dealers and emergency services.
At the same time, the reverse culture shock occurred in 2007 when I visited the US for the first time, and all the cyber cafes had gone. Replaced by wifi. I didn't have a laptop at the time, or a wifi capable smart device, so I spent days searching for cyber cafes everywhere I visited. I remember using a gaming cafe in the University of Phoenix, and searching Korea town for one of NYC's remaining cafes. The stress of getting around the city alone before having access to a device that could run google maps, was no joke.
I had a mobile phone around 1998. It was a brick. Wouldn't even want to carry that around with me. Ditched it after a few months. Next time I had a phone was 2008. By around 2004 most classmates had a phone, but I didn't. Wouldn't even have known what to use it for. Call my parents? What for. Talk to classmates? I can do that in person.
A friend who is a teacher said if you try to confiscate them you get parents showing up complaining it’s a safety issue.
The Principal doesn’t want to rock any boats and hides from it.
To be clear it's about 2% of parents that do this, if that. And they are consistently horrible parents - shocker. The worst part in modern times with social media and the like is that people started caring what the 2% think for fear they'll got rant on social media or whatever. Not to say we should be discriminatory or whatever, but seriously - the unambiguously correct answer to this is 'We're sorry to hear you feel that way, and wish you the best of luck finding a new school for your child.'
There are two problems. One is that we've let that 2% hold everything hostage.
Another is that a public school is legally required to offer an education. All children are legally entitled to an education. If you're private, you can tell them to pound sand.
> All children are legally entitled to an education.
understood. But are the parents entitled to be stupid? What does that have to do with offering the child education. Since when is educating children a democratic process amongst parents? why is it OK that we don't treat teachers as professionals and instead assume parents know best? I say this as a parent by the way.
It's almost like school is a big babysitting service lol.
A lot of stuff has gone off the rails in the last 15 to 20 years.
The bar for having a child is quite low. Schools are bound by geography and whatever income that provides.
> It's almost like school is a big babysitting service.
It most definitely is, and the issue as you've pointed out is a lot has gone off the rails in 20-25 years (15 years is actually too short of time frame).
Part of what has gone off the rails is that most of the structures that undergird our society (US) had been left to rot as economic gains in smaller and smaller arenas dominate. It's not healthy, it will almost certainly destroy American society, but the people with capital do not care. Some are actively gleefully participating in the destruction.
Also civics should be mandatory in all public schools starting at age like 10.
However, if in the 90s someone told me that in the future we'd all have the equivalent of a TV set with 1000 channels on our office desks, and people would think it was normal, I wouldn't have believed it.
You'd be surprised how some parents advocate using phones because "My kids need to learn how to manage the technology". Well, kids don't, since the technology exploits our primal drives. You don't give heroin to kids so they know how to manage it.
actually that's one plausible reason why Germans handle alcohol so much better than Australians and Americans. They get access to it as teenagers supervised by parents and don't go crazy, so they don't associate alcohol with going crazy.
Its generally true of many other countries too and there seems to be a correlation: the stricter attitudes to alcohol are, the worse the alcohol problems
I think the "supervised" is important. My kids had small amounts of alcohol at family meals. Quantity and strength rose with age so they were ready to handle being able to drink whatever they wanted when they could buy alcohol at 18. Its one of many things that kids learn better from adults than from people their own age.
I agree on heroin, but I think we should give all teens a class on recognizing and managing addiction. Take them through a few cycles of getting on and off caffeine, plus various digital addictions. Alongside traditional education on recreational drugs, prescription drugs, nicotine, alcohol, gambling, and the nature of addiction. And of course spotting addictions in others and how to help them.
Given the widespread commerical exploitation of engineered addictions, I think it's vital knowledge to have a good life.
> My kids need to learn how to manage the technology"
which is a bonkers excuse because there isnt a single other technology we require 24/7 access to. Its more likely that some parents expect 24/7 access to their kids.
They never were "allowed" but teachers don't have any actual power to confiscate the phone and then if some teacher did confiscate the phone parents would step in making a fuss about children rights yada yada.
So it ended up teachers not enforcing it and kids not being afraid because no one could do anything.
People are quite quick with not caring about rules they are not going to be punished or ostracised for...
I think children end up having phones for the journey to and from school. It's the reason I think a lot of parents first get their children phones. If they are travelling a distance, on public transport or being picked up somewhere by parents then I can understand that. It's hard for a school to say that the students can't have phones for the travel to and from school.
The issue then becomes what happens to those phones during the day. If school have lockers, that is an option, but not all schools have a lockers.
In the case of one of the schools here, they don't have enough lockers for everybody. That school had a 'phones mustn't be seen in lesson time' policy, but that obviously is too easy to abuse, with e.g. students going to the toilet in lessons or just accessing their phones anyway, which isn't hard when they have the phone in their pocket.
They now have switched to lockable pouches that phones have to go in during the day and are locked during school hours (with an 'unlocker' available when they leave school). This works better but requires quite a bit of staff time checking the pouches in the morning (students will do things like put calculators inside instead!) and costs money. I can see why not all schools have gone that route.
this doesn't surprise me at all. what surprises me is somehow people think this is unique to kids in school. Why not adults at home or in the office? I'm not saying we should ban phones for adults obviously, just pointing out that their strong negative effects on learning and social activity and others are definitely not limited to kids.
It is about the format. You cannot carry your laptop in your pocket and take it out every time there is the slightest bit of boredom or free time. The barrier to using phones is way, way lower.
Regardless of format, there is plenty of evidence which at minimum strongly suggests that school sized laptops are one of the leading drivers of the modern literacy crisis. As an educator I can attest to this being a seriously under appreciated issue.
Someone forgot to tell me that... I started in high school carrying my laptop everywhere with me to pull out (of my backpack) every time there is the slightest bit of boredom.
Some are pushing back on the laptops too. Kids seem to do better with writing without them. I think we should go back to having computer labs with dedicated time to learn how to use them and to use them for specific things. No more screens in classrooms and no more "they're digital natives" thinking.
The push back to that is that a lot of assignments have been moved to be digital, which saves teachers a lot of time with grading.
-I can't inspect my kid's homework once it is done.
-There is no "show your work" so the teacher can't find the flaw in how a kid is executing an algorithm in math, for example, the steps in long division.
-There is no artifact for the kid to review once it's graded, to understand where they went wrong.
-There is no artifact for them to study to prep for a test.
-My refrigerator door is bare.
Downvoting doesn't make this untrue; what a bunch of technofascists here.
The identification in this study is a sketchy, and a similar study in the exact same setting ((https://tom-dee.github.io/files/w35132.pdf) doesn't find a significant effect.
1. they see diverging pre-trends, which immediately suggests a problem in the diff-in-diff
2. they're doing some kind of propensity score matching to build a comparison set, and it looks like they're matching across state lines, which is going to expose them to all sorts of weird state-level shocks
3. while the previous study just looked at the impacts on grades, they've built a value-added model and they're estimating their effects through that. That just adds another place where they can get the model wrong and end up with bad estimates.
They also point out that the schools that bought these pouches had more ESSER money, which they could have spent on tutoring.
I'm currently in my final year of high school in Türkiye. Phones are strictly forbidden in all schools. However, my school allows students to use tablets for studying during class. This is useful, for example, for discussing a question with friends or showing a problem directly to the teacher. It also saves paper and reduces the weight of our bags. Despite this, I believe it is better to reduce screen time. When our eyes are less exposed to the high level of visual stimulation from screens, we can better focus on the static nature of a classroom lesson, which might otherwise feel tedious. Since I personally have no experience using tablets at school, I cant say whether they lead to any improvement in test scores
I have debated moving to a dumbphone to try and cut down my YouTube addiction. Thus far the only blocker for me has been the lack of Signal support.
I am pretty convinced that having a nonstop stream of media being beamed into us is a bad thing. I kind of miss being "bored". Like, truly bored, like being stuck on the train without any means to entertain myself outside of what's in my head (and maybe reading the safety notifications).
I mean, no, pretty much every service lets you download stuff for offline access (including YouTube if you have premium), which I was doing anyway to preserve battery.
I'll admit that part of me wants to try a dumbphone primarily as a curiosity, since I am curious how well I could survive in 2026 without all the smartphone conveniences. Also the battery that can last upwards of a week.
Maybe it's me, but since I deleted most of my social media I feel better and can articulate longer ideas. But the feeling of boredom is crushing. I can't find something to do with the time I wasted in social media before, any ideas?
Give yourself some time to adjust to the new baseline. You may find some new interest in new or old hobbies again. Hard to recommend anything specific.
i hope chromebooks and Blooket are next. I was shocked when I found out Blooket was part of his leaning. All the kids do is mash the buttons so they can get in game currency or whatever that crap is. The questions werent even tailored to his age group
The problem is extreme psychological "games" played on every app with hordes of behaviorists turning the Skinner Box to 1000000.
Its easy to go after under 18 cause they cant vote you out, or really do much of anything. Schools are fiefdoms run by the principal and superintendent. But we see this extreme addictiveness and gamification across all humans.
If work places would ban phones from toilets, I wonder why much that would improve productivity :) I bet people spend way more time in toilets now comparing to 20 years ago.
Here in the Netherlands we see an increase in total bans in schools as well. Most schools already banned phones in the classroom. Although I do support it I do have to remind myself that I loved wearing my walkman between classes back in the day or playing on my gameboy during recess. I think as a parent I'm in the end responsible for my kids usage of mobile devices.
Definitely banned at my kid's school: not only the phones go into a locked locker at the beginning of the day but in addition to that if the phone even rings (phonecall, alarm, anything), it's a warning. First warning: phone is confiscated and moved outside the locker and the kid has to go pick it at the end of day and explain what happened. Second warning: parents have to come get it. Third warning: kids cannot, ever, take a phone to school.
My daughter got a first warning and a few days later I received a letter citing a law article (about how phones cannot be used during school hours).
If the parent is allowing the student to bring a disruptive device to school, they are entrusting the student to responsibly silent or turn off their phone.
If the risk of fine helps the parent reevaluate the trust, I personally don't see the harm
Like anything else, the intentions are probably altruistic, and this discussion is probably missing context. But your last sentence is saying "I am OK with leaving the legal repercussions of my child up to a vague number of untrained people, as a risk-reward tradeoff of giving my child a way to contact me."
how many staff/positions are required to monitor these devices and their "law-breaking" offenses, which thus are (according to OP of this chain) to be reported/acted on?
What staff is further respnsible for parsing out whether or not an "alert" was something the child had no control over? IE; a weather warning or amber alert.
School staff is usually not untrained when it comes to this topic. Usually implementation of these rules at schools include many hours of direct instruction and supplemental instruction throughout the year. The state's implementation of the laws vary state-to-state as far as staffing requirements.
A child needing to contact their parent during the school day is not a new or abnormal occurrence, what is new and abnormal is the parental desire to have a cell phone with them all day. In my observation, this desire wasn't really there before the events of 2020
How is a phone ringing inside a box in a room on the other side of the building disruptive?
The phone is taken away from their possession it means that they must make sure they don't make a mistake before handing it over. Even if they remember afterwards they can't fix the mistake. Considering kids go to school on thousands of occasions that's a pretty low tolerance for mistakes.
I've forgotten something when leaving home more than 3 times over the duration of the previous 12 years. I guess other people are just better than me and don't ever forget anything.
These rules are not just applied to high/secondary schools. This is also a problem with elementary schools as well which has lockers/cubbies located in the classroom.
Also, kids aren't dumb. They know how to follow rules once the expectations are in place. The idea is to leave the phones at home entirely, allowing them in the locker to accommodate for the edge cases is a concession that has tradeoffs for the child's parent.
That doesn't add up - not only because phone usage is a question for district policy, not law. But also because someone else calling your phone is not your fault.
It still just strikes me as moral panic. The data are so weak and there's no obvious cause and effect. It's amazing to me how universal the praise is for phone bans even on HN. I really, really do not see the massive harms people are imagining. I also think there are much bigger and far worse causes of kids losing enthusiasm for school and it's the national/global malaise caused by corrupt government, poor outlook for young workers and the looming climate disaster. Focusing on phones is a very misguided attempt to prevent them from knowing about it.
