caymanjim 21 minutes ago

You can't be serious about privacy with a closed-source app and centralized server.

Signal is better than basic SMS, iMessage, Facebook Messenger, etc. That's got value. It's convenient and has reached critical mass so the barrier to entry is low enough that it's a viable option.

It's better than nothing, and just secure enough to be worth it and just secure enough to maintain a customer base.

It's still a business, and they will make it as secure as needed to earn money, and no more secure than that.

pajamasam 2 hours ago

I found the Machine Gods interview with Meredith Whittaker really interesting. She specifically talked about this issue of AI apps having too much access on users’ devices and that Signal is struggling to prevent these apps from getting access to users’ Signal chats. And that even if you don’t have an AI app installed, your contact could and thereby still leaks your chat.

Good to see they’re making some progress towards addressing this issue and that they are “cautiously optimistic that some major OS providers, like Google and Apple, are engaging with us on how these systems should better interface with privacy-sensitive apps like Signal.”

  • HumblyTossed 2 hours ago

    If this is true, does it not throw some water on the coals of Apple's "We're so secure" stance? Why the F would any app have access to my signal messages?

    • phoghed 2 hours ago

      Aren’t they implying that the users on the other side of your chats explicitly grant that access to their ai agent?

      • _heimdall 2 hours ago

        I believe the implication is that an OS may give its own AI tool direct access to see and interact with what is on the screen, including messages shown in a messaging app.

    • _heimdall 2 hours ago

      I expect the risk vector would primarily be related to OS-level AI tools being given to see whats being rendered on screen and interact with it. Signal can encrypt at rest and between devices, it can't encrypt when actually rendering text to the UI tree.

      • j45 1 hour ago

        Maybe signal can change how they render text on the screen. Nothings perfect, but maybe render it themselves?

        • zugi 44 minutes ago

          Like render all your chats as Captcha text so the AI can't read it?

          • j45 17 minutes ago

            Maybe, or just render it as an image. Or render it as individual pixels. Things might not be perfect but it would be a start. :)

            Rust / WebAssembly can do a lot.

    • solyin 2 hours ago

      You wouldn't, but someone you're talking to has connected the desktop app to their signal account, and is also using Claude in YOLO mode.

    • Barbing 1 hour ago

      As I understand it, the issue on iOS is Siri’s access to screen content. It's useful to be able to e.g. read Hacker News in Safari and be able to say, “Hey Siri, what do these three obscure acronyms in the comment at the top of my screen stand for?” Unfortunately, when iOS 27 was first released, there was no way to exclude an app like Signal from this feature. So if you had Signal open and you triggered Siri to ask an unrelated question, you could inadvertently send a screenshot of your Signal chat to the cloud.

      Thankfully, Signal pushed and Apple responded pretty quickly. Now we can tighten up our settings via:

        Settings > Siri > Excluded Apps
      • boplicity 1 hour ago

        Really should be:

            Settings > Siri > App Access Permissions
        

        With the option to "always ask," or "always allow," or "never allow."

        • dylan604 58 minutes ago

          This is one of those obvious situations where should and reality are not any where close to each other. Of course, Apple will want the default to be open and every thing whitelisted so "it just works". When someone wants their new shiny to be accepted, they will never go for the everything must be specifically allowed by user as the default.

          • AnthonyMouse 35 minutes ago

            The way they ought to do it is like this: The app specifies the default (which is "allowed" if they don't specify, but then Signal can specify otherwise), the user can then change it either way, and the app is given no means to tell if the user has changed it (so evil corp can't inhibit the user from doing what they want).

          • reactordev 30 minutes ago

            Yeah, unfortunately the guy who really championed privacy at Apple, passed away. Jobs would have been furious if AI had access to his chats without his permission.

            • brookst 21 minutes ago

              Apple’s been good (not perfect, but good) on privacy post-Jobs. PCC, PAT, and AVP’s bias toward privacy at the expense of utility come to mind.

        • rolosa 51 minutes ago

          As long as there's an easy way to get to it that doesn't involve digging through settings. The whole "[app] wants to paste from your clipboard" prompt is so god damn annoying.

