What Hacker News has been building since 2009?
I have compiled 23,935 answers to “What are you working on?” from 14,897 people on https://stillworkingonit.vercel.app/
The # of new Github orgs this month is on track to he the highest of all time (beating last month) according to Bloomberry: https://bloomberry.com/data/github/
I assume the site is German, and has an affinity to German sources? I don't think there is any greater reason beyond a selection bias.
It isn't complete. chessreport.ca doesn't appear, yet satisfies all of the criteria. Whatever mechanism is used clearly primarily triggers on German domains and seems suspiciously absent an enormous number of Canadian domains, just as an example that I personally checked.
Hardware is... Hard, and it costs a whole lot more to scale. Software can be scaled up and down, hardware not so much. You don't want to have to find someone to buy (or throw away more likely) a half-baked idea that's right now only a custom PCB or the build process for a non-tech item.
I get the sentiment, but there's something really nice now about picking a project and just chipping away at it for months until you have something you really like. That was a lot harder outside of work int he past, and now I feel like I can take notes when I have ideas and set an agent to work on it later. I've been learning a lot, and really enjoy thinking about software a step up from the line and module level thinking that used to take up most of my time.
Yeah, I had a similar reaction looking through the directory. Then I started clicking through. Some of those sites are new products from established companies. Others are side projects by people who’ve already built things I recognize.
If this site had been around in 2004, I’d probably have described Facebook as "a directory for Harvard students" and kept scrolling. That’s what I’m curious about: which projects am I scrolling past today that I’ll recognise in a few years?
I believe the answer will be tenacity. It's so easy to start a new project, and so so difficult to keep it going in the right directions for 10 years. The "top of the funnel" for these projects has exploded with AI, but the survival rate will be interesting to watch.
Hi HN, I’m Martin. I built NovumSignals because I was curious what people were launching without making a big announcement. Every day I scan around 100,000 newly observed domains, looking for sites where someone has built a product.
Finding a site is only the first step. I also track what happens afterward: a team publishes pricing, opens up its app, or starts hiring. You see this in Traction section.
One thing I’m still working on is telling a new startup from an existing company launching a product on a fresh domain. If you spot one I’ve classified incorrectly, I’d love to know what gave it away.
This is so cool and so much more useful that a similar setup I created but for monitoring free web-apps people are building these days - which work offline and do not require any login:
Unfortunately, it doesn't. Services actively scrape CT logs to build databases specifically for subdomain enumeration.
There are solutions to keep them out of those databases like a Wildcard TLS certificate but it adds complexity. I would start with putting server-side auth on your frontend bundles and adding some geo-blocking rules.
If they track domains from CT logs and you have a wildcard cert for your subdomains it may help. But the subdomain queries may be still observed on the network or found by crawlers.
CT logs is part of the story. Also track newly registered domains and periodically revisit sites to see what’s changed. I score what I find and add details like what the product does , link to github (with stars), linkedin etc.
Just to imagine, it is about 150 000 domains need to be analyzed daily. Just fraction of that ends in the database.
What Hacker News has been building since 2009? I have compiled 23,935 answers to “What are you working on?” from 14,897 people on https://stillworkingonit.vercel.app/
I wouldn't want to be GitHub's DevOps team right now. The explosion in usage must be nigh-overwhelming.
They aren't even trying to ban spammers. I'll have sympathy for them when they make a modicum of effort.
What makes you think they aren’t trying? Have you been on twitter, YouTube, or Reddit lately? Everyone is trying
The # of new Github orgs this month is on track to he the highest of all time (beating last month) according to Bloomberry: https://bloomberry.com/data/github/
I have a feeling the commit IDs are very soon going to start clashing!
On the flip side it has to be a great time to be a domain registrar. Collecting $10+ a year for hosting two nameserver listings is a pretty sweet gig.
I thought I was running out of interesting ideas, browsing this site shows there isn't anything obvious that's truly useful.
I wonder why is Germany building so many companies.
Tax structure seem to attract a lot of tech startup lately.
Good timezone, to hire global.
Layoffs?
I assume the site is German, and has an affinity to German sources? I don't think there is any greater reason beyond a selection bias.
It isn't complete. chessreport.ca doesn't appear, yet satisfies all of the criteria. Whatever mechanism is used clearly primarily triggers on German domains and seems suspiciously absent an enormous number of Canadian domains, just as an example that I personally checked.
Interesting the ratio of physical hardware products versus software to me, only 94 out of 3,222 in U.S.
Hardware is... Hard, and it costs a whole lot more to scale. Software can be scaled up and down, hardware not so much. You don't want to have to find someone to buy (or throw away more likely) a half-baked idea that's right now only a custom PCB or the build process for a non-tech item.
When everyone can "build" something, nothing "built" matters. It was fun while it lasted, blessed I got to enjoy a niche for as long as I did.