> national/global malaise caused by corrupt government, poor outlook for young workers and the looming climate disaster
All of these are decades+ old problems.
Phones have trillions of dollars of R&D invested into the best ways to steal attention. But you think that doesn't have any effect on children's ability to learn?
I think it amounts to focusing on something that seems achievable. The big drivers of problems today are massive, interrelated, and even when they have clear causes, they often lack clear levers to do anything about them. If you take the opioid crisis as an example, there are a million ideas on what the "how" is if one wants to address it, and most of those have the possibility of making the problem worse (e.g. via the iron law of prohibition, where enforcement encourages smugglers to concentrate products to even higher potencies). On the other hand, "tell schools to take phones away from students" is mostly concrete, and allows one to imagine a return of the world to the state it was in during their own childhood.
Opioid deaths have actually dropped rapidly. We also know how to solve climate change and just haven't been doing it.
It's the older prephone generations who are the most out of touch. The ones who put Trump in office. Gen Z may have lower test scores but you'd be hard pressed to say they aren't smarter than their elders.
Nah, I'm a parent of 3 kids - it's incredibly noticeable that there's a distinct difference in behavior with electronics vs without.
Are there other problems? Sure.
But this one is obvious, impactful, and easy to fix.
Next - I want to take away the chromebooks and "online" testing that the schools do too, and I'd like to consider a complete blanket ban on any sort of required account/web access for school work. This is near universally a product pushed on teachers by admins who get sold on products by for-profit tech companies.
It's not good for kids, it's good for bottom lines. Rip those fucking things out. Computer access can be a "sit down" at a desktop computer in a computer lab once or twice a week.
Care to elaborate? I have two teens and they literally yell at me for looking at my phone too much. Their cohorts in high school seem like much better people than we were 30 years ago.
You are commenting on an article that mentions a scientific national study, saying those harms are imaginary while the study precisely brings up evidence that they are not. This seems illogical to be honest. I am not implying that it's black or white and that this proves anything substantial, but it still contributes to our understanding of the matter.
I remember using early smartphones to hang out in IRC, Jabber etc with people that vibed a lot better than what was available on-site.
Kids won't have that escape hatch anymore once you blanket ban these devices.
But I suppose it makes sense. The majority absolutely got their brain fried by the products SV (read: HN) built and we need to protect the majority.
I wonder what the next generation of misfit kids will come up with. Or maybe we will create school environments that work for all kinds of people? Nah. Of course not.
honestly, i see it as a good thing if not everyone does it. i was one of the only 'online' kids back in my school time and i liked being able to get the phone and talk to my friends when i was bored, but if everyone does that, no one will talk face to face
As the parent of a (second generation) "misfit" kid, the kids are doing fine, in my opinion.
In the narrow slice of the world I have visibility into, it does genuinely seem like school culture is significantly more accepting of a wider range of folks. While I can obviously only speak to my suburban/rural school district in Central New York, I do have the interesting viewpoint of watching my kid attend the same school I did 25-30 years ago. One thing I can say with 100% certainty is that I would have been bullied mercilessly if I showed up in the same way they do today, but they have an active social life and participate in several active social circles that would not have been available to me.
I do think your "us vs them" mentality (i.e. "the majority got their brain fried" as if you are somehow superior and no susceptible to outside influence) is as much a part of the problem as the school environments you seek to blame.
As the part of three kids in 5th through 9th grade, the phone ban is an unqualified good, in my opinion.
They will be fine, and imho better for it. They’ll still do whatever they chose after school, but this way they’ll also learn how to deal with people that are not exactly a choice and they’ll have space to get a bit bored and, you know, think.
>Kids won't have that escape hatch anymore once you blanket ban these devices.
How about people learn to work with the people around them instead of running away to online communities?
Online communities are not all positive. They can bring many negatives, many of which are phrased as positives because they make people feel good whole atrophying or deskilling them.
I mean this reads genuinely ignorant, but falsely pretending it's good faith, at the very least, "learning to work with what is there" is quite resource-intensive, and with that could be seen as an unfair disadvantage for a certain type of kid.
Because they're not just busy doing homework and assignments and all but also have to juggle a much higher mental load on top.
The internet and internet communities are no silver bullet either, but "well just don't do that" is not doing the valid needs of various members of society justice.
___
It might be easier to empathize with the whole problem cluster if you view the problem like you view people with physical disabilities. Those too don't get told "well just fit in, lol", but have support systems in place.
"Nachteilsausgleich" is a very german term that comes to mind there.
Of course, it's not the same. But it helps for the mental model.
The correct solution wouldn't be the internet but - as I said - "school environments that work for all kinds of people", but - also as I said - I do not see that happening any time soon.
Maybe selectively in some schools due to some teachers making it their personal mission but certainly not on a systemic level. It is however a systemic issue.
My kids (16 and 13) both attend schools that recently implemented phone bans and they love it, somewhat surprisingly. They've commented on how one of their favorite things about school is actually the social aspect. Before the ban, at lunch or study halls or recess, kids would just be on their phones and now they're laughing and goofing off, as kids should be doing.
Bonkers to me that we ever allowed this.
Oh, and for context, the kids are allowed to go to the office and check in on a message or send a text (e.g., soccer practice is canceled due to rain, can you pick me up at 4?) during any non-class period so it's still easy to communicate.
You don't know what you have until you don't have it. This generation knows what it's like with phones because they experienced school with phones. The next generation who grows up with the phone ban will probably think it's pretty stupid, because they don't know what it was like without it. Then they'll repeal it again and go through the same cycle.
My older son (12) has his phone on my desk, and I unlock it for him when he wants it. Tried many times to give him full access, only to find out the phone usage skyrocketed to several hours a day.
When they go on a school trip, he's usually the only one without a phone and watches others glued to their screens, even when they have free time to run in a park.
Now, finally, the school purchased a box where kids lock their phones in at the start of the day and recover them at the end. They seem to enjoy it as well.
Interesting. How does he handle it? I mean, does he ever get angry about it or feel excluded by the other kids? Kids can be mean.
Of course, he would want to have a phone like other kids. On the train, he usually finds someone else to talk to or reads a book. Last trip he's talked to some girls which he otherwise wouldn't if he'd have a phone. At times, he gets frustrated, sometimes angry, but I try to talk him out of it, which sometimes works, sometimes it doesn't.
We just don't give our daughter (11) a phone. She has a smart watch that can text us and a few other whitelisted phone numbers (or call them). I don't think middle school kids need an actual phone.
Coming to a workplace near you soon (already here in places).
Have you never worked a job outside of an office? Many, many workplaces ban phones, and have for decades.
A little off-topic for schools, but honestly, I was always shocked by the amount of lost productivity to phones in the white-collar workplace. I worked in a cube farm, and walking around nearly everyone at their desk was looking at their phone at any given time. I can guarantee you that, most of the time, what they were looking at wasn't work related, or at best maybe it was related in a peripheral way (stock prices, industry gossip, etc.)
The "attention tax" that is paid to a handful of firms in Silicon Valley is really unbelievable.
That's wild. In my workplace, I rarely see that. If it's that visible, how come they aren't reprimanded for it? I'd think excessive phone-use would affect how much they get done too (in a visible way).
It's not just productivity. It alters the workplace socially, typically in negative ways. Rather than getting to know one's colleagues and accept them for who they are, animosity flourishes over trivial things. (I'm not claiming that workplaces were anywhere near perfect before cell phones, you still had jerks and gossiping cliques. But a lot of the time I'm like, "pull your nose away from the phone and get to know them, you may actually like them.)
Granted, I have worked in places where the only convenient social contact you have is with people within a 1 km radius. So you either got to know the people you worked with, isolated yourself, were paying hefty long-distance bills, or were burning your paycheques to fly to the nearest city every weekend.
> Bonkers to me that we ever allowed this.
I don't understand when it become allowed honestly. Like when I was at school, phones were never allowed. If a teacher saw one they'd confiscate it and your parents would have to come and collect it.
That was before the absolute worst addictive dark patterns etc. Which means that someone looked at the world after that point and said "yeah actually, phones are ok now" which baffles me
> Which means that someone looked at the world after that point and said "yeah actually, phones are ok now" which baffles me
more like someone looked at the world after that point and said "yeah actually that makes us a lot more money"
Phones in class seemed to be the result of the inability to deal with school shootings.
That doesn’t make sense, phones are common in EU classrooms as well and they don’t have the school shooting problem.
and in the UK, and lots of other countries too.
How so? I'm not following your logic here.
My recollection was the vocal complaints about banning phones in classes was from people who were concerned that their kid needed a phone to call for help if Columbine happened. This was 20 years ago before smartphones.
Parents insisted that they needed to be in contact with their kids. Not being able to text the kids was a safety issue and strong inconvenience.
an inconvenience we had lived with for all of humanity.
When I was a kid my parents just called the school
I'm both confused and not terribly surprised that people don't seem to recall that's an option.
Today's parents are the kids who were raised to never talk to strangers (for "safety") and so are largely also extremely adverse to that sort of "call a stranger" option.
Don't call a stranger. Call the school.
I am still absolutely perplexed and bamboozled by the actual real fact that there are parents texting their children at school, during classes, to check how they are doing on a daily basis.
School shootings. That's the safety issue parents are imagining.
Especially in a case of school shooting, parents shouldn't be calling their kids.
They are expecting their kids to text them so they can call the police.
Which is frankly bonkers on its own. Kids should know to call 911 first if they believe they are in a life threatening situation. Relaying information back through a parent who’s not on location is not ideal
The last thing emergency services need during a calamity is a horde of random people calling them about the thing theyre already aware of.
I got emergency response training from my university when I was on the board of an association and one of the big things they told us was, call the university emergency number rather than 112 because we (the university) are in more direct contact with emergency services, have well thought out calamity plans, a better overview of things like open buildings and where people are, cameras, etc.
Wow, there really are a lot of goddamned stupid parents
Yeah, like imagine your kid is hiding from the shooter, and their phone buzzes or rings because you called to check on them.
We really don't hate the media enough. An extremely rare occurrence that gets boosted whenever one occurs has convinced every parent in America it's happening everywhere, constantly, and thus we need to compromise the education of every student in the school to work around it.
Might as well leave your kid home at that point, iPad in hand. Even less ""risk"" when they were never going to learn anything at school anyway if they are allowed access to devices.
Extremely rare?
please, the US propaganda is strong here. That is the only country in the world where guns are so normalised that parents are legitimately worried about a random person shooting their kids in a school. Wikpiedia has multiple pages of school shootings in the US, so many that they have been grouped by decade. Five people were killed just a month back. In 2025, 71 school shootings happened. That is absolutely insane.
Seriously, take a good, long, hard, look at your usage of the term "extremely rare".
You're more likely to die being driven to school than you are in a school shooting. Of those 71 - how many were targeted gang on gang violence?
With over 100,000 schools - school shootings, as common as they are when compared to other countries, still classify as an "extremely rare event".
To compare it against other common concerns. You should be more worried about your child drowning than them going through a school shooting and more worried about them choking on their school lunch every day than them dying in a school shooting.
That parents worry about it and whether parents should be worrying about it are two different things.
which country has "active shooter drills" in schools as part of "normal" life?
Could you please explain why these exist in only one country?
It is truly amazing the levels of mental gymnastics and excuses that people in the US make instead of admitting that guns are a problem.
The point in question is whether allowing children to have phones in schools is a vital need so that they can communicate with their parents during shootings, not whether guns are a problem in the U.S. I would say definitely no to the former and definitely yes to the latter.
[delayed]
I've been looking for international data for a long time. I've come up short on a good, citation-quality source. Can you share?
Are you certain that America is the only one? Are we considering all countries, or are we talking about a subset?
> We really don't hate the media enough
The media isn't shooting kids.
> An extremely rare occurrence
26 school shootings have occurred in 2026 alone as of Oct 16. [1] That's not extremely rare to me. Extremely rare are the typical things Republicans campaign on, like widespread voter fraud or schools performing sex change operations.