      • bilbo0s 42 minutes ago

        Hate to be that guy, but why would that option be Siri, or even Signal, specific?

        If the goal is to ensure security and privacy of a chat screen or an excel window full of bank balances, wouldn't you want to prevent any app, on any OS from getting screen access?

        Serious question.

        I mean is there a way to prevent all background processes from taking screen shots while, say, Signal or something else private is in use? Across linux, Windows, MacOS, Android, ios etc? I feel like users should be able to set every OS to operate that way.

        BTW, I get and understand the failure state that occurs when the person you're talking to is a moron and is running Claude YOLO or something while you're chatting with them. I'm only talking about ensuring security on your own end.

cimnine 2 hours ago

I would appreciate if Signal published the findings of their 'forensics investigation' so that other app developers with fewer resources could profit. If it were something like a living document (wiki or repo), there could even be collaboration, where others share their findings.

ada-h00k 1 hour ago

I wish they would go one step further and alert every user of such a system that it contains spyware, and then recommend alternatives like GrapheneOS or Linux for desktop computers. Relying on Apps that meant to remain private to prevent screenshots from being taken won’t work in the long run. Users need to regain control over their operating system.

  • karel-3d 39 minutes ago

    Signal doesn't even officially support GrapheneOS... they are not on their app store and the APK download has a big "dangerous, don't do it!" sign

    https://signal.org/android/apk/

  • Joel_Mckay 36 minutes ago

    Most modern malware is ram resident only, and it resists forensic analysis to hide the payload RCE.

    The issue is telecoms are some of the most devious monopolists you will ever encounter. They literally helped change laws, add certification barriers, assist 3 letter organization campaigns on US citizens, and self-sign firmware images... blacklisting 3rd party OS on hardware though imei anti-theft systems.

    Starlink is successful because they pulled off a miracle business deal getting these telecoms to cooperate with Direct Connect satellite VoLTE services. =3

einszwei 2 hours ago

I am not sure why signal doesn't allow crypto payment (like monero) for their account creation when not using a phone number. To register you either need a phone number or payment method which can both identify you.

  • coherentpony 2 hours ago

    Privacy and anonymity are different things.

    • Madmallard 2 hours ago

      Nah if they are "serious" they offer both. It's a scam until proven otherwise.

      • roughly 2 hours ago

        Ah yes, Signal is a scam, this is a serious position held by serious people.

        • solyin 1 hour ago

          I would like all of the money I've given to Signal back in that case, please.

          https://signal.org/donate/

          • roughly 1 hour ago

            (I’m a regular donator, in case this is a subtle dig to put my money where my mouth is, but yes - everyone who finds real value in it should support them.)

  • Grombobulous 2 hours ago

    Probably because that would open up the platform to a flood of spam bots.

    • questionedon 1 hour ago

      It still costs money. I don't see why money in a different form would cause more spam. If it did, they could raise the price if they're getting more spam.

      I think it would be unlikely that any spam is going to come from the paid accounts. When phone numbers are way cheaper.

      Frankly, the paid accounts are overpriced. But, anyone that wants to pay with money instead of phone numbers is going to be fine supporting Signal anyway.

      The best argument for Monero is that the overlap of people that want to pay with a KYC payment method and that would pay in the first place instead of a phone number is very small.

    • snackbroken 1 hour ago

      Spammers operate out of countries where they have no fear of legal consequences, so all Signal has to do to deter them from the crypto option is make it more expensive than bulk phone numbers are.

  • panja 2 hours ago

    Last I heard, that was coming at a later date

  • opengrass 2 hours ago

    Should be buyable desktop only with volume licenses.

  • dist-epoch 2 hours ago

    If you want real security and anonymity, with support for multiple and temporary identities, use SimpleX. Recommended by Whonix, which is recommended by Edward Snowden.

    Signal is for pretend-security.

    • questionedon 1 hour ago

      >Signal is for pretend-security.

      No. Signal is for content privacy by code and metadata privacy by policy and also code but weaker.

      If you didn't notice, SimpleX had way less users and way worse UX.

      Being built for different things doesn't make it pretend security. You're completely correct that it's not for anonymity. You're completely wrong that it's not secure.

