I love the idea because I hate news sites in general and much prefer the text-only nature of HN. A shame that the stories linked to aren't so stripped back! It's made me think about doing the same for my part of the UK.
In some ways I also really like the option to hide "politics", although there's an interesting debate about what constitutes "politics" - how do you classify that?
Edit: and given that it's a submissions site, how do you plan to tell people about it, beyond the HN crowd?
So... I'm not the OP, but if I was running a site like it, I would totally prefer machine accessible articles and use AI to generate article tags that people could filter IF (this is a big if) article filtering is something they want to support. I know people can skip over articles on purpose, but a site with automatic filtering is a slightly different flavor of site.
why not just generate the articles too, this way you can keep it text only. it's pretty fast and cheap to generate text, certainly a lot faster than waiting for news to happen and for someone to submit it.
If the "politics" toggle actually worked, it would hide basically everything except the most dry educational topics and "Show HN" would be reduced to new puzzle games that don't require words.
My instinct is that it would filter stories that include:
1. Members of the judicial, legislative, and executive branches, elected officials, appointees, candidates, political parties, and high visibility court cases.
2. Whatever "current thing" is, based on an automated daily LLM analysis of the frequency of such things appearing in the news, from both supposed left, right, and center sources.
It would not filter:
1. Those in #1 above who are dealing with pure science or technology, as long as they aren't apart of any court dealings, budgetary issues, appointments, or elections.
Lol I never get this - "I'm not political." Just say you're a libertarian, dude.
Shouts to Brutalist.report, they have headlines as wacky-right as Zero Hedge, and as wacky-left as... ok, the New York Times. Probably some deserved social commentary in there but a least it isn't trying to filter both out completely.
Unfortunately the members of the libertarian party in the US prevent many technical libertarians (roughky speaking one who believes in self governing) from self idenitfying as such, since the term is often more associated with social liberalism combined with fiscal conservatism.
People who wear their politics as their identity don't seem to understand that there are a lot of us who are legitimately utterly bored by politics. The same way you might be bored by, say, gardening, baseball, or learning Swahili.
And it's interesting how much more often it is the left-leaning individuals who accuse us of being libertarians or covert conservatives. Especially given how the left (as a rule) publicly prides themselves on being accepting of people's differences while simultaneously berating centrists and the politically agnostic in online media.
"If you're not with us, you're against us," is an ideology that never dies, I suppose.
Neat, I'd love to be able to filter by state. I care deeply about MN news and politics (and WI to a lesser extent), but have zero interest in the rest of the region.
I started making something derived from that idea, mixed with some positive aspects of imageboards. There would be boards for each community, with a general homepage aggregating top posts from each board. A clean, text-based interface, with goodies from modern UI design.
Incentives are a problem however, moderation takes time and costs money at scale. Ultimately one of the things that makes HN work is the backing of YC. Maybe minimal, honest ads could work, but that requires validation in practice
FARK is kind of that. The UI is terrible, the contributor-submitted headline summaries are terrible, the forums are full of terrible people, but I still visit it because I can scan a page of links and see what's going on in the world across a wide swath of interests, and it's not algorithmically-generated like Google News.
"Midwest" has long been a pet peeve of mine; I don't understand what states like Michigan and South Dakota are supposed to have in common. It's like a more neutral way of saying "flyover country." That's a nice-looking website, but i would divide this news at least into a Great Plains category and a Great Lakes.
Also, Midwest of what, exactly? Most of the "midwest" is in the eastern half of the United States, if not all of it depending on your definition. It's west of the east coast, sure... but that doesn't exactly nail it down now, does it? Not exactly a surprise, that? The "mid" makes some sense on its own but I've never understood what the "west" was doing in there, nor particularly how they combine. The history of the term makes sense, in terms of how it was used in the 18th century, but its persistence into the 21st is a bit odd. You can't just say "inertia", many many other similar names from the 18th century are long gone. But somehow this particular one sticks around even though it is facially false.
It doesn't "bother" me, but it does make me intellectual wonder what it is about the term that has kept it around when so many other seemingly more suitable ones have been dead for hundreds of years.
Indeed, I always thought that the midwest should be Minnesota, the Dakotas, Iowa, Nebraska, and Kansas. Maybe Illinois and Missouri can come too, sometimes. The Great Lakes states should be called...well the Great Lakes region! Or perhaps, because they're in the middle portion of the eastern United States, we could call it the middle east.
The page does not render properly without executing a javascript application. For me that's deal breaker. It's still usable at least in the sense that text can be read and hyperlinks work. It's just really akward to read.
Normally, I'd argue no-JS web viewers are such a tiny edge case of a population that almost explicitly self-selects itself into commercial irrelevance, making them doubly not worth a site developer's time. That said, for a HN-reader site, it's probably a pretty large demographic and worth catering to.