> has convinced every parent in America it's happening everywhere,
Schools have active shooter drills. This has, in fact, saved lives. It's not something that doesn't happen.
I mean, it's happening in most states. Just not all the time.
But no, blame the media instead of blaming the shooters and the government that doesn't do anything to prevent it even when it knows how.
1. https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/articles/states-with...
If you look at the actual underlying data [0] most of these school shootings are escalations of fights, especially at football games. These are not what most people think of when they think of 'school shootings', where someone is rampaging through the halls executing everyone they see.
[0]: https://www.edweek.org/leadership/school-shootings-this-year...
Yeah from 2000-2025, there have been 35 "active shooter" type school shootings. There were roughly 30 "school shootings" per year between 1992 and 1999. They dropped to about 15 per year until 2020 when the number spiked back up to the 30 range where we are now
The USA is big, but 415 deaths in 405 shootings in 2026 is not exactly "rare" to justify kids having a phone. I don't totally disagree with your though. It's the same kind of slippery slope that leads to everyone having a massive truck to protect themselves.
You appear to be looking at this data [0], which is for all "mass shootings" not school shootings in particular.
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mass_shootings_in_the_...
And much like having a massive truck, having a phone might make you feel better but it does little to nothing to actually make you safer.
Extremely rare? Not in the US. There's about 250-350 school shootings a year in the US. More than 1 a day
>There's about 250-350 school shootings a year in the US. More than 1 a day
There's almost 1000 civil aviation accidents per year in the US, so 3x more than school shootings, yet most people don't go on a plane thinking this is something that will surely happen to them every time they board.
So yeah, the way media handles accidents has a huge impact on how gen-pop perceives threats.
Remember, the point of the media is to ragebait and fearmonger you to drive views and engagement, not to educate you. For education, you'll have to read books and papers.
250-300 school shootings a year still seems crazy. By comparison, in the UK we have had 1 in total (not per year).
>250-300 school shootings a year still seems crazy.
When you factor in US guns/capita, easy access to firearms over there compared to anywhere else in the world, prevalence of mental illnesses, drug use, bullying, average crime rates in the area etc, it's not actually that much. Plus if you start to deep dive, highest chances of shootings tend to be clustered into a few hotspot areas, that if you avoid, then chances of school shooting drop to zero.
For Americans it might also seem crazy that people in the UK have 800–1,200+ times[1] the chance of getting stabbed than US children getting shot, and at how many people in UK get arrested for online speech that would be protected under the first amendment in the US, so it's never apples to apples comparisons between countries, as everything differs.
> For Americans it might also seem crazy how many people in UK get arrested for online speech
I mean, I would agree that this a problem! Still, I'd rather be arrested (most of these people are never actually charged with anything) than my children be shot.
>most of these people are never actually charged with anything
Because as they say, "The Process Is the Punishment".
>I'd rather be arrested
I'd rather not, since it's something that can be avoided, by not having a government that treats 1984 as a model. But you can't really control if someone one day decides to stab or shoot you the same way you can't control if you get hit by lightning or by a drunk driver.
>than my children be shot
Most american school children will never be shot regardless of what they do. But the chance of speech arrest in the UK depends on what you say to who.
People do text their loved ones to let them know they have landed
The planes most people fly on are extremely safe. You're safer on one of those than you are in your own shower. The average number of airliner crashes per year in the US over the past decade is 0.1. The figure you quoted includes small planes, which are orders of magnitude more dangerous, especially small planes operated by hobby pilots. As a hobby pilot myself, I'd say that if you get in a plane like that without at least making sure your life insurance is paid up, you're fooling yourself. And most people do think small planes are kind of dangerous (and rightfully so).
Bad example aside, this is certainly a real phenomenon. It's not about ragebait or fearmongering. Those certainly don't help, but even news that deliberately avoids those and only tries to inform will suffer from it. News is, by definition, unusual. The more unusual it is, the more news it is. A fatal car crash might get a one-sentence mention in the local media. A business jet crash makes national headlines. A fatal airliner crash makes international headlines for months. That can easily form an upside-down impression of their frequency if folks aren't thinking about how news works.
Quick search reports that just commercial airline incidents are responsible for 857 deaths since 2000 while school shooting deaths total 220. So the point stands especially if you tried to account for more hours spent in school than on a commercial airliner. Per hour your airliner is probably orders of magnitude more likely to crash and kill you than a student is likely to die in a shooting.
Yes, it is extremely rare. As a comparison, the US has about 40,000 deaths from car crashes per year. About 110 deaths per day. Your kid's risk of dying on the drive to school is 10,000% higher than from being shot during the day.
Also, the school shooting statistics grossly misrepresent the real risk for the average family, because distribution is extremely biased towards violence that happens in a tiny number of high schools with high crime, drug and gang problems.
Few things are as emotionally overwhelming as the idea of your child being killed, so people react based on how strongly they feel about the issue, not by rationally assessing the real risk. A Columbine-style random mass shooter is like being afraid of a shark attack at the beach - it strikes terror into people, but it's not factually in the top hundred or thousand things you should rationally be worried about.
Pretty sure 350 < 365, decidedly less than 1 per day
School day
> Extremely rare? Not in the US. There's about 250-350 school shootings a year in the US. More than 1 a day
Where are you getting this data. I think that's way off. [0] Says 268 since 2018, where a school shooting is any shooting on school property, whether during school hours or not.
[0]: https://www.edweek.org/leadership/school-shootings-this-year...
The data on school shootings is very inconsistent. In most of the sources, a shooting between gangs that happens on a weekend at 2am that happens to be in school grounds is reported as a school shooting. So is any other murder between anyone on campus including staff, etc, even if they're not "mass" or "random" killings. Even suicide is often counted in these lists.
The closest analog we have for "person goes into a school while it's in session to kill people at random" is the FBI's list of "active shooter" incidents, and only some of those are counted as "Mass killings", and the data there says we've has as little as 3 (in 2024) and as many as 15 (in 2023) per year in the past 5 years: https://usafacts.org/articles/what-is-considered-a-mass-shoo...
And that 3-15 number is all mass killings, not just in schools (I don't know how many of those were in schools, but we could stipulate maybe 1 in 3?)
So, the 250-350 number is a couple of orders of magnitude higher than the type of school shootings parents are actually worried about when it comes to needing to text them during the day.
In 2025 there were 18 incidents where someone was injured with a firearm on school grounds and 6 of those happened during school hours. In total three students were murdered across two separate school shootings.
If ‘school shooting’ statistics are anything like other gun violence statistics, the vast majority of those are inner city gang activity in the vague vicinity of a public school, not Columbine copycats.
People often imagine school shootings as school mass schooting, despite these are a tiny fraction of school schootings.
Not an American, but have family living there. In two separate occasions, my nephews were in a lockdown because of a potential shooter in the area. The problem is, the hoaxes, bomb threats and etc. do not contribute to the statistics, but they make everything much worse.
I'm very sorry to say this, but I have no idea how you guys live like that.
> I'm very sorry to say this, but I have no idea how you guys live like that.
Unrelated to the topic, but keep this in mind when you see or read any news coming out of the U.S. There is no war on U.S. soil, so it's not a literal war zone, but the population has been living in a similar state of heightened arousal perpetually since Sept. 11, 2001. Everyone's brain has been paralyzed with fight-or-flight since then. Constant state of being afraid and on edge, fed and amplified by the media and the politicians (who are all victims of it as well, to some degree). You can't make rational decisions when in constant panic. It becomes a feedback loop of panic and overreaction, over-correction, and irrational actions causing more fear and paranoia- some justified, some not. I truly believe this explains a lot of what has happened to the country in the last decades.
That's a great description of the first few years after 9/11. But now, bollocks. Sure, there are always-online people that are like this, but not your average Joe on the street, at least where I live.
lol what the ACTUAL fuck are you talking about
> An extremely rare occurrence
The US has anything around 250-350 shootings a year (I wonder where the spike during covid comes from?!) [1]. The entirety of Europe including the European parts of Russia and Turkey struggles to reach 10 incidents a year [2], with quite a few of them being barely relevant (accidental discharge, mafia drive-by gone bad). Europe is about the same size as the US and has about double the population, so the risk per person and year to experience a shooting is orders of magnitude more large than in the US.
On top of that, gun violence and accidents are the top killer for children and young adolescents in the US [3].
You don't have a problem with the media, you have a problem with guns. And with "you" I mean "Americans as a whole", because Switzerland and Czechia (the countries with the most permissive firearms regulations and similar ownership rates to the US) don't have school shootings being a thing.
[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1463594/number-of-k-12-s...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_school_shootings_in_Eu...
[3] https://publichealth.jhu.edu/2024/guns-remain-leading-cause-...
This line got brought up constantly at a local school board meeting when a phone policy was being drafted (And is brought up by parents to admin when their children are reprimanded for phone use)
It appears to be either:
A. An excuse to get their kid out of trouble for scrolling TikTok & Reels during class
B. A weak attempt to provide a socially-justifiable reason for the parent’s general anxiety (constantly texting their kid, watching their precise location, using Life360 to see their messages with peers and fine-grained activity)
C. A futile effort to exercise control over a hypothetical situation where the parent is stripped of control. What are you going to do if you get a text saying “there’s a shooter in the school”? Call the police? The faculty all have phones and are doing the same. Text them back saying “okay I love you”?
C. In Uvalde parents got their kids out of the school while the police stood around and did nothing. But yes, being able to say "I love you" means something.
A horrible failure by police to do their job. The police also actively restrained and handcuffed parents who were trying to get in to the school.
Taking a broader look at the situation, kids being rescued in heroic efforts by parents when police are actively not doing their job or making a situation worse, the solution to this is probably not unregulated phone access for children during school hours.
I've gone through a version of this as a parent. One afternoon, I received a phone call from my son as he and his class were fleeing into the woods behind his school due to shots fired on the campus. As I drove the 30 minutes to an area near his school (not to the school, I didn't want to be in the way or in danger) and was passed by a constant stream of police vehicles, the only thing keeping me sane was the occasional message from my son. He and dozens of schoolmates made it to a neighborhood near the school where people that were home took them in, fed them, and helped them feel safe.
As it turned out, the actual issue was a hoax call about a student with a gun and an accidental gun misfire by an investigating police officer leading to a "shots fired" emergency.
All that said, I still think phones in school is a net negative for the kids. It's a massive distraction.
Our school district has had a number of similar “false alarms” in the last few years. Usually about once season.
Students will notice something concerning (an unidentified object in someone’s backpack, a threatening comment online by a peer, a rumor, etc) and text their parents instead of reporting it to an adult at the school who could investigate.
The parents (not knowing what else to do since they are not in the school) call police, tell other parents, post on social media. Leading to a wave of parents calling the front office and rushing to pick up their kids from class early.
That's a comfort thing rather than a safety thing. In a version of that story where he didn't have a phone, the eventual outcome would have been the same.
The actual safety argument is really thin. You'd need a situation where the adults are out of contact, the kids are in a position to use their phones, they aren't in a position to use a wall phone or find a friendly adult, and somehow that communication is critical to their survival. I'm not sure this ever happens, even rarely.
>accidental gun misfire by an investigating police officer leading to a "shots fired" emergency
Cops are jokes, man. They should be required to have a 4-year degree and pass military style firearms training, not whatever gobbledygook is happening at the academies.
Parents want to text their kids during the school day in places where this is not a concern. You only need a few sufficiently needy or neurotic parents to get the schools to relax policies (which is also why legislation to ban phones helps even if schools ‘should’ all have bans anyway: they get to say that their hands are forced if parents complain)
In post-USSR of the late 90s and early 00s it was a safety measure because of all of the street crime.
I've heard the rise of safety-ism and anxiety can be linked to the missing children photos on the back of milk jugs in the 70s. Also throw in media streaming national news instead of local news and you get a distorted idea of the dangers in your local community.
Maybe the terrorism and other turmoil in the 70s sunk into the generational subconscious and also contributes to the modern anxiety.