      • mrinf1nity 1 hour ago

        My take: Drains the shit out of batteries too. Also, AI screen readers don't care. If it's on the screen, it can read it.

    • rpdillon 1 hour ago

      > Signal is for pretend-security.

      Can we please stop it with this?

  • jon128 35 minutes ago

    The 501c3 named Signal is effectively running a giant honeypot, or in simpler terms a "scam".

    In real-world practice, the 501c3 named Signal and Amazon Web Services that its servers run on can see the metadata of which users messaged which other users at what time.

    This is why they haven't given the users the option to invite other users with a string (or "token" or whatever) so the inviting user can be messaged without a PSTN number or Google id being demanded from the invitee.

    If you're trying to buy some good shit on the street or meet up at "da show" with urbanite degenerates, Signal is great.

    Serious people, infosec pros, execs, etc stopped using Signal about two years ago -- at least that's what I saw from my corner of the world.

    • qwerpy 31 minutes ago

      So what do “serious” people use? I have a pretty easy life so I don’t bother straying away from the easy to use apps, but I’m still curious what the l33t hax0rs use.

      • 2PqboPPmKegvanx 20 minutes ago

        this is always my problem with it - it seems like lots of people shit on Signal, but never say what either they use or what they recommend (and why)

        it comes across like more of a ploy to get you to scare people away and get them to use other, less secure, messengers

      • jon128 15 minutes ago

        Among the high net worth audience there are a handful of commercially supported forks of the Signal software in use. Others are using a supported fork of Element X which is deemed "polished" among by the less literate of users.

        "Signal" in the previous comment referred to the service hosted by the 501c3 named Signal, not the body of open source software named Signal ; these are overlapping but different things.

        FOSS quietly shines in the private (as in, among private entities).

        Organizations that are universally recognizable as working on "serious" things have coalesced around Matrix and Element X or other Matrix clients (some not FOSS), instead of services hosted by third parties (such as Slack). Different audience but an example of modern literacy.

        "Small" users such as "l33t hax0rs" which I read as "age range of teenager to college freshman", often set up their own XMPP servers and use OMEMO. Perhaps these users are not organized around something "serious", but their choice to have self-respect and gain literacy to act it out is something that can be taken seriously.

        To answer your question more directly: anything with decent technical merit that either doesn't require a 3rd party or the 3rd party can be specifically chosen.

        I recently wrote on this topic, not so much the technical pieces but the vibe-perspective

          https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50417774
ifh-hn 2 hours ago

Weird how to signal macos is the least private OS in respect to this topic. Most people consider apple to provide the most private and secure os's.

  • goldenarm 1 hour ago

    Consumer sentiment and truth can be orthogonal.

    Most people admire German engineering thanks to the "Deutsche Qualität" ad campaign, yet we forget that came from Opel, one of most unreliable carmarkers at the time.

    Apple has invested billions to advertise how private they are, but reality is more complex than that. They have been hostile to security researchers multiple times, and have been slower than the industry average at patching vulnerabilities multiple times.

    • brookst 19 minutes ago

      What OS providers do a better job of privacy and security? Anyone with decent adoption?

  • treyd 50 minutes ago

    It's been great marketing for them but it's never been actually true beyond what they need to do to make the marketing believable.

  • cosmic_cheese 46 minutes ago

    My impression is that the desktop apps have never been very high on the list of priorities. They’ve always felt like checkbox tickers.

    This is unfortunate because a lot of the people who are knowledgeable and care about security/privacy spend their days in front of a keyboard, which is always going to be vastly better to jot out messages with than any kind of handheld mobile device.

tamimio 10 minutes ago

Open source both client and server, I can self host server, remove phone number requirement AND any other shenanigans you put as an alternative like payments to unmask people, then we have a start to talk about privacy, other than that, do not trust Signal.

quotemstr 1 hour ago

> This means that we are restricting the latest AI agents built into mobile operating systems from potentially capturing and storing your Signal data.

This decision is mine to make, not Signal's. As the owner of the computer, I decide what programs have access to what. Signal has no business attempting to block my own user agent, which I run with my fully informed consent, accessing my own data.