If you mean by count of users you're entirely right. Of course most of those users only ever use a handful of websites. And they're very far from the average HN user that actually surfs the web. If you're not aware, HN itself works great without javascript.
But in terms of content that exists on the web the current JS app-only design of the 2020s is relatively new and while significant, it's probably not even half of the content on the web. Most of it is just .html rich media hypertext documents that don't need any javascript.
Yeah, but I and my friends of a certain age were very aware that when “cornhole” the game started making the rounds, that it was named that as a joke. The slang term is much, much older but not everybody was aware of such unsavory slang. So it was sort of a prank on polite society.
The name is a shibboleth for the site in general. If you think it's a gross name, then you're not the target audience. Midwesterns predominantly think of "cornhole" in the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cornhole sense, as it's a wildly popular game.
I love the idea because I hate news sites in general and much prefer the text-only nature of HN. A shame that the stories linked to aren't so stripped back! It's made me think about doing the same for my part of the UK.
In some ways I also really like the option to hide "politics", although there's an interesting debate about what constitutes "politics" - how do you classify that?
Edit: and given that it's a submissions site, how do you plan to tell people about it, beyond the HN crowd?
So... I'm not the OP, but if I was running a site like it, I would totally prefer machine accessible articles and use AI to generate article tags that people could filter IF (this is a big if) article filtering is something they want to support. I know people can skip over articles on purpose, but a site with automatic filtering is a slightly different flavor of site.
why not just generate the articles too, this way you can keep it text only. it's pretty fast and cheap to generate text, certainly a lot faster than waiting for news to happen and for someone to submit it.
If the "politics" toggle actually worked, it would hide basically everything except the most dry educational topics and "Show HN" would be reduced to new puzzle games that don't require words.
My instinct is that it would filter stories that include:
1. Members of the judicial, legislative, and executive branches, elected officials, appointees, candidates, political parties, and high visibility court cases.
2. Whatever "current thing" is, based on an automated daily LLM analysis of the frequency of such things appearing in the news, from both supposed left, right, and center sources.
It would not filter:
1. Those in #1 above who are dealing with pure science or technology, as long as they aren't apart of any court dealings, budgetary issues, appointments, or elections.
> A shame that the stories linked to aren't so stripped back
You might really enjoy Kagi News.
https://news.kagi.com/world/latest
Just do it the way HN does it -- have a "super downvote" button. HN's "flag" operates this way, usually takes care of "politics".
"Our goal is to eventually monetize this site with two small ads on the homepage reserved exclusively for Midwestern businesses."
Thank you for stating that. Is this for profit, or just to cover costs of hosting? Will you be self-hosting the ads, or using an ad network?
On another note, what are the plans for moderation?
This is what we wanted. Please make it include Canada too, after all we do have our own midwest that is culturally similar <3
I feel certain that your politics filter is leaving items that people will consider political
Lol I never get this - "I'm not political." Just say you're a libertarian, dude.
Shouts to Brutalist.report, they have headlines as wacky-right as Zero Hedge, and as wacky-left as... ok, the New York Times. Probably some deserved social commentary in there but a least it isn't trying to filter both out completely.
NYTimes is moderate left at most.
Unfortunately the members of the libertarian party in the US prevent many technical libertarians (roughky speaking one who believes in self governing) from self idenitfying as such, since the term is often more associated with social liberalism combined with fiscal conservatism.
People who wear their politics as their identity don't seem to understand that there are a lot of us who are legitimately utterly bored by politics. The same way you might be bored by, say, gardening, baseball, or learning Swahili.
And it's interesting how much more often it is the left-leaning individuals who accuse us of being libertarians or covert conservatives. Especially given how the left (as a rule) publicly prides themselves on being accepting of people's differences while simultaneously berating centrists and the politically agnostic in online media.
"If you're not with us, you're against us," is an ideology that never dies, I suppose.
Neat, I'd love to be able to filter by state. I care deeply about MN news and politics (and WI to a lesser extent), but have zero interest in the rest of the region.
MinnPost is also very good for MN news: https://www.minnpost.com/
too bad there isn't a hackernews for everything. that was reddit for in the beginning, but reddit jumped that ship a long time ago.
I started making something derived from that idea, mixed with some positive aspects of imageboards. There would be boards for each community, with a general homepage aggregating top posts from each board. A clean, text-based interface, with goodies from modern UI design.
Incentives are a problem however, moderation takes time and costs money at scale. Ultimately one of the things that makes HN work is the backing of YC. Maybe minimal, honest ads could work, but that requires validation in practice
> moderation takes time
Could AI assist with some of this, and maybe include a public mod log for transparency?