Anyway, parents (among others) are anxious and can be influenced/manipulated by playing into those fears
Today's parents of school-aged kids largely weren't even born in the 70s, so milk jug thing probably isn't true. (I'm about to turn 50, born in '77, if I had a kid at 30, they'd be 20 and out of school).
But, the national media, with it's need to get views/clicks/engagement, pushes a steady stream of outrage-porn, doom-porn, anxiety-porn, whatever you want to call it. And I suspect that doesn't help anybody.
> parents texting their children at school, during classes, to check how they are doing on a daily basis.
That's the least surprising part, to me. The immediately severely addictive nature of The Devil's Whispering Obsidian Mirror of Everlasting Distraction is more of a "why didn't the teachers ban it sooner?" thing than a "why might parents who have the same addiction, prefer using their Endless Scroll Distraction Oblong to talk to their kids than spend another minute doing whatever boring job the economy forced upon them?"
15 years ago, when my then-girlfriend was phoning me in the middle of the work day, it was surprising; but then, I am a massive introvert*, and by the power of the Typical Mind Fallacy** the idea of people wanting to just hang out with me all day was a thing I had to learn rather than it just being my expectation the whole time.
We're a social species. Checking in on each other is the norm. Parents on their kids, moreso. I wish now my parents had been more like that than they were, though I finished school at basically the same year 84x48 black and white 2G phones got affordable: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nokia_8210
* an introvert? On a nerd website? Surely not! :P
** https://www.lesswrong.com/w/typical-mind-fallacy
But what's the root cause analysis? Big tech infesting our society with social media addiction so that they can personally profit from it.
Everyone who builds these products and profits from doing so is responsible for this.
So what is the solution? It seems to me that we should look at what was done to the tobacco companies in the previous century. Regulate these companies and fine them for the damage that they've intentionally caused to society.
Imagine how much better off we’d be, with capacity to nimbly and efficiently both establish new regulations and repeal existing ones. We do the opposite, make it difficult to regulate and difficult to deregulate. Much commerce, especially tech, depends upon the lack of regulatory agility, especially since it often allows the industry to supply the agility when needed by writing the regulations themselves, or guiding via lobby.
perceived safety issue
Despite the fact parents could always contact the school as they did for us growing up
It was never a safety issue. We survived generations without it.
Unfortunately, parents now are very worried about school shootings. That just wasn't a concern until the last two or three generations (the Columbine shooting happened when millennials were in grade school).
It is my perception that school shootings are less frequent after covid. Is that true ?
Nope, 2023 was a record year for the number of school shootings. And the overall trend line continues to go up, with increased lethality per shooting as well.
There were 21 people killed in 2023 from school shootings.
This is fewer than "deaths in a hot car" (1/2), "familial homicide" (1/10), and "deaths from traffic" (1/50). Cancer, suicide, and (inferential from various studies) obesity all outrank it.
As I recall from the last time I dug this up, this is fewer deaths than "people falling off of their roof" and lower than the annualized rate of fatal lightning strikes (2006-2025).
Strange then that none of those drive policy, and we instead focus on a thing that is astonishingly unlikely to occur.
So it’s unlikely to happen, move on?
Some principals
- Spend finite resources where they will have more, rather than less, impact
- Diminishing returns can mean that reducing the prevalence of an outcome from 1% to 0.01% is less expensive than reducing it from 0.01% to 0.005%
- That an outcome is tragic does not intrinsically mean "something must be done". Sometimes all possible "somethings" carry costs that outweigh the benefit
In this context, the "something" that is proposed is "bringing phones into school" which has demonstrably
- not reduced shooting incidence
- Nor reduced its harm
- increased antisocial behavior and depression
- Reduced school performance outcomes
So "moving on" would have been better than what happened in this case, yes.
Unfortunately no the frequency is increasing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_school_shootings_in_th...
Across the US, there has been a massive increase in gunfire at schools, starting 2021. Often, the rate is at least 1 shooting per school day.
Source: https://everytownresearch.org/maps/gunfire-on-school-grounds...
This seems to be true. Depending on how you define each.
Speaking very roughly, a random person is more likely to be hospitalized due to covid than to be even at a school while a gun is fired there.
CDC estimates that this week alone there will be 5100 covid hospitalizations, while Everytown (cited below by robby_w_g) tallied 107 incidents of gunfire at school for the entire year-to-date.
https://www.cdc.gov/cfa-modeling-and-forecasting/covid19-dat...
I suspect they're lying. They probably didn't want the stress of their moody teen whinging about the phone ban.
What are they planning to do? Call their kid, who is hiding, and let the shooter hear where the kid is?
People lie on the internet, and sometimes even lie to themselves. I can almost guarantee that most of them just have some other motive.
The kids are statistically much more likely to kill themselves. Mental health should take a priority.
Some school shootings are elaborate suicides, after all.
As if texting your mom while a shooter is running loose in the building would change anything. Come on, let's be serious, parents cannot help in that situation.
Kids don't need to have their phones on them during class "for safety". On the way to and from school, sure, but once they're at school, stow them somewhere.
i think it’s more about helping the parents know their kid is still alive so they don’t go insane but i agree phones should be restricted in schools
Parents seem worried about kids too here in the UK where we don't have school shootings. I think everyone is just so used to a world where we have constant contact with anyone at all times.
School shootings aren't a concern. Just picking a random year from google-- there were 21 school shooting deaths in 2023.
Compare with other causes of death for kids
- 29 from vehicular heatstroke
- ~300 (1/100k) familial homicides
- 1014 traffic fatalities
Even if it were a concern having a phone in such a scenario may make for good hollywood, but is terrible from a safety viewpoint. The last thing you want during a lockdown is phones clogging the network and ringing as kids try to hide.
Parent's aren't worried about school shootings because they're mathematically a concern, parents are worried because they're emotionally terrifying. People are bad at evaluating risk, and you can't solve that problem by just pointing at some numbers.
Policy decisions should definitely be based on statistics and not feelings though, and "pointing at some numbers" is a great way to structure a disagreement about policy.
I agree, nothing should be done to save kids from school shootings, because they're rare.
Arguing in bad faith is fun! But you are right: We should allow an entire generation of kids to suffer from phone-induced brainrot so that their parents don't have to worry about school shootings.
School boards are elected, and highest turnout for those is going to be among parents. If a majority of parents have a concern then the school board has to listen if they want to keep their position.
Sometimes feelings turn into statistics (eg anxiety, depression, etc). You can't always just tell people to walk it off. Sometimes you can, but sometimes it absolutely has to actually be handled (gun control).
People are afraid of whatever they are told to be afraid of in the media. It's not about numbers and probabilities.
I think this is one of the most inhumane statements I’ve read in a while on here.
How is this inhumane? Because it calls attention to the scourage of vehicular child killing? The bloodbath on the highway? Can you not admit there's something curious in the way people selectively care about things regardless of their importance or solveability?
That number should be 0. As a parent of a child in a country that doesn't have issues with school shootings, the fact that kids are taught how to protect themselves during a school shooting from a very young age, aren't allowed to wear light-up shoes to not be seen too easily by a shooter, some states even argue that teachers should carry. This is very concerning to me. Enough that I would not choose to move to the US for fear of the safety of my kids. Arguing that kids die from other causes too diminishes the urgency of the situation, which I understand is your point, but you might want to reconsider.
> the Columbine shooting happened when millennials were in grade school
I'm a millennial and it happened when I was in high school. But yeah, there was maybe only one incident with a gun at my high school before then (not a shooting, kid just had a starter pistol in his backpack) and I don't recall ever thinking of a school shooting until Columbine happened.
That doesn't explain it though. Millennials were allowed to have phones with us, they just had to be kept silent and out of sight at all times during the school day. They were already available to us in case of a real emergency, there was no need to relax the rules to account for school shootings.
I don't see this as a legitimate concern because their child can simply have a phone and not use it unless needed. In the unlikely circumstance that a school shooting occurs while their phone is confiscated another room, I'm sure they can borrow a phone from a classmate.
How will a phone save my child’s life in a school shooting?
That doesn’t explain it in most parts of the world where school shootings aren’t a thing parents would list on their top 20 things they worry about though.
What is the proposed mechanism where the phone helps during the active shooter event
Canada has almost no school shootings but also went down the "cellphones in glass" sinkhole[1].
[1] https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/canada-school-cellphones-ban-...
For a lot of parents it absolutely was. Active shooter drills have been a normal thing for this generation.
The same change in accepting phones also happened outside the USA, where your children being shot during school generally isn't a concern.
That’s still not a safety issue. Letting the kid text mom at lunch break is not going to have any impact on what happens in a school shooting
Whether or not it's just in their head, the fact that the chance of your child being shot to death is high enough that the school runs practice drills is so disturbing that some parents need an extra security blanket.
Parents wanted their kids to have phones in school to treat their (the parents') anxiety. It doesn't do anything to stop a shooter or any other problem, but you can blast off a bunch of texts to your kid if you're worried about them.
It's a shame that so many parents basically traded their kids' social development for relief from some temporary bad feelings.
I was never worried about my school being shot up in the early 1990's, that's the difference
plenty of things were absolutely safety issues that most people survived without
Yes but we didn't used to have one school shooting every day.
We still don’t, bro
We survived those generations by having land lines that people could find anywhere they went. That doesn’t exist anymore.
Survivorship bias.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias
Humans used to survive without any type of technology at all, just a fire in a cave with a pointy stick. Doesn't mean people want to do that.
"safety issue" of moms who need more valium.
I think that, when used well, the ability to communicate was more about giving kids extra freedom than about increasing safety. I was not born before the wide availability of landline phones, so I don’t have a direct comparison. But it was pretty great to be able to easily call home and say something like “hey, is it okay if I go out with some friends and come back later than usual?” or “there’s an activity I’d like to do that will make me miss the bus - can you pick me up?”.
In the pay phone era, the use of phones at school was asymmetrical: kids could call parents, but parents mostly could not call kids.
Before the phone era, you wouldn't have to make those calls, because your parents didn't care what you were up to. You could even stay over with friends for a few days without telling your parents and it wouldn't have mattered a whole lot.
Then, of course, the media was full of scary murderers during the late 1960s and 1970s and things changed. Laws also changed to get parents on the hook.
Without any sort of phone, I might have been less inclined to do an unplanned activity that would keep me at school after the school bus left, because getting home by public transit was obnoxiously slow, it was too far to credibly walk, a safe bike route basically didn’t exist, and none of my friends were old enough to have a car. But I was lucky that my parents’ commutes were such that one of them could come and get me after work if I managed to arrange it. Which I sometimes did by using the aforementioned pay phone to call their office.
I don’t know about any relevant laws, but this was a big city, well after the 1970s. I semi-regularly walked myself a mile or so after elementary school to a parent’s office and no one batted an eye, but this may have been partially a result of the fact that the route was quite safe and largely car-free. Hmm, maybe the problem with kids’ freedom these days has as much to do with busy roads dividing up the world as with fear of school shootings.
I think that public transit in the particular area where my middle school was would have been, if anything, worse in the pre-phone era.
As a young kid we had to ask the office to make a call. When we were older we had a student (landline) phone for outgoing calls that we didn’t have to ask to use.
Parents called the office and left messages directly or had the kids call back.
I grew up in the early 90s, pagers were common among doctors and drug dealers, but cell phones were largely a novelty (and those that did exists were the size of shoe boxes, so usually mounted in a car's center console).
If mom or dad needed to contact me, they called the office. If it was urgent, the office dispatched somebody to come get me out of class. This happened to me approximately never, but on odd occasion it did happen to somebody.
And as noted, if I needed to contact mom or dad, I used the pay phone. If it was just "come and get me from sport practice", I didn't even feed in a quarter, I just called collect and they didn't bother accepting.
Parents are a bit insane today. Growing up (pre-teens through teens), I could disappear for the better part of a day and it was no big deal. I'd ride my bike into the city (20 miles each way). I'd go skiing with friends and be gone until well after dark.
Similarly, when my son was a similar age, he's skateboard all around town. He had a cell phone for part of that period, but we pretty much never texted him and he was even less likely to text us. Kids need to stretch their wings.
Completely understandable desire on the part of parents.