  • AaronAPU 58 minutes ago

    It’s interesting they even try to fight this fight because fundamentally they can never control one side of the conversation taking photos or otherwise logging. That they pretend its tractable at all makes me question their security in general.

    Preventing man-in-the-middle is different, something you can actually do technically. That is something you can actually promise to a degree.

    • dylan604 56 minutes ago

      That is different than having it sent to the cloud with users "unaware" and then the cloud leaking it though.

    • quotemstr 55 minutes ago

      They could go full mandatory remote attestion, in principle closing every hole but the analog one. This understanding of privacy, one in which the user is part of the threat model, slouches inevitably towards DRM.

      Either Signal respects that regular people have general purpose computing or they don't.

  • crusty 54 minutes ago

    Don't they though? You can always form it if you don't like their priorities and decisions, just like those for any other feature.

aboringusername 2 hours ago

Isn't the solution kind of obvious here? Mobile devices already have permissions (location, file system, contacts, photos/media), so they just need to implement 'AI/agent' access. If denied, agents are simply prohibited from working. It should be an opt-in toggle similar to location when the app starts, it can request the AI/agent permission during its lifecycle at the right moment (such as tapping an 'ask AI' button and a prompt appears with the permission).

But really, the key to privacy is trusting the recipient, because one the data lands on the other device, it's outside of your control, and if the user has malware enabled (consciously or not) there's not much you can do about that.

m-hodges 17 minutes ago

Some people aren't reading the whole article. You can turn it off if you disagree with the product decision. I'm sure there will be folks mad on the opt-in/out axis either way.

That said: periodic reminder that Signal cannot protect you from your chat partners' devices. You might have this protection enabled, but if your chat partner has it disabled, their OS's AI can now read your chats.

coldtea 1 hour ago

>Signal Is Serious About Protecting Your Privacy (signal.org)

The problem is that this is also what someone not serious about protecting our privacy would say.

  • rpdillon 1 hour ago

    Sure, but it's not like Signal doesn't have a track record here.

  • roughly 55 minutes ago

    Yes, you’d really have to look at, like, their track record - for instance, an entity with something like 20 fucking years of delivering a messaging platform that the fucking FBI regularly complains they can’t read could make that statement with a little more credibility than whoever you’re thinking of.

dijit 2 hours ago

As much as they beg and plead, I have a very suspicious automatic gut reaction to US based companies screaming from the heavens about how they're the one true privacy bastion... They have a lot of frothy-mouthed fans who poke their head out immediately when I bring up any of my concerns about things[0] - or when I state that: one company should not be the only one fighting for private messaging.

The smart play is to have companies in many countries and have them federate traffic across each others infra (like tor) and to have third-party clients with their own ability to implement the E2EE bits...

- or, even better: use something like Matrix amongst friends, you only need a slightly technical friend to set it up for you and now it's really hard for someone to violate your trust, and you're not even a big target for mass surveillance: win-win.

As it stands, Signal can still be compelled to act against their users, especially those not under US jurisdiction, and they're forbidden from talking about it. They're directly under the CLOUD act (if they're not a honeypot designed explicitly to drown out other private messengers, which sounds conspiratorial but its the only thing that makes sense based on how effective their marketing is compared to others- the concerns raised against Signal would kill other messengers).

[0]: https://blog.dijit.sh/i-don-t-trust-signal/

  • TFNA 1 hour ago

    I have followed digital privacy and nation-level-actor interception stories since the European Parliament's ECHELON report over a quarter-century ago, and to me it is a given that no strong state like the USA would permit a truly secure app being used at a societal scale. I use Signal myself, but am under no illusions.

    The developers might be bona-fide idealists and the E2EE encryption might be reliable (if only when compiling the app from source oneself), but it feels obvious that the US authorities would gain access to things like contact metadata or forcing a compromised build on request. The app is leaky in this regard, and Signal rents cloud infrastructure which enables covert shenanigans with the server, like compromising the infamously vulnerable Intel SGX which is the only thing keeping people's contact lists (uploaded by default to the server) private.

    • rpdillon 59 minutes ago

      This is a reasonable take, though I would add that simply compromising the notification server is enough to get the metadata about who's talking to who.