I get the sentiment, but there's something really nice now about picking a project and just chipping away at it for months until you have something you really like. That was a lot harder outside of work int he past, and now I feel like I can take notes when I have ideas and set an agent to work on it later. I've been learning a lot, and really enjoy thinking about software a step up from the line and module level thinking that used to take up most of my time.
This really opened my eyes to the wave of slop that is flooding the internet
I mean I knew this was the case, I just didn't realize the extent yet
Yeah, I had a similar reaction looking through the directory. Then I started clicking through. Some of those sites are new products from established companies. Others are side projects by people who’ve already built things I recognize.
If this site had been around in 2004, I’d probably have described Facebook as "a directory for Harvard students" and kept scrolling. That’s what I’m curious about: which projects am I scrolling past today that I’ll recognise in a few years?
Can an admin explain why this user’s comments keeping getting killed? I see nothing obviously wrong.
Maybe because they are clearly LLM-written
In another comment they identify themselves as "Martin": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50572749
But in their profile they claim to be "Walter": https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=walterschnitzel
So definitely something not completely forthcoming here.
His email contains martin. Maybe his name is Martin Walter. Or Martin W. Doe. Not a good reason to flag.
Iam Martin, and Walter is just the nickname I use online. Sorry for the confusion :/
I believe the answer will be tenacity. It's so easy to start a new project, and so so difficult to keep it going in the right directions for 10 years. The "top of the funnel" for these projects has exploded with AI, but the survival rate will be interesting to watch.
ICANN, Verisign and Charleston Road Registry are laughing all the way to the bank.
Let's Encrypt would be too, if they were smartly capturing surplus value instead of doing that weird anti-capitalist "charity" thing.
steam is like 45 days behind approving new steamworks partner accts n tax info etc , from the rush of sloppers
Hi HN, I’m Martin. I built NovumSignals because I was curious what people were launching without making a big announcement. Every day I scan around 100,000 newly observed domains, looking for sites where someone has built a product.
Finding a site is only the first step. I also track what happens afterward: a team publishes pricing, opens up its app, or starts hiring. You see this in Traction section.
One thing I’m still working on is telling a new startup from an existing company launching a product on a fresh domain. If you spot one I’ve classified incorrectly, I’d love to know what gave it away.
I'm going to take it as a compliment that none of my projects are listed :-)
Though like another person said, I'm sick of buying domains so just using subdomains these days.
This is so cool and so much more useful that a similar setup I created but for monitoring free web-apps people are building these days - which work offline and do not require any login:
https://opentab.nextfive.in/
(Also has a bunch of non-vibe coded faves like Excalibre and photopea)
Would explore yours over the weekend :)
Cool project that will help keep me humble when I think, "my app is groundbreaking!" as it then follows all of these into the slop heap.
Really amazing tool - was surprised my site wasn’t found; published it some weeks ago and no way I could see to submit it.
Reminds me a lot of the days of Altavista and co!
I like the idea, good to see thumbnails in the listing. Goodness, very few made an effort to change the default fonts that Claude picks all the time.
Thanks! Glad you like the thumbnails. Now that you’ve pointed out the fonts, I can’t unsee them either.
This, and text colors being undreadable over hero images is a cherry on top. Slop slop slop.
> text colors being undreadable over hero images
I thought those ones were less slopped than the others. But I also like how every hero text is either punctuated to the 9s:
"Math. AI. Make a difference."
or with a classic claude comma twist.
"The human sleeps, we listen."
(Both made up, but you get the gist)
I put my personal projects under a subdomain of a main address.
I hope that protects me from this public shaming.
Next step: Monitor LetsEncrypt logs for new subdomains.
Unfortunately, it doesn't. Services actively scrape CT logs to build databases specifically for subdomain enumeration.
There are solutions to keep them out of those databases like a Wildcard TLS certificate but it adds complexity. I would start with putting server-side auth on your frontend bundles and adding some geo-blocking rules.
If they track domains from CT logs and you have a wildcard cert for your subdomains it may help. But the subdomain queries may be still observed on the network or found by crawlers.
A better practice is to use longer names like the-best-app-ever.domain to avoid being enumerated via common defaults like "staging," "app," or "dev"
Why would it be more public shaming than productHunt ?
only need to configure access permissions in Cloudflare and the project’s admin backend to solve this.
J'accuse!
Nice job. I’m guessing these are the types of “companies” VC firms get spammed with. Yuck!
Is this showing all new startups or just the ones that are Claude hallucinations?
Pretty likely all non-empty websites whose domains showed up in Certificate Transparency logs.
CT logs is part of the story. Also track newly registered domains and periodically revisit sites to see what’s changed. I score what I find and add details like what the product does , link to github (with stars), linkedin etc. Just to imagine, it is about 150 000 domains need to be analyzed daily. Just fraction of that ends in the database.
Neither of my two initiatives are listed so maybe not.
It looks like an MVP. The number seems quite high, but considering that 250,000–500,000 new domains are registered every day
Now try the same with Certificate Transparency logs!
The mark · of slop.