With that context, it seems like the core problem with having phones in schools might be the "smart" part, due to the amount of competing content that is brought into a student's presence when they should be focussed on socializing and academic work.
On the other hand, non-smart phones are decidedly boring. Has any school attempted allowing non-smart phones only? Really curious what the outcomes might be.
> That was before the absolute worst addictive dark patterns etc. Which means that someone looked at the world after that point and said "yeah actually, phones are ok now" which baffles me
Zeitgeist went too deep into phone normalization. Kids are being raised by parents who were mad their phones were taken away when they were in school. Kids complain, parents then complain to admin or teachers, and teachers' authority to take away a phone slips bit by bit by bit.
The cheeky thing about a teacher's authority is, like all authority, it isn't actually real, it just exists by the consent of those over whom the authority is exerted. "Consent" being used loosely - if you can convince people via rhetoric, tricking them, intimidation or whatever, then that counts too. Anyway point is, when all the students decide together that the teacher can't actually make them put their phones away, then that becomes reality. Teachers also learn not to waste their social capital / authority on demanding something they can't get.
The teacher's job has always been hard, but I've a lot of friends and family that have been teachers up to the last 20 years, and it is absolutely getting harder. Glad to hear some school districts are getting the right idea and banning phones, kids just aren't equipped with the tools to protect their attention from those that would leech it to sell to advertisers. Maybe none of us are.
Phonification of the world is right. Remember this xkcd?
https://xkcd.com/1802/
It used to be a funny premise that somebody would carry their phone just because they were leaving the house.
When I was in high school, there was a payphone in the atrium. Then everyone started carrying their own phones and they took the payphones out, so now if you don't have a phone you really are stuck.
Happened in real life, too. A few years ago I was out of town when my phone died and needed to get from one hotel to another. No problem, I thought, get a cab. Oops, hotels don't have a cab stand any more. Call one? No payphone in the lobby. The front desk doesn't have a phone, either. Lowest friction path was buying a charger. Good thing businesses just let you plug in anywhere these days.
What about that one?
https://www.xkcd.com/1348/
Blows my kids' minds the fact that sometimes, you couldn't watch cartoons, because there were no cartoons "on."
Or waiting till a certain time, because only then you could watch your favourite show.
I think you are giving too much credit to us!
The problem was already entrenched before anyone noticed and cared.
Not just a school issue: my 8 yr old daughter asked me to install a TikTok alternative on her iPad. She’s not allowed to use it much - long care rides mostly.
But she found out from a friend who lives in a home with a more liberal policy. Happened on a playdate after school. And so I am negotiating from behind the curve.
Similar for me - but I don’t think that answers the question you’re responding to.
There were parents that let their kids drink in 7th grade when I was in school - but still kids today are not allowed to bring Jim Beam to class, just like then.
Something definitely shifted with the phones, it’d be interesting to see a documentary or read a book about how it ended up being allowed in the classrooms..
It was because only the bourgeois kids had them at first, and these weren’t just average kids — their parents were were in the know techies and early adopters, Steve Jobs stans, yuppies. “If the ‘in the know’ families have cell phones”, thought normie America, “my kids should too.” Iow, blame hn here, and the early adoption crowd whose lack of wisdom and lust for the shiny got us.
The tech elite famously didn't give their children devices.
> Something definitely shifted with the phones, it’d be interesting to see a documentary or read a book about how it ended up being allowed in the classrooms..
The children in schools aged out of being Gen Z (raised by Gen X) and into Gen Alpha (raised by Millennials). I think that goes pretty far to explain the shift.
I've never personally met a strict millennial parent, while my parents (and those of my peers) when I was in school seemingly still held more 'old-school' values like refusing to give their children smartphones until highschool (or until they got their own job and could buy it with their own money), being willing to ground (and punish) their kids, and restricting screen time.
It's definitely a tough situation. Our kids aren't phone-aged yet but even toddlers are getting iPads as default for outings and even home life in some situations. I've heard people say that when they are more strict about phone access for older kids, the kids will just end up with secret accts on their friends devices. Yet again tech goes faster than we can figure it out
What period of time are you referencing?
I understand your example but am trying to align the example to phones
>But she found out from a friend who lives in a home with a more liberal policy. Happened on a playdate after school. And so I am negotiating from behind the curve.
This is precisely why it can't be solved without collective action.
And what's crazy is that studies have found that while kids don't want to be left out of social media, they do want everyone to be off it. Which is more or less corroborated by the top level comment:
>My kids (16 and 13) both attend schools that recently implemented phone bans and they love it, somewhat surprisingly.
in 2023 my eldest went to high school and was told that sometimes they would have to use their phone in class to do classwork.
> I don't understand when it become allowed honestly. Like when I was at school, phones were never allowed. If a teacher saw one they'd confiscate it and your parents would have to come and collect it.
When and where was this? Before smartphones, teachers (at my school, Sweden, 90s/early 00s sometime) didn't give a crap about phones as long as you didn't play music out loud on it, not until society got infected with social media that teachers started telling kids to put away the phones it seems to me.
I think it was a gradual thing that's why there wasn't a "allow or forbid" moment, it just was, until it was everywhere and literally poisoning people's mind.
UK, around 2000-2015
US, graduated 2008, we were never allowed phones either.
In the US in the early mainstream-cell-phone era (95-05ish), playing with any sort of device in class would get called out if spotted by teachers.
Some of the larger-handed athletes amusingly thought their tiny Nokias were small enough to make it not obvious they were texting/playing Snake on them, but it was pretty easy to spot.
Having it in your backpack if it's not making noise? Sure. Using it? Nah.
In the 1980s it was Sony walkman radios and cassette players kids where getting taken away at school. Though it didn't happen much, I think most kids knew it was a distraction.
Probably due to tablets becoming standard use at school. It was around the same time, and I imagine it felt silly to tell kids they couldn’t use one extremely distracting device while requiring them to use another that is the same thing in a different form factor.
Phone bans are a start. Getting tablets out of the curriculum is next.
I think flip phones were allowed in a lot of schools and then I guess they gradually evolved into smartphones with social media apps?
You didn't use a flip phone in class as all your could do with them was talk which was obvious. Though kids playing snake did get them taken away. For the most part a flip phone was used to call for a ride after school. (much better than waiting in line for 20 minutes for the student phone)
The problem isn't just phones in class, but in school outside of class. We had phones in school, but no use for them - almost all my contacts were my classmates, who would I text?
I still remember when digital watches became affordable - if your hourly chime went off, your watch was confiscated.
A whole bunch more school shootings scared parents into wanting connectivity, plus ability to track kids through safety/surveillance tools like Life360
With no thought to what being constantly surveilled does to kids psychologically. As a parent, I know it’s hard, but parents really need to get a handle on their anxiety, helicoptering harms children. Developing independence is a core drive for them.
Anecdotal evidence here, but a number of my family members working in public education have recounted similar stories of parents threatening (or attempting) legal action when a student’s phone or iPad is taken away.
The common rationales from the parents are:
- “What if a school shooting happens? You are making them unsafe!”
- “Their IEP says they need it!” (It almost never does, or calls for device access for a very specific, limited reason tied to a communication tool or educational outcome. Not unlimited video scrolling)
Lots of folks here profited from and advocated for those policies.
It’s always important to consider the impact of your work and whether the dollar earned is worth the damage done.
Also, the “move fast and break things” shouldn’t be allowed anywhere near children.
Not everything is a conspiracy
I was in high school when the iPod touch was huge. They were definitely banned by the letter of the law, but so many kids had them that some teachers just gave up on enforcing the rule. There will always be some number of kids not paying attention or goofing off, and they don't have the energy to enforce the rule 100% of the time. Then, as smartphones became ubiquitous, the soft acceptance just snowballed.
I remember advocating to a teacher that an iPod touch is not a phone and therefore it should not be banned.
In general I think we were only allowed to use phones during math lessons (as calculators). This was at a time when none of us had mobile data and there was like one wifi router in the whole building.
Thats how it was in middle school for me, and then in high school phones were basically always allowed. Its probably not a coincidence that my grades were better in middle school than they were in high school.
IMO one cause of this and many other problems in the public education system is that parents have too much influence in the education system.
Nowadays, if they give a kid a failing grade, there's a good chance the parents show up to try and intimidate their way into a pass... Instead of figuring out why their kid is failing. Same goes if their kid gets into trouble - their angel can do no wrong, why are you being mean?
This kind of stuff was happening 20 years ago, I am not surprised it's gotten worse. Parents by and large are unqualified to make decisions about education, but have outsized influence in it. It's probably a huge reason why the US public educational system has been getting smoked by Europe and east Asia, where parents have less insurance.
> Parents by and large are unqualified to make decisions about education
Especially in the sense of grading and assessment, but I wouldn't generalize this. Both in the sense of do they actually make good decisions on things they can (sometimes) control, such as school (district) selection — barring interesting exceptions like Nikole Hannah-Jones I think they do — and whether they are legally or morally thus qualified. Not that you're implying this, but I bristle a little at the use of the term, since it connotes the removal of parent agency by state action. Caution is advisable there.
They are experts, but they are providing a service. There needs to be a balance. Your doctor is another primary example.
I think one guiding principle is methods vs. values. An expert has more authority on methods, but values need broad alignment between the service provider and the the people they serve. And neither party is entitled to the other - both parties need to feel the relationship is mutually beneficial for the relationship to be sustainable.
So there is some truth in needing to defer to educators, but not absolutely.
>Parents by and large are unqualified to make decisions about education
This attitude will drive people away from public schools (and already has). Parents are major stakeholders in their children's education and public schools must be accountable to the public. For the benefit of everyone, there should be a better process for handling the input from parents.
I think we would agree there needs to be a balance. Arguing about changing an F to some passing grade is wrong. But it's also incentivized by the schools and states to meet metrics, so it's unfair to just cast this blame on the parents. But absolutely parents who do this are in the wrong and schools should not enable it.
Some things experts should have broad leeway on are methods. How they structure a reading curriculum or teach long division. Not so much on enforcing certain goals or values.
And the more results that the schools deliver, the more deference from parents they will be able to expect. But the more contention there is between parents and schools, the worse public school support will become.
We pushed as long as we could against "smart phones" as parents with my two sons.
Eventually gave in when the flip phone my son had as a freshman in high school couldn't run the app the marching band was using to communicate.
A very sad memory with my younger son: I was a chaperone for one of his soccer camps when he was in middle school. I remember down time between games, and thinking this is nice he can spend some time socializing with his teammates. But he was the only one without a phone, and the teammates immediately took out their phones and started scrolling, leaving my son to sit there alone in silence.
(Yeah, maybe I should have tried to convince the other kids to put down their phones, but it was an awkward moment that took me by surprise.)
That's great. I sat at dinner with my teenage nephews after the phone ban had been announced in my state but before it had gone into effect. They were all opposed to the idea and gave several reasons about why they weren't comfortable with giving up their phones. I told them some of the arguments for it and they remained skeptical until I pointed out that _noone_ would have phones and their eyes lit up as they considered the implications of that and they suddenly became excited about the upcoming ban.
I think there are more parents that want their kids reachable at all times and the kids just want to hang with their friends.
Pedantic aside, _no one_ is two words.
Shouldn't that be a colon rather than a comma?
> Before the ban, at lunch or study halls or recess, kids would just be on their phones and now they're laughing and goofing off, as kids should be doing.
During my personal experience working with schools, I've always saw kids off their phones when physically next to each other. Phones were always banned in class, but lunch usually permitted them. I guess social dynamics change from place to place.
> they love it, somewhat surprisingly
The problem with phones, as well as social media, or anything else with a network effect, is that it becomes a prisoner's dilemma. You can recognise the harms, but feel the need to take part anyway, because opting out puts you at a social disadvantage. If everyone opts out, the disadvantage is neutralised
s/social media/AI/g
> Bonkers to me that we ever allowed this.
Bonkers, but what about lobbying by big tech?
> Before the ban, at lunch or study halls or recess, kids would just be on their phones and now they're laughing and goofing off, as kids should be doing.
> Bonkers to me that we ever allowed this.