      My general impression is that Signal is about as secure as I can reasonably expect, but that the entire ecosystem is compromised because it's going through two companies that are beholden to the US government.

  • krautburglar 1 hour ago

    "Moxie Marlinspike" I am not going to trust some jabroni, straight out of central casting, who doesn't even fly by his family name. Seems like yet another usgov+hollywood fabrication. Good on you.

    JWZ site, so if you don't want the HN testicle egg, copy paste, don't click:

    https://www.jwz.org/blog/2025/04/signal-3/

  • questionedon 1 hour ago

    It turns out that good privacy tech doesn't rely on jurisdictions.

    It's a stupid take that the country matters. If the tech is sound and trustless, it won't matter what country the company is based in.

    Similarly "digital sovereignty" is stupid. E2EE is what matters. And SimpleX shows that you can essentially add highly effective client-side metadata encryption.

    For content privacy, you're much better off with an E2EE file service hosted in North Korea than non-E2EE file service in Switzerland.

    • TFNA 55 minutes ago

      E2EE is only about message contents. Intelligence services have made it clear that metadata is enough for them, and Signal's code (since at least the introduction of Intel SGX features) doesn't protect that, precisely because of server jurisdiction.

      • questionedon 37 minutes ago

        But, if it was in an EU country, the media would still be collected by intelligence services. And shared due to the various eyes alliances.

        I think Signal's threat model is more about law enforcement local or national than intelligence agencies with backdoors in the internet.

        As it happens a lot of the abuse of our rights comes from law enforcement. So it's a big improvement to protect against that.

        I don't think anyone's expecting Signal to be super anonymous when it's run on AWS.

        Yeah, I admit they should work a lot more on metadata privacy. Because anonymity is important in messaging for contact privacy.

    • dijit 51 minutes ago

      servers, computers and users all live inside a jurisdiction.

      Technology must work around this fundamental fact, or work within the law: everything else is a perpetually losing battle.

      You can't have an organisation providing anonymous E2EE if there are laws that force KYC or CSAM scanning; and you will be hard pressed to argue on the side of fraudsters and kiddie fiddlers in front of the population.

      Like I said, the best solution is small local groups; just like neighbourhoods- there's no actual need to have ONE directory and ONE "instance" of a chat network outside of convienience.. and truthfully, it's not that convenient, because everyone chooses a different chat network anyway. (Whatsapp, Signal, Telegram, Facebook messenger-- which isn't whatsapp for some reason, Wechat, Threema, etc,etc,etc,etc).

EGreg 1 hour ago

Groups is even more serious, but on a different front:

https://groups.app/confidential.html

  • ebb_earl_co 1 hour ago

    Where did you hear about this? I am intrigued and would like to know more.

    • EGreg 1 hour ago

      I built Groups, starting nearly a decade years ago, as a privacy-preserving CRM. Since then it’s been downloaded by about 6 million people in over 100 countries. It isn’t as big as Signal by any means, but it has an entirely different focus. You can download it and try it — it’s free:

      https://qbix.com/GROUPS

      Over the years we’ve had various requests for conversation or personal usage data, including a court case of some church, and we told them the truth - that we don’t receive any. They said to send that in writing and that was it.

      Here was my reply years ago to Moxie Marlinspike about why decentralization is key to provable privacy:

      https://community.intercoin.app/t/web3-moxie-signal-telegram...

      • ebb_earl_co 55 minutes ago

        Thank you! Best of luck in your endeavors.

vlyan 10 minutes ago

no, it isn't.

if it was, it wouldn't require a phone number or a payment to sign up. that's an utter non-starter for a privacy tool. no public API, no third-party clients, no first-party web client. Signal Messenger LLC is, painfully obviously, a SaaS company waiting for a buyout from a megacorp.

and the undeserved glazing it got from the media reeks of operation mockingbird bullshit.

LoganDark 1 hour ago

> This means that we are restricting the latest AI agents built into mobile operating systems from potentially capturing and storing your Signal data.

I have family conversations in Signal that I want Siri and Spotlight to be able to index. I've been considering moving to a different app solely because of this. Make it a setting!!