As for funding, what about a citizen-owned model as described here:
https://www.noemamag.com/the-last-days-of-social-media/
FARK is kind of that. The UI is terrible, the contributor-submitted headline summaries are terrible, the forums are full of terrible people, but I still visit it because I can scan a page of links and see what's going on in the world across a wide swath of interests, and it's not algorithmically-generated like Google News.
"Midwest" has long been a pet peeve of mine; I don't understand what states like Michigan and South Dakota are supposed to have in common. It's like a more neutral way of saying "flyover country." That's a nice-looking website, but i would divide this news at least into a Great Plains category and a Great Lakes.
Why do you want division ? Unity is much better
SD is west. The midwest coast centers around the midwestern great lakes.
Also, Midwest of what, exactly? Most of the "midwest" is in the eastern half of the United States, if not all of it depending on your definition. It's west of the east coast, sure... but that doesn't exactly nail it down now, does it? Not exactly a surprise, that? The "mid" makes some sense on its own but I've never understood what the "west" was doing in there, nor particularly how they combine. The history of the term makes sense, in terms of how it was used in the 18th century, but its persistence into the 21st is a bit odd. You can't just say "inertia", many many other similar names from the 18th century are long gone. But somehow this particular one sticks around even though it is facially false.
It doesn't "bother" me, but it does make me intellectual wonder what it is about the term that has kept it around when so many other seemingly more suitable ones have been dead for hundreds of years.
Indeed, I always thought that the midwest should be Minnesota, the Dakotas, Iowa, Nebraska, and Kansas. Maybe Illinois and Missouri can come too, sometimes. The Great Lakes states should be called...well the Great Lakes region! Or perhaps, because they're in the middle portion of the eastern United States, we could call it the middle east.
Very cool! I did something similar for news from across my state (Arizona), but in a more Drudge Report style format with thematic clustering.
https://azpost.com
Out of curiosity, how are you determining which stories are 'political'?
Seems like it means elections, government institutions, parties, officials, and so on. What the French would call la politique, and not le politique.
Please feel free to leave feedback
The page does not render properly without executing a javascript application. For me that's deal breaker. It's still usable at least in the sense that text can be read and hyperlinks work. It's just really akward to read.
Normally, I'd argue no-JS web viewers are such a tiny edge case of a population that almost explicitly self-selects itself into commercial irrelevance, making them doubly not worth a site developer's time. That said, for a HN-reader site, it's probably a pretty large demographic and worth catering to.
> For me that's deal breaker
Why? 99.999% of the web relies on javascript without issue.
If you mean by count of users you're entirely right. Of course most of those users only ever use a handful of websites. And they're very far from the average HN user that actually surfs the web. If you're not aware, HN itself works great without javascript.
But in terms of content that exists on the web the current JS app-only design of the 2020s is relatively new and while significant, it's probably not even half of the content on the web. Most of it is just .html rich media hypertext documents that don't need any javascript.
I don't think that answered my question but ok
Seems identical to me when I disable JS?
Poor choice of name.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cornhole_(slang)
I think it's a great name
"Cornhole" is an extremely common and popular lawn game played all around the Midwest.
Yeah, but I and my friends of a certain age were very aware that when “cornhole” the game started making the rounds, that it was named that as a joke. The slang term is much, much older but not everybody was aware of such unsavory slang. So it was sort of a prank on polite society.
With respect, I think this might say more about you than about the general population ;)
The vulgar meaning of the word is the original one and is more than 100 years old
You've never played Cornhole?
Yes, and rolled my eyes at the name.
Please take your prudery, crush it into a tiny ball and cram it in your cornhole.
The name was probably chosen so people who can't take a joke or a bit of double entendre stay away.
Excellent choice of name :)
Beavis and Butt-Head - Cornholio Montage
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dk57aLMoYGE
The name is a shibboleth for the site in general. If you think it's a gross name, then you're not the target audience. Midwesterns predominantly think of "cornhole" in the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cornhole sense, as it's a wildly popular game.
As a fellow Midwesterner, I wonder if there's a way to filter news by state?
My first thought as well.
I kinda wish Manitoba and maybe Ontario were allowed.
spiritually they are part of the midwest
How do you source your news stories? Have you thought about adding an archive.is or wallhop link options for each story?
Separate RSS feeds for Top and New would be very much appreciated!
Is it open source? I couldn't find a github link on the page anywhere
here is something similar from another hn member https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50502423
I don't like how posts move around when I upvote them. I'd rather them stay where they are until I refresh.
There also doesn't seem to be a way to upvote or reply to comments.
I concur. Upvoting and having them relocate was jarring.
I'm no longer able to look at such blindingly bright websites anymore... wow, what a shock to my eyes and brain.
That's terrible! Are you light-sensitive?
If "light mode" use is uncomfortable, your monitor is set too bright (for dark mode, too).
This is great. Thanks!
Looks neat! I signed up!