Mm. You've just reminded me of middle school, where if the kids got too loud during lunch, a teacher might order us to all eat in silence and anyone braking the rule would have to stand alone looking at a wall until the end of the lunch period as punishment.
In retrospect, I have absolutely no idea why that guy even wanted to be a teacher if he wasn't OK with kids socialising while they ate.
Your kids have non-class periods? Lucky them!
> they love it, somewhat surprisingly
I recommend reading The Anxious Generation by Jonathan Haidt. It's a great read on the effects of social media, phones, and general modern society on our youth.
One of the interesting bits in the book was about phone access in school. There are 3 tiers for any kid:
1) everyone has phones, including you 2) everyone has phones, except you 3) no one has phones
Option 2 has been tried by many parents over the years, to lackluster results. Kids basically feel weird and isolated if they're the only one without a phone. Turns out, as you discovered, that if no one has a phone, everyone is happier. It's something no single parent can do, but we're starting to discover that if we implement it across the whole school, it really does work.
This isn't directly related to a school ban, but I can share another anecdote that reinforces your kids' thoughts. I'm a parent of 17 & 15 year olds and regularly (3-4x/yr) chaperone my 15yo daughter's soccer team to regional and national events. It's typically two vanloads of girls -- 18-24 kids -- and up until about three events back we let them have phones until lights out. As expected, if they weren't competing, they were on their phones. We instituted a revised policy last year where we take phones at 9pm (lights out at 10pm) and give them back after breakfast. It's made a world of difference in the camaraderie that's developed, since the girls now have to actually talk with each other. It's also led to improved travel maturity overall, and much more pleasant van rides [with only silent phone use allowed -- typically locked in with their personal pre-match music]. 10/10 do recommend.
> Bonkers to me that we ever allowed this.
It’s not bonkers at all. The reason why phone usage became so prevalent is precisely because of how much we didn’t know. It doesn’t even make logical sense why it’s bad.
That’s how insidious it is because it seems so benign.
When I was in middle school, there would always be kids with a GameBoy or Walkman with a small group gathered around them. Even someone with a Nokia phone and snake was enough to break the boredom we all felt.
Funny as phone bans this September in France is what may have pushed to the youth uprising (and allowing them back was in their demands).
my boys ( ~17 and 14 and a Junior and Freshman US HS respectively) mostly feel the same. Or at least they don't complain about it and are in the routine. Both of them meet up with their friends before school and sometimes after school for clubs. However, the kids still refer to their Yondr Pouches as a "i-can't-call-my-parents-and-tell-them-i-love-them-in-an-emergency pouch" heh.
The study https://cepr.harvard.edu/sites/g/files/omnuum9881/files/2026... finds a ≈0.01 standard-deviation difference in test scores the year lockable phone pouches are adopted, with no detectable additional difference in the following year. Certainly nothing to sneeze at from a system-wide perspective, but easily overwhelmed by other factors for any individual student.
Individual test students are going to be hard to predict anyway. Though I think this is compared to the sample standard deviation, and for most students their improvement over time is going to be smaller than the difference between two random students.
That ≈0.01 SD effect is actually 0.0087 +/- 0.0043 (standard error), giving a 95% confidence interval of roughly 0.0003 to 0.0171 standard deviations.
So the effect could be tiny.
Worse, the report says it excludes observations outside the 0.5th and 99.5th percentiles of the 2021–22 fall-to-spring score-change distribution. I'm not sure how this is defensible. Either you trust your measurement instrument or you don't.
If you're using a difference-in-differences design, excluding observations can change what you're measuring, particularly if the exclusions differ between treatment and control groups or over time. Without trimming those observations, the estimated effect drops from 0.0087 SD to 0.0058 SD (and is no longer statistically significant).
The authors preregistered their study, but there's nothing in the report indicating that the trimming of 'extreme' values was part of that preregistration...
Sounds like they noticed a few extreme outliers were pulling the difference down and hacked it out. Methodologically that’s really sus to do this after the study is done. But generally I think it’s okay to exclude extreme outliers - we generally assume Gaussian distributions, but the real world happens and messes things up. Having a few kids that are 5 or 6 sigma out pulling your averages - I can believe the rules are different for them. But this should have been decided ahead of time.
I emailed the authors and received a reply. That part of the study was not preregistered.
My message to them:
Their reply:
Aside:
Wow! I love this.
I love that you bothered to email them with a thought out question.
I love that they bothered to respond with a thought out answer and they took you quite seriously.
I love that you bothered to tell us about the exchange.
Thank you so much for all of this. This is what we should all strive to do with our time and as a community.
Don't forget that scores are normalized for many tests. It's not a linear scale from "nothing correct is a zero, everything correct is a 10". Rather, the average number of correct answers (often weighted, but ok) is a pass. This will mess up any analysis.
The test they're using is the NWEA MAP Growth https://www.nwea.org/map-growth/ which doesn't have a concept of pass or fail. It doesn't even have a fixed set of questions, but adapts the difficulty dynamically based on earlier answers to get a more accurate measurement.
Everyone in the US knew phones were destroying attention spans years ago, but educational bodies and school boards punted the burden down to individual schools, teachers, and parents. Of course it failed: no single teacher or parent wants to be the bad guy and face social friction.
China just banned them outright. It's the same with companies - weak committee vs. a founder who just makes the hard call.
Some others would say it's the same as with liberal or totalitarian states - you are to judge what you do vs. a unchecked despot.
But I agree, this is long overdue and capitalism has figured out how to defacto undermine individual judgement to a level that we need some railguards.
Absolutely. I was a high school teacher in the 2010s, and it was such a hard aspect of teaching to navigate.
For any reasonable phone policy to be implemented well, it has to come from the highest level of administration. It has to be enforced consistently across all levels from the district/principals down to individual classroom teachers. That requires a lot of people to understand the issue well, come to agreement, and be capable of enforcing difficult policies.
There are so many factors that make it difficult for this to happen. Parents who disagree with policies, often for valid reasons. Staff turnover makes consistency difficult. If one teacher lets students use phones, it makes it harder for everyone around them to manage the policy effectively. If groups of teachers don't adhere, it gets even harder.
This is no different than the impact of AirBnB on housing availability, especially in tourist destination towns. Tech companies create a situation that's really hard to manage, and then leave it to individuals and small organizations to manage something that really needs to be figured out at a societal level.
> Everyone in the US knew phones were destroying attention spans years ago
I think that is the general consensus but I think that is only so because of common knowledge; I do not actually believe it is true, nor do we have any data to indicate that it is the phones any more than it is the continuously declining curricula in the US. Correlation is not causation.
It's really not obvious and genuinely feels like moral panic to me. The data here are so weak for something that is supposedly so harmful. It doesn't stand up to scrutiny. I don't think phone bans are worth the cost of the pouches. In some small ways it's actually hurting kids. They used to take pictures of the board or check google classroom assignments and now they can't. Mine are more likely to miss assignments now than before the ban and I don't see any change whatsoever in kids behavior.
How long before this enters the work force at various points?
My empty nester wife reentered the work force as a nurse. As one of her studies during her in hospital training she studied cell phone impacts on nursing. She’s commented how some nurses—and not just the young ones just coming out of school, but just as often the middle and older generations—struggle to be effectively present because they’re on their phones all the time.
I see informal bans, and well motivated individuals, but I haven’t seen it “become the norm thing” for workplaces to do as the schools are starting to do yet. Curious if it will.
I don't see this problem at my workplace. Maybe in the lunchroom which cuts down on socializing I guess. We're a bunch of awkward tech nerds anyway tho
I am in tech and the longer I work the less I want to look at my phone, I usually dont even know where my phone is for most part of the day and then I will remember to check it after 3 or 4 hours, but again, I work on a computer so I think its more of a replacement, the problem exists in a different format
I was just wondering if this could apply to Workshops or other days in the corporate world that are different from the day-to-day.
Imagine your job offers a three day off-site to address some of the most pressing matters. All of the company bigwigs will be there and it will be a luxuriously beautiful space (think Mohonk Mountain House in New Paltz, NY).
The catch is you need to hand your phone to a concierge (who insists you will be contacts in case of an emergency*), laptops need to be checked out, and web activity will be scrutinized (sorry, no HN or Reddit). In a mundane organization (more blue-chip company than hustle-fueled startup), you'd probably only get 5% of office personnel to agree, but they'd probably accomplish some cool stuff.
*I would want to acknowledge that this involves giving up some level of autonomy that is vital for more vulnerable peoples (women, minorities, people who have obligations outside of their job), but it's an interesting thought exercise for how humans collaborate and solve problems.
In France in 1956 they were passing a law that forbid children below 14yo to get alcohol served at the school cantine (https://youtu.be/n_Ez2RMjwuA - TV report from that time in French). I hope we will get laws forbidding phones in schools, or to children in general, and my guess is that it will resonate like this one for future generations.
I wonder if we'll see something happen with phones (and specifically, infinite feed consumption) that somewhat mirrors alcohol and cigarettes. First getting it out of the hands of kids and then gradually removing it from physical and social environments.
Eventually it becomes something adults can do where appropriate, knowing the harms associated with it.
It may seem crazy to think about with such a ubiquitous activity as phone scrolling. But if anyone drank at a business lunch like people did in the 50s or smoked in the office, they'd quickly have a meeting with HR.
I can almost imagine the kids bumming a cigarette from the teachers during break time.
It should have been done years ago. My partner is a teacher and she was so frustrated by pupils having phones (more recently, secretly) in the classroom. I don't know why it was ever allowed.
One of the main reasons to go to the office is so people can't alt-tab during meetings.
I used to zone out all the time during boring in-person meetings without a device back in the day. I credit having to sit through mass in Catholic school.
I'm in the office. Even the people in the office take calls from their desk to do other things at the same time. And when they bother to go to the meeting room... they fiddle with the phone under the desk to do other things. People who want to "check out" during a meeting will do it one way or another.
Good indication that those meetings should have probably been an email.
One of the main reasons to go to the office vs working from home is so people can't alt-tab during meetings.
It's hard to argue the conservative case when everyone's very fashion-minded and wants to do latest thing.
It's generational. The parents that didn't grow up with phones at a young age don't understand how addictive/ isolating a phone can be. Millennials grew up with it and understand.
It took us 10-15 years to understand the scope of the problem, which is sad, that's a lot of opportunity lost.
Isn’t it common sense or what am I missing?
Are the test scores improving because of the phone bans or are they improving because we're getting past the COVID era school lockdowns and things are going back to normal?
Its been like 4 years. We can stop blaming COVID for everything.
The lockdown had permanent strongly negative impact on every kid that was in school at that time. You’d need to wait for all of them to be out (about 15 years) to safely stop blaming it.
I don't see people "blaming COVID", a coronavirus with no agency, for anything.
I see people, including the person to whom you are responding, continuing to make observations about policies which were put in place during the pre-endemicity phase of the spread of that coronaviruses, some of which have turned out to have caused far more harm than the little or zero good they did (school-closures being perhaps the most obvious).
Does it matter? Let's keep at it for a while and see if it continues.
Though I imagine they're pretty certain whether it's one or the other. Teachers at least seem to be quite certain, though 'common sense' doesn't always pan out.
> Does it matter?
Yes, it is important to understand which things are true and which are false.
True, but probably not enough to delay implementing a policy that seems to be giving small but noticeable improvements across the board.
Its a stretch to call them “noticeable improvements across the board”. The study barely found statistically significant results when excluding students with significant changes and combining subjects. Math and reading on their own had no significant results and neither did including students with extreme changes.
They also ignored other changes that may have been introduced by schools at the same time.
From a policymaker perspective, I’d argue that this study falls short of warranting investments into these pouches.
One may even argue that there is a bit of a conflict of interest here with some of the data for the study coming from the manufacturer themselves and the study specifically discussing these pouches as opposed to other ways of enforcing such ban…
Not all countries had widespread school lockdowns, but all countries have the same phone problem.
There's also the possibility of tests being dumbed down even further, like they have been doing steadily for the past 40 years.
I wonder if it would make sense to make smartphones age restricted broadly like alcohol cigarettes or gambling.