I don't trust Google and Facebook, but I do trust Apple. Don't force-distrust Apple on my behalf, I don't want that. This should be my choice.

  • Flimm 1 hour ago

    This outlook is initially appealing. The problem with it is that it is not only your choice that matters, it is also the choice of your contacts. Do your contacts want you to share their private conversations with you with online AI, unencrypted? Do you want your private conversations to be leaked by your contacts?

    • LoganDark 1 hour ago

      I'd imagine stuff like this is why, say, Telegram has a difference between "non-secret" and "secret" chats. I'd imagine all Signal would need is a similar mechanism for either locking down an existing chat or making a new locked-down chat. Then you could be confident that none of its participants could be passing it to a leaky or unscrupulous provider.

      Signal could even make it the default, because I have no shame in asking my family to let me index their chats. That would be better for the masses, I'd imagine.

Bender 1 hour ago

I will stick with services that can be my dumb pipe and use E2EE libraries that can do MLS [1], OMEMO [2], OTR [3], GPG [4] and manage keys out of band but I do appreciate that services like signal exist to limit the number of governments that can eavesdrop.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Messaging_Layer_Security

[2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OMEMO

[3] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Off-the-Record_Messaging_proto...

[4] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GNU_Privacy_Guard

  • ajsnigrutin 1 hour ago

    And how many of the people you chat with daily use all those? Your friends, relatives, elementary school classmates, high school friends who still call you over for a beer (and you them), coworkers from previous projects with new leads etc.?

  • gib444 1 hour ago

    What does that look like in practice for you, day to day?

  • Flimm 1 hour ago

    All of these are vulnerable to AI tools installed on your device or on your contact's device. That's what this article is about.

    • g-b-r 1 hour ago

      Those are just protocols, it's the specific apps and applications that have to prevent screenshots and access to their notifications to AI tools

asxndu 2 hours ago

Signal is run by a careless, low effort team.

It may be the best we have, but the bar is so low.

How can you claim to care about security and your desktop application is just a electron wrapper?

Over 300 MB & 1 GB ram for a texting app?

This is a very unfocused team.

  • TFNA 2 hours ago

    signal-desktop is more than a texting app. I use it daily for fairly complex videoconferencing. Yes, Electron is not ideal, but a native app for all of the supported OSes is a lot to ask.

    And I don't find signal-desktop's load onerous on my middling-RAM computer, though this is the only Electron app I have running (I get the impression that many HN readers have multiple Electron apps going, which I guess would add up.)

    • busymom0 2 hours ago

      Out of curiosity, since signal has a native iOS app, why don't they use the Apple's Catalyst framework to port the same app to macOS?

  • ada-h00k 57 minutes ago

    If you don't like Electron, there are also unofficial apps that run natively. For example, I created a Qt based Signal client called Corvus. However, just because the official Client is built with Electron doesn't automatically mean it's insecure. The Signal developers probably know a lot more about these things, so my client is likely less secure in that regard. Not to mention the fact that you then have to trust another person beside the signal devs.

LoganDark 1 hour ago

Bad headline. Everyone is "serious about protecting your privacy". Even vendors who store your passwords in plaintext say that.

  • vaillancourtmax 1 hour ago

    Privacy is not the same thing as security.

    • LoganDark 1 hour ago

      I understand, but nearly everybody says privacy to mean security, which is one of the reasons this headline is bad.

      Companies even want you to think that them securely holding all your data is the same as it being private to you. That's on purpose.

jgalt212 2 hours ago

Signal is great for sure, but is is really useful when WhatApp (which uses signal under the hood) archives all your conversations?

  • mplanchard 2 hours ago

    Signal the app is not signal the protocol. The latter is what WhatsApp uses. What WhatsApp chooses to do on top of that protocol has no bearing on Signal the app.

    • jgalt212 45 minutes ago

      Well given the app and protocol have the same name, I could hope the mandarins on this site could understand my confusion.

  • internet_points 2 hours ago

    WhatsApp doesn't use Signal under the hood. They use or have used some of the same cryptographic protocols; Whatsapp at some point started using the axolotl protocol developed by Signal. But there is no sharing of messages or infrastructure.