I know that I as an adult struggle to have a good relationship with my phone. Imagine not having a fully developed brain yet.
All the kids I know have a healthier relationship with their phone than some of the adults I know. Some adults can't even bear to not look into their phone while watching a movie.
But then that creates the question of whether or not the development of the brain outweighs learning proper use from a young age, something to think about.
I live in a small mountain town in BC and I really hope the who town bans smart phones for kids by the time our 3 year old goes to school.
I think it’s much easier for everyone if nobody has one - nobody is missing out, parents are not the bad guys, etc.
They’re screwing up the lives of so many adults, I feels it’s a certainty we’ll look back in some years and wonder wtf we were thinking giving them to kids.
What I want to know is when was the original ban removed? When I was in high school in the mid-late aughts, cell phones in lockers were tolerated, but if a teacher ever caught you with one in class it would be confiscated until the end of the day.
As a parent, it's clear: time to start cutting technology from children--social media, cell phones, tablets, AI, even internet--until we've returned to at least Millennial academic achievement levels.
Amazing to me they were ever allowed in the first place.
It wasn't until 24/7 social media that it started to have such a negative impact though. My first phone I think was a Sony Ericson Z-something, and of course me and everyone else brought their phones to school so we could share mp3s over IR during recess, but during class the most distracted you ended up being was trying to type and send SMSes while not looking at the screen.
A far cry from what seems to be going on with schools today due to smartphones, social media and all that comes with essentially "one big 24/7 public group".
My guess is that a "social media ban" would have the same effect, but it's a lot harder to put in place, so easier to just ban phones overall.
There are already multiple ways of blocking social media on kids phones. I think the kid safe SIMs available in the UK give you that option, you can use DNS that stops looks ups, my router lets me have blocking rules for specific devices...
Parents can do that (and some do), but that just turns your kid into a social pariah.
Kids who love school phone bans love it precisely because it affects all.
I home educated so the pressure was less because kids had a variety of rules so they adapted.
Some parents were stricter than me, some a lot less so. At one point I set up a Jitsi server so one girl whose parents did not allow chat apps could talk to the others. They were unusually strict.
I also had my younger one use some things on a computer rather than a phone.
I also found it weird. I graduated in 2011 when teachers still confiscated phones. I found it baffling that between then and now we entered a period where that became something like a taboo.
I’m not surprised we’re back where we started but the fact that we ever went on this journey to begin with is weird.
Maybe they were not harmful back then before social media became big and people got cheap and fast data. Back then phones could basically just text and call and confiscating them was most likely excessive.
I remember when in highschool and sure there was social media but nobody had a smartphone.
Hey i spent a lot of hours playing snake on my Nokia and drug wars on my TI83 in school in the 90s. There are always ways to ignore boring teachers, i guess modern phones just make it easier.
I used to be envious of the kids with TI-89s who could play more games.
My school confiscated flip phones if you had yours out in class. Before smart phones constant texting was already a thing for young people, plus even dumb phones had games.
Maybe this is an American thing? Here in Ireland lots of kids would have had 2G 'smart phones' capable of running AIM, email, etc in the mid 2000s. By around 2008 / 2009 most kids would have had an iphone or one of the final generation of non touchscreen smartphones that had raced to catchup in features. By 2011 literally every kid would have had an android or iphone (android's were much more popular for a few years due to price, here in Europe - they're still far more common than in the US).
I graduated school in 1999, and every single kid was texting constantly. Phones had become ubiquitous in 1998 due to an Irish bank giving a free cellphone out when a new account was opened.
1998 was firmly beeper territory for my friends and I. I didn't know a single person with a cell phone. We weren't exactly in some tech backwater either - grew up in the SF bay area.
That's crazy to me. I vividly remember everyone I knew going from not having a phone (unless their parents were wealthy) to suddenly having one. For years kids would trade 'free codes' to get around the price of texting - this was all 'pay as you go' so you bought credit from stores to call and text. I suspect the mobile companies were leaking these 'secret engineer codes' in order to boost the popularity of texting. But I did have some awareness that we were quite ahead of the US in adoption of mobile, based on TV shows and such at the time. Incidentally, prior to that literally no one I knew had a pager. Just didn't penetrate at all here beyond drug dealers and emergency services.
At the same time, the reverse culture shock occurred in 2007 when I visited the US for the first time, and all the cyber cafes had gone. Replaced by wifi. I didn't have a laptop at the time, or a wifi capable smart device, so I spent days searching for cyber cafes everywhere I visited. I remember using a gaming cafe in the University of Phoenix, and searching Korea town for one of NYC's remaining cafes. The stress of getting around the city alone before having access to a device that could run google maps, was no joke.
I had a mobile phone around 1998. It was a brick. Wouldn't even want to carry that around with me. Ditched it after a few months. Next time I had a phone was 2008. By around 2004 most classmates had a phone, but I didn't. Wouldn't even have known what to use it for. Call my parents? What for. Talk to classmates? I can do that in person.
A friend who is a teacher said if you try to confiscate them you get parents showing up complaining it’s a safety issue. The Principal doesn’t want to rock any boats and hides from it.
To be clear it's about 2% of parents that do this, if that. And they are consistently horrible parents - shocker. The worst part in modern times with social media and the like is that people started caring what the 2% think for fear they'll got rant on social media or whatever. Not to say we should be discriminatory or whatever, but seriously - the unambiguously correct answer to this is 'We're sorry to hear you feel that way, and wish you the best of luck finding a new school for your child.'
There are two problems. One is that we've let that 2% hold everything hostage.
Another is that a public school is legally required to offer an education. All children are legally entitled to an education. If you're private, you can tell them to pound sand.
> All children are legally entitled to an education.
understood. But are the parents entitled to be stupid? What does that have to do with offering the child education. Since when is educating children a democratic process amongst parents? why is it OK that we don't treat teachers as professionals and instead assume parents know best? I say this as a parent by the way.
It's almost like school is a big babysitting service lol.
A lot of stuff has gone off the rails in the last 15 to 20 years.
> But are the parents entitled to be stupid?
The bar for having a child is quite low. Schools are bound by geography and whatever income that provides.
> It's almost like school is a big babysitting service.
It most definitely is, and the issue as you've pointed out is a lot has gone off the rails in 20-25 years (15 years is actually too short of time frame).
Part of what has gone off the rails is that most of the structures that undergird our society (US) had been left to rot as economic gains in smaller and smaller arenas dominate. It's not healthy, it will almost certainly destroy American society, but the people with capital do not care. Some are actively gleefully participating in the destruction.
Also civics should be mandatory in all public schools starting at age like 10.
Anyone is entitled to be stupid. That's kind of what the country is based on.
Exactly.
However, if in the 90s someone told me that in the future we'd all have the equivalent of a TV set with 1000 channels on our office desks, and people would think it was normal, I wouldn't have believed it.
You'd be surprised how some parents advocate using phones because "My kids need to learn how to manage the technology". Well, kids don't, since the technology exploits our primal drives. You don't give heroin to kids so they know how to manage it.
actually that's one plausible reason why Germans handle alcohol so much better than Australians and Americans. They get access to it as teenagers supervised by parents and don't go crazy, so they don't associate alcohol with going crazy.
Its generally true of many other countries too and there seems to be a correlation: the stricter attitudes to alcohol are, the worse the alcohol problems
I think the "supervised" is important. My kids had small amounts of alcohol at family meals. Quantity and strength rose with age so they were ready to handle being able to drink whatever they wanted when they could buy alcohol at 18. Its one of many things that kids learn better from adults than from people their own age.
I agree on heroin, but I think we should give all teens a class on recognizing and managing addiction. Take them through a few cycles of getting on and off caffeine, plus various digital addictions. Alongside traditional education on recreational drugs, prescription drugs, nicotine, alcohol, gambling, and the nature of addiction. And of course spotting addictions in others and how to help them.
Given the widespread commerical exploitation of engineered addictions, I think it's vital knowledge to have a good life.
Knowledge threatens the racket.
That would be a great idea, but how to prevent the ol' "mommy mommy, we learned about shooting smack today!".
> My kids need to learn how to manage the technology
there is some value about this. Unlike heroin, at some point the kids will have to use technology and learn to manage it.
But there must be better ways than unfettered access during school hours.
> My kids need to learn how to manage the technology"
which is a bonkers excuse because there isnt a single other technology we require 24/7 access to. Its more likely that some parents expect 24/7 access to their kids.
What is there to learn? Phones are locked down. You can't learn much about technology with a locked down device.
They never were "allowed" but teachers don't have any actual power to confiscate the phone and then if some teacher did confiscate the phone parents would step in making a fuss about children rights yada yada.
So it ended up teachers not enforcing it and kids not being afraid because no one could do anything.
People are quite quick with not caring about rules they are not going to be punished or ostracised for...
I think children end up having phones for the journey to and from school. It's the reason I think a lot of parents first get their children phones. If they are travelling a distance, on public transport or being picked up somewhere by parents then I can understand that. It's hard for a school to say that the students can't have phones for the travel to and from school.
The issue then becomes what happens to those phones during the day. If school have lockers, that is an option, but not all schools have a lockers.
In the case of one of the schools here, they don't have enough lockers for everybody. That school had a 'phones mustn't be seen in lesson time' policy, but that obviously is too easy to abuse, with e.g. students going to the toilet in lessons or just accessing their phones anyway, which isn't hard when they have the phone in their pocket.
They now have switched to lockable pouches that phones have to go in during the day and are locked during school hours (with an 'unlocker' available when they leave school). This works better but requires quite a bit of staff time checking the pouches in the morning (students will do things like put calculators inside instead!) and costs money. I can see why not all schools have gone that route.
this doesn't surprise me at all. what surprises me is somehow people think this is unique to kids in school. Why not adults at home or in the office? I'm not saying we should ban phones for adults obviously, just pointing out that their strong negative effects on learning and social activity and others are definitely not limited to kids.
School-issued laptops constantly available. A phone is doing something, but there are a lot of negative factors at play.
It is about the format. You cannot carry your laptop in your pocket and take it out every time there is the slightest bit of boredom or free time. The barrier to using phones is way, way lower.
Regardless of format, there is plenty of evidence which at minimum strongly suggests that school sized laptops are one of the leading drivers of the modern literacy crisis. As an educator I can attest to this being a seriously under appreciated issue.
https://legislature.vermont.gov/Documents/2026/Workgroups/Ho...
Someone forgot to tell me that... I started in high school carrying my laptop everywhere with me to pull out (of my backpack) every time there is the slightest bit of boredom.
Some are pushing back on the laptops too. Kids seem to do better with writing without them. I think we should go back to having computer labs with dedicated time to learn how to use them and to use them for specific things. No more screens in classrooms and no more "they're digital natives" thinking.
The push back to that is that a lot of assignments have been moved to be digital, which saves teachers a lot of time with grading.
With the digital assignments:
-I can't inspect my kid's homework once it is done.
-There is no "show your work" so the teacher can't find the flaw in how a kid is executing an algorithm in math, for example, the steps in long division.
-There is no artifact for the kid to review once it's graded, to understand where they went wrong.
-There is no artifact for them to study to prep for a test.
-My refrigerator door is bare.
Downvoting doesn't make this untrue; what a bunch of technofascists here.
Laptops are locked down and remotely administered in a way that phones are not.
Aren't they similarly tied to worse learning outcomes for the kids though?
Other than Google/Microsoft/Apple executives, who actually thought computers in the classroom would have a positive effect on learning outcome?
The identification in this study is a sketchy, and a similar study in the exact same setting ((https://tom-dee.github.io/files/w35132.pdf) doesn't find a significant effect.
1. they see diverging pre-trends, which immediately suggests a problem in the diff-in-diff 2. they're doing some kind of propensity score matching to build a comparison set, and it looks like they're matching across state lines, which is going to expose them to all sorts of weird state-level shocks 3. while the previous study just looked at the impacts on grades, they've built a value-added model and they're estimating their effects through that. That just adds another place where they can get the model wrong and end up with bad estimates.
They also point out that the schools that bought these pouches had more ESSER money, which they could have spent on tutoring.
I'm currently in my final year of high school in Türkiye. Phones are strictly forbidden in all schools. However, my school allows students to use tablets for studying during class. This is useful, for example, for discussing a question with friends or showing a problem directly to the teacher. It also saves paper and reduces the weight of our bags. Despite this, I believe it is better to reduce screen time. When our eyes are less exposed to the high level of visual stimulation from screens, we can better focus on the static nature of a classroom lesson, which might otherwise feel tedious. Since I personally have no experience using tablets at school, I cant say whether they lead to any improvement in test scores
I have debated moving to a dumbphone to try and cut down my YouTube addiction. Thus far the only blocker for me has been the lack of Signal support.
I am pretty convinced that having a nonstop stream of media being beamed into us is a bad thing. I kind of miss being "bored". Like, truly bored, like being stuck on the train without any means to entertain myself outside of what's in my head (and maybe reading the safety notifications).
Just disable wireless Internet and you don't need to go the dumb phone route.
I mean, no, pretty much every service lets you download stuff for offline access (including YouTube if you have premium), which I was doing anyway to preserve battery.
I'll admit that part of me wants to try a dumbphone primarily as a curiosity, since I am curious how well I could survive in 2026 without all the smartphone conveniences. Also the battery that can last upwards of a week.
I might just buy one; they're not too expensive.
then there's too little friction to turn it back on though
If I may suggest: put your phone into black and white mode. Stops the phone looking like a babies or a dogs toy.
iOS improved this mode at some point I think? Try it out:
Control Center: add Color Filters
Settings > Accessibility > Display & Text Size > Color Filters > Grayscale
Done! Let's see how long I can live without my pretty colors.
Impossible to establish causality here.
Maybe it's me, but since I deleted most of my social media I feel better and can articulate longer ideas. But the feeling of boredom is crushing. I can't find something to do with the time I wasted in social media before, any ideas?
Give yourself some time to adjust to the new baseline. You may find some new interest in new or old hobbies again. Hard to recommend anything specific.
i hope chromebooks and Blooket are next. I was shocked when I found out Blooket was part of his leaning. All the kids do is mash the buttons so they can get in game currency or whatever that crap is. The questions werent even tailored to his age group
The problem isnt the phones. Never was.
The problem is extreme psychological "games" played on every app with hordes of behaviorists turning the Skinner Box to 1000000.
Its easy to go after under 18 cause they cant vote you out, or really do much of anything. Schools are fiefdoms run by the principal and superintendent. But we see this extreme addictiveness and gamification across all humans.
http://archive.today/pbZQw
This is a good start. Now do Chromebooks.
If they allowed phones into the test, those test scores would improve even more.
I'm hoping that the study authors framed the question more rigorously than the headline writers.
No - that's not what the evidence shows; it's just what the NY Times reported! The results from several studies yields a more nuanced report.
If work places would ban phones from toilets, I wonder why much that would improve productivity :) I bet people spend way more time in toilets now comparing to 20 years ago.
Here in the Netherlands we see an increase in total bans in schools as well. Most schools already banned phones in the classroom. Although I do support it I do have to remind myself that I loved wearing my walkman between classes back in the day or playing on my gameboy during recess. I think as a parent I'm in the end responsible for my kids usage of mobile devices.
I remember my reaction to seeing an iPhone in school. It must have been 2010.
"Oh. This thing is designed to make you retarded."
Who let kids have phones at school?
Least surprising result ever
Definitely banned at my kid's school: not only the phones go into a locked locker at the beginning of the day but in addition to that if the phone even rings (phonecall, alarm, anything), it's a warning. First warning: phone is confiscated and moved outside the locker and the kid has to go pick it at the end of day and explain what happened. Second warning: parents have to come get it. Third warning: kids cannot, ever, take a phone to school.
My daughter got a first warning and a few days later I received a letter citing a law article (about how phones cannot be used during school hours).
It's great IMO.
You think it's great that if somebody calls your daughter's phone that you can get into legal trouble (fined) over it?
If the parent is allowing the student to bring a disruptive device to school, they are entrusting the student to responsibly silent or turn off their phone.
If the risk of fine helps the parent reevaluate the trust, I personally don't see the harm
Like anything else, the intentions are probably altruistic, and this discussion is probably missing context. But your last sentence is saying "I am OK with leaving the legal repercussions of my child up to a vague number of untrained people, as a risk-reward tradeoff of giving my child a way to contact me."
how many staff/positions are required to monitor these devices and their "law-breaking" offenses, which thus are (according to OP of this chain) to be reported/acted on?
What staff is further respnsible for parsing out whether or not an "alert" was something the child had no control over? IE; a weather warning or amber alert.
School staff is usually not untrained when it comes to this topic. Usually implementation of these rules at schools include many hours of direct instruction and supplemental instruction throughout the year. The state's implementation of the laws vary state-to-state as far as staffing requirements.
A child needing to contact their parent during the school day is not a new or abnormal occurrence, what is new and abnormal is the parental desire to have a cell phone with them all day. In my observation, this desire wasn't really there before the events of 2020
How is a phone ringing inside a box in a room on the other side of the building disruptive?
The phone is taken away from their possession it means that they must make sure they don't make a mistake before handing it over. Even if they remember afterwards they can't fix the mistake. Considering kids go to school on thousands of occasions that's a pretty low tolerance for mistakes.
I've forgotten something when leaving home more than 3 times over the duration of the previous 12 years. I guess other people are just better than me and don't ever forget anything.
You're making assumptions about the location of these lockers.
At my kid's middle school they're literally in the library.
These rules are not just applied to high/secondary schools. This is also a problem with elementary schools as well which has lockers/cubbies located in the classroom.
Also, kids aren't dumb. They know how to follow rules once the expectations are in place. The idea is to leave the phones at home entirely, allowing them in the locker to accommodate for the edge cases is a concession that has tradeoffs for the child's parent.
That doesn't add up - not only because phone usage is a question for district policy, not law. But also because someone else calling your phone is not your fault.
It is your fault. You should have turned your phone completely off before putting it in the locker.
It depends on the country whether it is law or not, I would imagine.
I would imagine that any such law would be in violation to FCC rules interfering with lawful use of the radio spectrum.
...turn it off?
Leaving your phone on while it shouldn't be, however, is your fault.
Someone else calling your phone is not your fault. Your phone ringing is 100% your fault.
Highly recommend Waldorf school for K-8.
>let's fuck freedom to make the line go up
Can we have the same thing at workplaces ?
https://archive.is/pbZQw
Everyone called this and this is exactly what tech was afraid of. Positive outcomes after a few schools ban phones.
Imagine what it could do for the adults…
This effect is not confined to those in schools.
Unfortunately I have to bring my phone to work because I have multiple MFA logins. I would love to leave the phone at home if I could.
It still just strikes me as moral panic. The data are so weak and there's no obvious cause and effect. It's amazing to me how universal the praise is for phone bans even on HN. I really, really do not see the massive harms people are imagining. I also think there are much bigger and far worse causes of kids losing enthusiasm for school and it's the national/global malaise caused by corrupt government, poor outlook for young workers and the looming climate disaster. Focusing on phones is a very misguided attempt to prevent them from knowing about it.
> national/global malaise caused by corrupt government, poor outlook for young workers and the looming climate disaster
All of these are decades+ old problems.
Phones have trillions of dollars of R&D invested into the best ways to steal attention. But you think that doesn't have any effect on children's ability to learn?
I think it amounts to focusing on something that seems achievable. The big drivers of problems today are massive, interrelated, and even when they have clear causes, they often lack clear levers to do anything about them. If you take the opioid crisis as an example, there are a million ideas on what the "how" is if one wants to address it, and most of those have the possibility of making the problem worse (e.g. via the iron law of prohibition, where enforcement encourages smugglers to concentrate products to even higher potencies). On the other hand, "tell schools to take phones away from students" is mostly concrete, and allows one to imagine a return of the world to the state it was in during their own childhood.
Opioid deaths have actually dropped rapidly. We also know how to solve climate change and just haven't been doing it.
It's the older prephone generations who are the most out of touch. The ones who put Trump in office. Gen Z may have lower test scores but you'd be hard pressed to say they aren't smarter than their elders.
Nah, I'm a parent of 3 kids - it's incredibly noticeable that there's a distinct difference in behavior with electronics vs without.
Are there other problems? Sure.
But this one is obvious, impactful, and easy to fix.
Next - I want to take away the chromebooks and "online" testing that the schools do too, and I'd like to consider a complete blanket ban on any sort of required account/web access for school work. This is near universally a product pushed on teachers by admins who get sold on products by for-profit tech companies.
It's not good for kids, it's good for bottom lines. Rip those fucking things out. Computer access can be a "sit down" at a desktop computer in a computer lab once or twice a week.
Care to elaborate? I have two teens and they literally yell at me for looking at my phone too much. Their cohorts in high school seem like much better people than we were 30 years ago.
You are commenting on an article that mentions a scientific national study, saying those harms are imaginary while the study precisely brings up evidence that they are not. This seems illogical to be honest. I am not implying that it's black or white and that this proves anything substantial, but it still contributes to our understanding of the matter.
How much Apple and Samsung stock do you own ?
There are three major studies and one shows a miniscule improvement and the others don't. It doesn't seem significant nor is it clearly causal.
I remember using early smartphones to hang out in IRC, Jabber etc with people that vibed a lot better than what was available on-site.
Kids won't have that escape hatch anymore once you blanket ban these devices.
But I suppose it makes sense. The majority absolutely got their brain fried by the products SV (read: HN) built and we need to protect the majority.
I wonder what the next generation of misfit kids will come up with. Or maybe we will create school environments that work for all kinds of people? Nah. Of course not.
honestly, i see it as a good thing if not everyone does it. i was one of the only 'online' kids back in my school time and i liked being able to get the phone and talk to my friends when i was bored, but if everyone does that, no one will talk face to face
As the parent of a (second generation) "misfit" kid, the kids are doing fine, in my opinion.
In the narrow slice of the world I have visibility into, it does genuinely seem like school culture is significantly more accepting of a wider range of folks. While I can obviously only speak to my suburban/rural school district in Central New York, I do have the interesting viewpoint of watching my kid attend the same school I did 25-30 years ago. One thing I can say with 100% certainty is that I would have been bullied mercilessly if I showed up in the same way they do today, but they have an active social life and participate in several active social circles that would not have been available to me.
I do think your "us vs them" mentality (i.e. "the majority got their brain fried" as if you are somehow superior and no susceptible to outside influence) is as much a part of the problem as the school environments you seek to blame.
As the part of three kids in 5th through 9th grade, the phone ban is an unqualified good, in my opinion.
They will be fine, and imho better for it. They’ll still do whatever they chose after school, but this way they’ll also learn how to deal with people that are not exactly a choice and they’ll have space to get a bit bored and, you know, think.
>Kids won't have that escape hatch anymore once you blanket ban these devices.
How about people learn to work with the people around them instead of running away to online communities?
Online communities are not all positive. They can bring many negatives, many of which are phrased as positives because they make people feel good whole atrophying or deskilling them.
I mean this reads genuinely ignorant, but falsely pretending it's good faith, at the very least, "learning to work with what is there" is quite resource-intensive, and with that could be seen as an unfair disadvantage for a certain type of kid.
Because they're not just busy doing homework and assignments and all but also have to juggle a much higher mental load on top.
The internet and internet communities are no silver bullet either, but "well just don't do that" is not doing the valid needs of various members of society justice.
___
It might be easier to empathize with the whole problem cluster if you view the problem like you view people with physical disabilities. Those too don't get told "well just fit in, lol", but have support systems in place.
"Nachteilsausgleich" is a very german term that comes to mind there.
Of course, it's not the same. But it helps for the mental model.
The correct solution wouldn't be the internet but - as I said - "school environments that work for all kinds of people", but - also as I said - I do not see that happening any time soon.
Maybe selectively in some schools due to some teachers making it their personal mission but certainly not on a systemic level. It is however a systemic issue.
For a lot of tech workers this means less money in their pockets. Maybe some sort of advocacy or lobbying group should be formed.